Libertarian Commentary on The News by Nathan A. Barton - Price of Liberty
No human being has the right -- under any circumstances -- to initiate force against another human being, nor to threaten or delegate its initiation. The Zero Aggression Principle
11/20/08
Libertarian Commentary on The News
By Nathan A. Barton © 2006


Mission Statement
Revised 8.04.04
 
Editorial Policy Revised 3.19.04
 
See Reader's
Feedback
 
Reader's Forum
 
Looking for Health NEW
 
Commentary
on the News
 
Return to Home Page

October 30, 2006

Libertarian Commentary on the News, 22-27 October, 2006
Fortunately, election season is rapidly running its course, and I for one am glad. Sadly, in our series of world-wide fronts, there is no season for the ending of strife, either political or physical or cultural, and I (again, speaking for myself) am tired of it. At the same time, some things (such as the mess in Canaan) have almost dropped out of the news this week - they all need a rest anyway, as do we. But for the first time in a while, I have a number of free speech and school stories to bring to your attention.

Free Speech
US, Russia slide in press freedom survey
Star [Malaysia]
"Restrictions on civil liberties due to the 'war on terrorism' have undermined media freedom in the United States and Russia over the past year, journalists' rights group Reporters Without Borders (RSF) said. RSF's 2006 Worldwide Press Freedom Index released on Tuesday, a survey of censorship, intimidation and violence against journalists, found Finland, Iceland, Ireland and the Netherlands the most media-friendly. North Korea was last again."

I suppose that there was some symbolism involved in RRND selecting a Malaysian paper for this story, which appeared many places, but just wasn't considered news by most. Malaysia, of course, is hardly a sterling example of a country promoting freedom and liberty, of the press or anything else. And the key here is "intimidation" - apparently a cop giving a baleful look to a gossip reporter as she double-parks counts. Press mavens are unlikely to "enjoy" the benefits of a habeas-corpus-free court system but continue to exercise their freedom of speech in this country to attack other freedoms, such as that of religion and of our right to defend ourselves.

Free Speech
Total Information Lives Again
SpaceWar.Com
The new U.S. intelligence czar is developing a computer system capable of data-mining huge amounts of information about everyday events to discern patterns that look like terrorist planning. The technology is reminiscent of the axed Total Information Awareness program. Civil liberties and privacy advocates criticized the effort, called Tangram, which is being developed by contractors working for the Office of the Director of National Intelligence.

As a number of us predicted, the end of TIA was really not the end: and here it is, like a year-old reanimated corpse in time for All Hallows' Eve. Who has the wooden stake?

Mama's Note: Everyone who objects to this kind of snooping needs to get serious about not putting personal information out where it can be easily snagged. Encrypt ALL email, quit supporting fractional reserve banking and use anonymous payment systems where possible, or cash. There are thousands of things you can do to preserve your privacy and increase your liberty. See "Backwoods Home" for great ideas and entertaining articles.

Free Speech
FL: School newspaper censored
St. Petersburg Times
"There are few issues in American education as widely discussed as the achievement gap, the racial divide that separates the academic performance of white and minority students. But not at Hillsborough High School, where the principal pulled an article detailing the school's achievement gap from the student newspaper. ... 'If it's something that has a potential to hurt students' self-esteem, then I have an obligation not to let that happen,' he said. 'I don't think it's the job of the school newspaper to embarrass the students.' Editor-in-chief Emily Matras wrote the article, which included a chart breaking down Hillsborough High student test scores as reported on the state Education Department's Web site. She wanted to let classmates know what the school administration was doing to address the divide, including a schoolwide reading push. Instead, she learned this lesson: 'High school is not the real world,' said Matras, a junior."

"Self-esteem outweighs freedom of speech and the press." (13th Article of the Bill of Rights, apparently, at least the HSH-FL version.) But I have to tell you, Emily, your GRTF-school IS the real world, where tyrants (principals and superintendents and school boards in schools; a whole slew of thugs outside) tell you that what is written on a 219-year-old piece of paper means nothing.

Mama's Note: Indeed! Sending children to government school and then protesting what happens there is like tossing the kids into a shark tank, then being angry when they are attacked by the sharks! It's a whole lot easier to keep the kids out of the tank than to fight with the sharks.

