| |
11/20/08
|
||||||||||||||||
|
|
October
23, 2006 In November 2000, Clinton signed a bill passed by Congress that ordered the states to adopt new, more onerous drunk-driving standards or face a loss of highway funds. That's right: the old highway extortion trick. Sure enough, states passed new, tighter laws against Driving Under the Influence, responding as expected to the feds' ransom note. The feds have declared that a blood-alcohol level of 0.08 percent and above is criminal and must be severely punished. The National Restaurant Association is exactly right that this is absurdly low. The overwhelming majority of accidents related to drunk driving involve repeat offenders with blood-alcohol levels twice that high. If a standard of 0.1 doesn't deter them, then a lower one won't either. But there's a more fundamental point. What precisely is being criminalized? Not bad driving. Not destruction of property. Not the taking of human life or reckless endangerment. The crime is having the wrong substance in your blood. Yet it is possible, in fact, to have this substance in your blood, even while driving, and not commit anything like what has been traditionally called a crime. What have we done by permitting government to criminalize the content of our blood instead of actions themselves? We have given it power to make the application of the law arbitrary, capricious, and contingent on the judgment of cops and cop technicians. Indeed, without the government's "Breathalyzer," there is no way to tell for sure if we are breaking the law. (Read the rest here. Click the "back button" to return to The Price of Liberty.)
Other articles at the von Mises Institute (There are thousands of them, all free.) Defense
Services on the Free Market Making
Economic Sense The
Trouble with NASA
Ludwig
von Mises Institute The
Free Market, published by the Mises Institute The
Independent Institute Foundation
for Economic Education (FEE) Ayn
Rand Institute Institute
for Humane Studies National
Center for Policy Analysis Reason
Foundation Acton
Institute Future
of Freedom Foundation |
Archives The
Ethics of Liberty The
Idea of a Private Law Society The
Source of Prices Enterprising
Education: Doing Away with the Public School System Why
is Medical Care so Expensive? The
Snare of Government Subsidies How
We Come to Own Ourselves Is
All-Day Kindergarten An Economic Fix? The
Justice and Prudence of War: Toward A Libertarian Analysis The
Antifederalists Were Right Do
Greedy Spinach Merchants Want To Kill You? The
Revolutionary War and the Destruction of the Continental The
Fraudulent Tax Click
the "back button" to return to The Price of Liberty.)
| ||||||||||||||
|
Submit
Feedback
|
|
||||||||||||||
|
|
