| |
11/20/08
|
||||||||||||||||
|
|
December
04, 2006 The fundamental dogma of all brands of socialism and communism is that the market economy or capitalism is a system that hurts the vital interests of the immense majority of people for the sole benefit of a small minority of rugged individualists. It condemns the masses to progressing impoverishment. It brings about misery, slavery, oppression, degradation and exploitation of the working men, while it enriches a class of idle and useless parasites. This doctrine was not the work of Karl Marx. It had been developed long before Marx entered the scene. Its most successful propagators were not the Marxian authors, but such men as Carlyle and Ruskin, the British Fabians, the German professors and the American Institutionalists. And it is a very significant fact that the correctness of this dogma was contested only by a few economists who were very soon silenced and barred from access to the universities, the press, the leadership of political parties and, first of all, public office. Public opinion by and large accepted the condemnation of capitalism without any reservation. Socialism But, of course, the practical political conclusions which people drew from this dogma were not uniform. One group declared that there is but one way to wipe out these evils, namely to abolish capitalism entirely. They advocate the substitution of public control of the means of production for private control. They aim at the establishment of what is called socialism, communism, planning, or state capitalism. All these terms signify the same thing. No longer should the consumers, by their buying and abstention from buying, determine what should be produced, in what quantity and of what quality. Henceforth a central authority alone should direct all production activities. Interventionism, Allegedly a Middle-of-the-Road Policy A second group seems to be less radical. They reject socialism no less than capitalism. They recommend a third system, which, as they say, is as far from capitalism as it is from socialism, which as a third system of society's economic organization, stands midway between the two other systems, and while retaining the advantages of both, avoids the disadvantages inherent in each. This third system is known as the system of interventionism. In the terminology of American politics it is often referred to as the middle-of-the-road policy. What makes this third system popular with many people is the particular way they choose to look upon the problems involved. As they see it, two classes, the capitalists and entrepreneurs on the one hand and the wage earners on the other hand, are arguing about the distribution of the yield of capital and entrepreneurial activities. Both parties are claiming the whole cake for themselves. Now, suggest these mediators, let us make peace by splitting the disputed value equally between the two classes. The State as an impartial arbiter should interfere, and should curb the greed of the capitalists and assign a part of the profits to the working classes. Thus it will be possible to dethrone the moloch capitalism without enthroning the moloch of totalitarian socialism. (Read the rest here - click your "back" button to return to The Price of Liberty)
Other articles at the von Mises Institute (There are thousands of them, all free.) Defense
Services on the Free Market Making
Economic Sense The
Trouble with NASA
Ludwig
von Mises Institute The
Free Market, published by the Mises Institute The
Independent Institute Foundation
for Economic Education (FEE) Ayn
Rand Institute Institute
for Humane Studies National
Center for Policy Analysis Reason
Foundation Acton
Institute Future
of Freedom Foundation |
Archives The
Ethics of Liberty The
Idea of a Private Law Society The
Source of Prices Enterprising
Education: Doing Away with the Public School System Why
is Medical Care so Expensive? The
Snare of Government Subsidies How
We Come to Own Ourselves The
Antifederalists Were Right The
Revolutionary War and the Destruction of the Continental The
Fraudulent Tax Globalization:
The Long-Run Big Picture A
Century of War Click
the "back button" to return to The Price of Liberty.)
| ||||||||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||||||||
|
|