Free Speech
US court takes up COPA dispute
eSchool News
"Eight years after Congress tried to criminalize the online posting of material deemed 'harmful to children,' free-speech advocates and web site publishers took their challenge of the law to trial Oct. 23. Salon.com, Nerve.com, and other plaintiffs backed by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) are suing over the 1998 Child Online Protection Act (COPA). They believe the law could restrict legitimate material they publish online -- exposing them to fines or even jail time."

Of course, if Congress follows Hillsborough's definition of "harmful to children" we all should be in this suit.

Mama's Note: Without a realistic definition of what is "harmful to children," (not to mention responsible parenting) we'll all be in jail under this insanity.

GRTF (Government Ruined, Theft Funded) Schools:
All homework and no play ...
Tennessean
"Imagine, after a full day's work, you come home and put in a couple more hours' worth. Now translate that to school. It's what some students face every day. 'I hate homework,' said Hillsboro High freshman Meagan Beckham, who has several honors classes in her schedule and complains that take-home assignments take away from her free time. 'I'd much rather have less homework or no homework.' Of course, it's not called homework for being quick and easy. 'Starting in middle school, homework was incredibly discouraging for my children because they'd already gone to school for a long day and they came home with huge amounts of homework that took them into late at night,' said Wendy Kurland, mother of two college students and director of the Homework Hotline, a nonprofit that serves 28 counties in the area. 'As grownups, if we had jobs like that, we would quit.'"

Closely tied to the last two articles, we see this little whiny piece of tripe: sure to be taken seriously by the liberal segment of the population. And sorry, Wendy, I've been working in the "grownup" world for 33 years now, and ALL my jobs seem to have been like that. The only "40-hour" jobs around are menial ones (clerking at convenience stores, flipping burgers, or similar things) or union-government jobs at the lower levels and pay scale.

Mama's Note: Of course, if all of the stupid crap was taken out of the average "school" curriculum and homework, there wouldn't be much to complain about - and children might actually learn something useful once in a while. The answer isn't less homework, it's getting rid of the garbage at every level in the education of our children. Get them OUT of the government schools if you care about this at all.

GRTF Schools:
British pupils "cannot locate UK"
BBC News [UK]
"One in five young British children cannot find the UK on a map of the world, a magazine's research suggests. National Geographic Kids said it also found fewer than two thirds of children were able to correctly locate the US. The magazine, which questioned more than 1,000 six to 14-year-olds, said it discovered several children in London did not to know it was the UK capital. But the National Association of Schoolmasters Union of Women Teachers branded the findings as 'nonsense.'"

Now, if you want to really be scared, ask the "grownups" these questions. Notice the immediate (and correct) reaction of the union. Of course, this is nonsense - but what else can we expect from the pitiful excuse for schools where self-esteem is more important than truth, and limited work-hours more critical than actually learning anything good.

GRTF Schools:
GA: Chilly schools won't turn on heat
WSBTV News
"Students and teachers at one DeKalb County school say the freezing temperatures we saw overnight made it awful chilly inside their classrooms. They can't understand why the school system wouldn't turn on the heat. The school system says no matter [how] cold it gets, it's their practice to turn the heat on in all schools on October 30. ... A DeKalb County Schools spokesperson told Channel 2 that's not entirely true. We found out the school district doesn't turn on the heat system-wide until October 30. And once the heat is on for all schools -- it stays on. ... The school system did tell us that principals can petition to have their heat turned on before October 30. But if it warms up, the heat won't be turned off -- so many principals choose to wait." [Editor's note: Like the fuel used on one unnecessary "over-warm" day wouldn't cost more than installing some FRIGGIN' THERMOSTATS? - TLK]

Oh, dear. My heart bleeds. If this is such a big deal, perhaps the students and teachers should all go to the private sector, where the school owners and customers can dictate when the heat is turned on and off.

Mama's Note: Ah yes, the "one size" fits nobody of government operations. It's been a LONG time since I went to school, of course, but one thing I remember was how HOT it always was and how much I enjoyed recess or a change of classes, simply because I could get out into the fresh air. I remember school rooms always smelling bad in cold weather, full of sweaty bodies, warm bologna sandwiches, chalk, and assorted other smells - many of which I never identified.

GRTF Schools:
Money starts flowing in teacher bonus program
Arizona Republic
"In the closing weeks of the fall campaign, the Bush administration is handing out money for teachers who raise student test scores, the first federal effort to reward classroom performance with bonuses. The 16 grants total $42 million and cover many states. The government has announced only the first grants, $5.5 million for Ohio, where Education Secretary Margaret Spellings was to make the presentation today. The department will release the remaining grants in the weeks leading up to the Nov. 7 election in which a reeling Republican Party is eager for good news. In Ohio, the GOP can trumpet the news of money for the state education department. The $5.5 million will go to schools in Cleveland, Cincinnati, Columbus and Toledo."

More theft-by-government, of course. Illegal federal expenditures to welfare schools, increasing previous welfare payments in exchange for meeting really meaningless goals.

GRTF Schools:
Feds ease limits on same sex schools
Breitbart
"For the first time in a generation, public schools have won broad freedom to teach boys and girls separately, stirring a new debate about equality in the classroom. The Education Department on Tuesday announced rules that will make it easier to create single-sex classes or schools, a plan that's been expected for almost three years. The move comes as the value of same-sex education is in doubt. Research shows mixed results, as even the department's own review says. Yet Education Secretary Margaret Spellings said more parents deserve to have the option. The push began not with the White House, but rather with female senators of both parties."

A "solution" for a "problem" that should have never existed, if not for government interference in education in the first place. And as you can see, it is being challenged as well, but more on political grounds than anything substantial. Parents, get your kids out of these schools!

GRTF Schools:
Texas District Disavows Anti-Killer Training
Denver Post
A suburban Fort Worth school district that has been teaching students to attack a gunman if he invades a classroom said Wednesday that it has halted the program. The district will continue to train students in how to respond to life-threatening situations but no longer will show them how to take down an attacker, spokesman Richard Crummel said.

As the trainer said, this completely invalidates the entire program: kids aren't allowed to defend themselves and each other in this school, clearly, even if it is only with pencils and schoolbooks. It is time to arm teachers - except that few of them are willing to be armed. So it is past time to GET YOUR KIDS OUT!!!! (Thanks to Tim for this article.)

Home Front:
Poll: Most Americans say no one winning in Iraq
CNN
"One in five Americans believes the United States is winning the war in Iraq, according to a poll. The number has dropped by half since December. About the same number -- 18 percent -- believe insurgents are winning. But the majority, 60 percent, say no one is winning in Iraq. The poll of 1,013 adult Americans interviewed by telephone found two-thirds -- 64 percent -- of those polled oppose the war in Iraq."

Like all polls, this means little. Notice that seldom do we ever hear about polls asking questions like "Is the earth round?" or "Which way is west?" or "What is the square root of twenty-five?" Why? Because we'd quickly find out that far too many people are exhibiting all the signs of intelligence of an eggplant - a rotten eggplant, at that. Compare this to the Brit poll this week that found that very few students could even find the British Isles on a map of the world, and then ask yourself, is "democracy" worth it?

Home Front:
NY: Activists take ferry in free speech protest
Staten Island Advance
"A group of nearly 100 antiwar activists, most wearing black T-shirts with the legend 'We Will Not Be Silent,' boarded two evening ferryboats yesterday to exercise their right to free speech. The event, which brought together several antiwar groups from around the city, was organized in response to an Oct. 9 incident on the Staten Island Ferry. ... Stephanie Schwartz, a Hunter College student from Manhattan, said she was warned by Coast Guard security officers not to wear the shirt -- with Arabic writing and the English translation -- on the boat anymore, due to security concerns. ... Coast Guard spokesman Chief Tom Sperduto said he was aware of Ms. Schwartz's claim, but said the Coast Guard personnel on the boat that day denied telling Ms. Schwartz that she shouldn't wear the shirt."

A baffling little protest, which makes no sense at all - both as to why the USCG personnel would care what a tee-shirt said (in New York? Please!) and as to why this would merit a protest - except that any press coverage is worth whatever bizarre behavior people can come up with, apparently.

Mama's Note: I don't know anything about New York, but even here in Wyoming a government school child can be sent home or punished if they have a shirt or anything showing a picture or any likeness of a gun! Nobody has ever explained just how the picture of something can harm anyone, but that certainly never stopped a "zero tolerance" witch hunt yet.

Home Front:
Radical Islam finds US "sterile ground"
Christian Science Monitor
"The Islamist radicalism that inspired young Muslims to attack their own countries -- in London, Madrid, and Bali -- has not yielded similar incidents in the United States, at least so far. 'Home-grown' terror cells remain a concern of US law officers, who cite several disrupted plots since 9/11. But the suspects' unsophisticated planning and tiny numbers have led some security analysts to conclude that America, for all its imperfections, is not fertile ground for producing jihadist terrorists. To understand why, experts point to people like Omar Jaber, an AmeriCorps volunteer; Tarek Radwan, a human rights advocate; and Hala Kotb, a consultant on Middle East affairs. They are the face of young Muslim-Americans today -- educated, motivated, and integrated into society -- and their voices help explain how the nation's history of inclusion has helped to defuse sparks of Islamist extremism."

Steve Trinward (RRND/FND) points out correctly that this weakens the basis of the nastiness being promoted and performed by the Bush Administration. But the real point here is to ask WHY the US is less fertile ground: inclusion may be part of it, but France, the Netherlands, Britain have all demonstrated this "inclusiveness" and yet they have problems. While I don't know the answer, I can certain suggest one or more: first, despite significant degradation of our freedoms, we ARE significantly more free across the spectrum than old Europe or Africa or Asia. Second, we are more religious than Europe, by a long shot - but mostly made up of religious groups that DO encourage human dignity and freedom and peace, and to put it bluntly and literally, the right of people to go to Hell in their own way if they so choose.

Home Front:
Older recruits fill out military
Boston Globe
"Kevin Adams, 39, has a white-collar job, a girlfriend, a cat, and a home in Marblehead. For exercise, he likes to sail. At 4 a.m. tomorrow , he will leave all that behind and head off for basic training at Fort Benning, Ga., where a drill sergeant will order him to do push-ups, sit-ups, and run with recruits half his age. Adams has signed up for a six-year stint in the Army Reserve. That commitment could mean deployment to Iraq, where Reserve and National Guard soldiers are an integral part of the occupying force, and where recent US fatalities have made October one of the deadliest months of the war."

Problems with recruiting and retention have, of course, led to a changed situation that should have been adopted decades ago. While youth is critical in many military jobs, there are still many more jobs where age is no barrier. Fortunately, the National Guard and Reserve, unlike the Active Force, are not so tied to the beloved concept of "up or out" and older "junior" soldiers and officers are accepted.

Mama's Note: No standing army is compatible with liberty and justice. The true "militia" of able bodied men and women of every age need to train together to defend their homes and families.

Home Front:
Whites appealed Katrina insurance more
Associated Press
"Though poor and minority neighborhoods suffered the brunt of Katrina's fury, residents living in white neighborhoods have been three times as likely as homeowners in black neighborhoods to seek state help in resolving insurance disputes, according to an Associated Press computer analysis. The analysis of Louisiana's insurance complaints settled in the first year after Katrina highlights a cold, hard truth exposed by Katrina's winds and waters: People of color and modest means, who often need the most help after a major disaster, are disconnected from the government institutions that can provide it, or distrustful of those in power. The Littles and the Kitchens watched helplessly as Hurricane Katrina battered their homes. Both families waited patiently for an insurance adjuster to settle their losses. And both were sorely disappointed with the outcome. Then, their paths diverged."

Statistics don't tell lies, but liars use statistics. All these conclusions are strictly subjective - the same statistics could be used to demonstrate exactly the opposite, but that wouldn't be acceptable to the AP's media outlets. It also shows some preconceptions: that only the government can provide help, that people have to go to the government, and that people even should go to the government.

Mama's Note: And none of this demonstrated in the least that anyone had LESS OPPORTUNITY to appeal or beg for help, so what is the point anyway? More race baiting to keep us fighting one another.

Home Front:
OH: Town holds Halloween sex offender roundup
Fox News
"Officials in Lima want to make sure sex offenders have no contact with children out trick-or-treating. During the two hours Saturday afternoon when kids will be out collecting candy, people convicted of sex crimes will be rounded up and kept under supervision. Project director Jim Wingate with the Allen County Sex Offender Risk Reduction Court said children going to strangers' houses might be vulnerable. He said sex offenders who don't show up will be jailed. Bill Kluge, a Lima defense attorney called the plan 'ludicrous,' noting that the sex offenders wear ankle monitors, so authorities already know where they are. Approximately 40 sex offenders will be affected by the trick-or-treating roundup, according to the Lima News."

Of course, this is basically what the entire US Government did in the case of the Iraqi invasion, isn't it? Where are the parents? (Probably getting ready for their debauched "Halloween" parties, I guess, based on the ads I keep seeing for "adult" costumes and decorations.) Of course, this is Ohio, one of the more tyrannical states in this disunited union.

Mama's Note: This could be applied to a great many things, of course... How soon before they begin to "round up" all gun owners after every school shooting, or all smokers, or all homeschoolers... ??? Those can be, and many times are, considered "crimes" too.

Home Front:
Drug raid yields Los Alamos documents
Kankakee Daily Journal
"A drug bust at a trailer park in New Mexico turned up what appeared to be classified documents taken from the Los Alamos nuclear weapons laboratory, authorities said Tuesday. Local police found the documents while arresting a man suspected of domestic violence and dealing methamphetamine from his mobile home, said Sgt. Chuck Ney of the Los Alamos, N.M., Municipal Police Department."

Hmmm. Couldn't make enough selling poor-quality meth and was expanding? Or does the guy work at Los Alamos and need the meth himself to keep up with his work, and found a market for his better-quality meth?

Home Front:
Some cities will vote on Iraq withdrawal
Rockford Register Star
"For a week and a half, 81-year-old Hamer Lacey hauled his broken back and clipboard to a Gloucester grocery store parking lot, looking for signatures of residents who shared his fervent opposition to the war in Iraq. His work over the summer put Gloucester among 139 Massachusetts communities where residents will vote next month on a nonbinding question that calls for an immediate U.S. withdrawal from Iraq. Voters in several cities in Wisconsin and Illinois will consider a similar question."

A dedicated man - although for the life of me I can not see why he (or the others doing this) is wasting his time getting towns to vote on something like this, when such things were abdicated to the feds centuries ago. (I suppose it is a good sign that some people, even the elderly, are now fed up with that fact, however.) Like the next group, I applaud his courage and work.

Home Front:
Troops petition for Iraq withdrawal
Washington Post
"More than 100 U.S. service members have signed a rare appeal urging Congress to support the 'prompt withdrawal' of all American troops and bases from Iraq, organizers said yesterday. 'Staying in Iraq will not work and is not worth the price. It is time for U.S. troops to come home,' reads the statement of a small grass-roots group of active-duty military personnel and reservists that says it aims to give U.S. military members a voice in Iraq war policy. ... The unusual appeal -- the first of its kind in the Iraq war, organizers say -- makes use of a legal protection afforded by the Military Whistle-Blower Protection Act, which provides that members of the military, acting in their capacity as citizens, can send a protected communication to Congress without reprisal."

100 out of a million - I could probably get that many in Fort Riley alone, because I know how soldiers like to gripe - and none of us really savor the idea of getting killed in Iraq, or even having to spend 12 or 16 months in 120F heat and dust and danger. And it is essentially meaningless, when you consider that just the Army generates at least a hundred "Congressionals" every workday: a letter sent by a soldier to a Congressman complaining about everything from lost pay to failed promotions to poor conditions in the barracks to the way their wife (or husband) was snubbed in the PX. But I do applaud their moral courage in doing this.

Iraqi Front
Iraq: 86 US dead in October
Washington Post
"At least 15 Iraqi police recruits were killed Sunday when two buses taking them to Baghdad were ambushed by insurgents north of the capital, a local police official said. Twenty-five recruits were injured in the attack, and 20 others were kidnapped, he said. On Sunday and Monday, the U.S. Military announced the deaths of seven soldiers and a Marine, bringing the number of U.S. Troops killed in Iraq this month to 86 -- the fifth-highest total in any single month since the war began. The only higher monthly tolls were 137 in November 2004, 135 in April 2004, 106 in January 2005, and 96 in October, 2005. Attacks against U.S. and Iraqi forces in Baghdad have increased more than 40 percent since midsummer, U.S. Military officials say."

Continued US and Iraqi casualties have made this a very bloody month indeed.

Iraqi Front
US diplomat apologizes for candor
MSNBC
"A senior U.S. diplomat apologized Sunday night for saying U.S. policy in Iraq displayed 'arrogance' and 'stupidity.' A day after his remarks in an interview were broadcast by the pan-Arab satellite channel Al-Jazeera, Alberto Fernandez issued a written apology through the State Department press office. 'Upon reading the transcript of my appearance on Al-Jazeera, I realized that I seriously misspoke by using the phrase 'there has been arrogance and stupidity' by the U.S. in Iraq,' said Fernandez, director of public diplomacy in State's Bureau of Near Eastern Affairs."

Even though he had to back water, at least, for once, a diplomat spoke the truth.

Iraqi Front
Corrupt arms deals cost Iraq $800 million
Stevens Point Journal
"Iraq's former finance minister alleged in a U.S. television report aired Sunday that up to $800 million meant to equip the Iraqi army had been stolen from the government by former officials through fraudulent arms deals. The former minister Ali Allawi told CBS' '60 Minutes' that $1.2 billion had been allocated from the Iraqi treasury to the defense ministry to buy new weapons. About $400 million was spent on outdated equipment, while the rest of the money was simply stolen, he said."

I don't know whether to believe Allawi or not - he is as corrupt as anyone in the Iraqi government and has always had his own agenda. But I have no doubt that millions, or even billions, have been stolen, as can be expected in any third-world (and most first-world) countries.

Iraqi Front
White House says Iraqis can be pushed only so far
USA Today
"The White House said Monday that it is working with the Iraqi leadership to end religious violence -- but it cautioned against pushing too hard on the fragile government. White House spokesman Tony Snow said it would be counterproductive to threaten to withdraw U.S. forces if goals aren't reached. 'We're not in the business of issuing ultimatums,' Snow said. Snow made the remarks amid growing concerns that Iraq's government is not taking action to reach a political consensus that would disarm private militias blamed for much of the violence."

No kidding? Snow's remarks are as silly as those people who make stupid comments about Iraqis reaching "political consensus" on anything at all.

Korean Front
North Korea said to be willing to talk
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
"North Korea is amenable to returning to international nuclear talks if the U.S. shows a willingness to resolve a dispute over the North's alleged counterfeiting and money laundering, a South Korean lawmaker said Monday. A Japanese legislator, meanwhile, said a top Chinese official who recently visited Pyongyang indicated China was not optimistic that North Korea will end its nuclear program or reenter disarmament talks soon."

I understand that the counterfeiting is hardly "alleged" - having been proven in court multiple times and being an open secret on the peninsula. And of course, all governments engage in some form of money laundering. And it is hardly a surprise that NK is willing to talk - that is the only way they will get more freebies from long-suffering western taxpayers, of course.

North American Union:
Mexico extradited 50 fugitives to US
Sheboygan Press
"Mexico has extradited a record 50 fugitives to the United States this year, including several alleged drug traffickers, murders and rapists, U.S. Ambassador Tony Garza announced Tuesday. Garza said the extraditions showed that Mexico is no longer a haven for U.S. criminals. 'Fugitives allegedly committed crimes in the United States and thought they would enjoy free and unfettered lives south of the border,' Garza said in a statement."

Fifty is a record? A pretty poor one, then. I would expect the "routine" extradition to be several thousand a year, given the number of expatriates living in each country. Shucks, during the War Between the States there were more "extraditions" between Mexico and Texas than fifty a year.

North American Union:
Poll: Americans for more border cops, not a fence
CNN
"Although a majority of Americans support increasing the number of Border Patrol agents along the U.S.-Mexico border, most do not support building a 700-mile fence along the border, according to a CNN poll released Wednesday. Seventy-four percent of 1,013 poll respondents said they would be in favor of more U.S. agents along the border. But only 45 percent said they wanted a border fence built, according to the survey conducted by Opinion Research Corp. on behalf of CNN. And while 58 percent said they would support large fines on employers who hire illegal immigrants, 54 percent said they would oppose jail terms for those employers."

About the only thing this poll shows is that those groups and power brokers opposed to limiting border crossings with a fence have done a very good job of demonizing the idea - making the thing sound like a new Berlin Wall. As I comment elsewhere, polls show the ignorance and inability of people to reason - and the disparity in the questions on fines versus jail demonstrate that.

Politics 2006 and Beyond:
AZ: High court allows new voter ID law
Los Angeles Times
"The Supreme Court cleared the way Friday for Arizona to enforce a new rule for next month's election that requires most voters to show proof of identification before casting a ballot. In an unsigned and apparently unanimous opinion, the justices reversed a ruling by the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco that had blocked the Arizona law from taking effect this year. The justices emphasized that they were not ruling on the still-pending constitutional challenge to the law. They also noted that the law included some exceptions for eligible voters without photo identification. Nonetheless, Friday's order is likely to be seen as a benefit for Republican candidates and a setback for Democrats."

The only reason that this law could be viewed as "favoring" one political party over another is if one political party has (or expects) to benefit from people breaking the law and voting illegally: requiring an ID to vote is far more justifiable than requiring an ID to buy cigarettes or alcohol, yet one party consistently supports one but not the other - it is, indeed, the hit dog that barks.

Politics 2006 and Beyond:
NY: Opponent lauds Clinton ... for president
Gainesville Sun
"Republican U.S. Senate candidate John Spencer said Sunday that his rival Hillary Rodham Clinton would make a 'tremendous' presidential candidate if she chose to run in 2008 and criticized Americans who say they hate her. ... 'From a Republican point of view, maybe she would be an excellent candidate because we can beat her,' Spencer later told reporters. Clinton's presumed national ambitions took center stage in the early moments of the forum, but she refused to disclose her plans for 2008, saying she had not made up her mind. Yet, she also refused to say whether she would commit to serving another six-year term in the Senate."

Shades of Lady Bird Johnson - she wanted to LBJ out from under foot, so she got him to run for the legislature.

Mama's Note: How cute and coy... as if she's not plotting day and night for the chance to occupy the dictator's chair! Just imagine how much fun we'll have if she's given the chance! She'd fill the cabinet with people like Janet Reno in a heartbeat. She'd give or do ANYTHING for the chance to be Empress of the world - dictator. Bet on it.

Politics 2006 and Beyond:
Electronic voting machines could skew elections
ABC News
"Cheryl Kagan, a former Maryland Democratic legislator, was shocked when she opened her mail Wednesday morning. Inside, she discovered three computer discs. With them was an anonymous letter saying the discs contained the secret source code for vote-counting that could be used to alter the votes cast through Maryland's new electronic voting machines. 'My understanding is that with these disks a malicious person could skew the outcome of an election,' Kagan said. Diebold, the company that makes the voting machines, told ABC News, 'These discs do not alter the security of the Diebold touch-screen system in any way,' because election workers can set their own passwords. But ABC News has obtained an independent report commissioned by the state of Maryland and conducted by Science Applications International Corporation revealing that the original Diebold factory passwords are still being used on many voting machines."

We are hearing more, earlier, about the potential problems with electronic voting - my family and I are casting old-fashioned paper ballots, even if we are mailing them in. But really, this just gives a different way to steal elections, not (as some imply) that elections were once honest and now are not.

Mama's Note: A vote not cast can't be "stolen" or changed. I will never again vote for any candidates for political office, only AGAINST the various taxes and other freedom destroying "laws." If I ever get a chance to vote FOR a repeal of anything, I'll be first in line... but I'm not going to lend any legitimacy to the scam of electoral politics.

Politics 2006 and Beyond:
Chicago voter database hacked
ABC News
"As if there weren't enough concerns about the integrity of the vote, a nonpartisan civic organization today claimed it had hacked into the voter database for the 1.35 million voters in the city of Chicago. Bob Wilson, an official with the Illinois Ballot Integrity Project -- which bills itself as a not-for-profit civic organization dedicated to the correction of election system deficiencies -- tells ABC News that last week his organization hacked the database, which contains detailed information about hundreds of thousands of Chicago voters, including their Social Security numbers, and dates of birth. 'It was a serious identity theft problem, but also a problem that could potentially create problems with the election,' Wilson said. A nefarious hacker could have changed every voter's status from active to inactive, which would have prevented them from voting, he said."

Gee - wouldn't that be kind of like going through the obituary columns? Chicago has always been known as one of the cities with the most generous of franchise - where you can keep voting for years and years after you're in the ground. Sadly, until something like that nasty little scenario DOES happen, this will be a continuing problem. (Of course, a truly "nefarious" hacker would simply allow the people to vote, but record what HE wanted them to vote regardless of what they did on the ballot, and would anyone ever really notice the difference? Especially in Chicago?) (Several detailed studies have concluded that the old Mayor Daley's political machine bought the 1960 election for JFK by a very good turnout from what would today be classified as a "disadvantaged minority" - the "life-challenged" climbing from their 4x8 plots to cast their ballots.)

Politics 2006 and Beyond:
Fox appears in campaign ads; Limbaugh mocks
People
"Michael J. Fox, who suffers from Parkinson's disease, appears in a TV ad for a Senate candidate who supports stem-cell research, and the severe shaking and stiffness associated with the disease are evident in his movements. But conservative [sic] radio host Rush Limbaugh has accused the actor of exaggerating his symptoms for the camera. Commenting on Fox's commercial for Missouri Senate challenger Claire McCaskill, Limbaugh said on his syndicated radio program Tuesday, 'He is moving around and shaking, and it is purely an act.' ... Parkinson's is a chronic, progressive disorder of the central nervous system that renders patients increasingly unable to control their movements.

As I suspected, as soon as I read and heard the stories about Fox's appearance and Limbaugh's story, most places would not report what Fox later admitted (confirming what Limbaugh had speculated about) - Fox either increases or goes off his medication in order to let his symptoms reappear when going to testify before legislative committees, and did so in order to make this advertisement. Given that he has medication that does allow him to control his movements, and voluntarily changed the dosage for the sole purpose of making a statement, it was indeed "purely an act." If someone did something like this before an interview to determine their eligibility for a disability pension or some similar action, what they did would be rightly considered fraud and deception. But since Michael J. Fox just wants to steal more money from the taxpayer, I guess it isn't. And people have the gall to blame Limbaugh? Please. Sadly, too many people would rather vent their hatred of Rush Limbaugh than recognize that Fox is even more of an enemy of liberty than Limbaugh is.

Mama's Note: The pot calling the kettle black. A pox on both of them.

Politics 2006 and Beyond:
TN: GOP pulls anti-Ford ad
Tennessean
"A controversial ad by the Republican National Committee -- that some said was tinged with racist overtones -- is no longer running, Ken Mehlman, RNC chairman told CNN today. The campaigns of U.S. Senate candidate Republican Bob Corker, which the commercial was seeking to help, and rival Democrat Harold Ford Jr. had both called for the ad to be pulled. Corker's camp called it 'tacky' and 'over the top.' The commercial, which began airing last Friday, attacked Ford's liberal votes and his attendance at a Playboy Super Bowl party last year. One character in the ad, a scantily clad blonde woman, tells viewers she partied with Harold and later coos, 'Harold, call me.'" [FND editor's note: The mud is getting deeper and thicker in this race, with still a couple weeks to go. Corker currently leads by a point or two, but the aftereffects of this slimeball ad could cost him dearly - SAT]

I've not seen the ad, but I heard it several times, and while nasty, I'd hardly call it slimeball - how can you insult a man like Harold Ford Jr.? And wouldn't it be more racist if it were a black prostitute propositioning him? Politics is already a dirty business, especially in Tennessee, and the Ford family is the poster child for this - telling the truth in a disgusting but attention-getting way is hardly making it dirtier.

Politics 2006 and Beyond:
PA: Santorum in fight for political future
San Francisco Chronicle
"There is probably no one the left would rather see defeated this November than Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum. The two-term Republican is a reliable ally of President Bush on matters from Iraq to confirming judges. He is a religious conservative who has spoken out against abortions, gay unions and contraception. He is a liaison to the business community and a consistent vote against environmental regulation. He is No. 3 in the GOP's Senate hierarchy. By most measures, he is the most vulnerable incumbent in the Senate. With just more than two weeks remaining before election day, Democrat Bob Casey Jr. leads Santorum in surveys by anywhere from 5 to 13 percentage points. Democrats regard Santorum's seat as the surest bet of the six GOP seats they need to win a Senate majority."

As with the mainstream media's review of McCain below, this leaves a lot to be desired as an accurate and unbiased report. Oh, for the chance to vote for "none of the above!"

Politics 2006 and Beyond:
McCain hawkish, and lonely, on Iraq
Boston Globe
"As Senator John McCain travels the nation on behalf of Republican candidates, his proposal to send tens of thousands of additional US troops to Iraq is making things awkward for some of the congressional candidates he's campaigning for. His stance is also shaping the early stages of the 2008 presidential campaign. As public support for the war dwindles, it is hard to find any Republican candidates who publicly agree with McCain, an Arizona Republican who is among the party's brightest hopes for the presidency in 2008. While staunch military supporters such as Virginia's Republican senators, John W. Warner and George Allen, have begun to suggest a change of course in Iraq with fewer US troops, McCain's proposal to add troops has distanced him from the mainstream of his party."

The Globe, of course, is only reflecting the mainstream media in calling McCain one of the GOP's "brightest hopes" - the man has long since left the GOP's conservative and mainstream wings, and has more in common with Chaffee and such ilk than with Goldwater's proto-libertarianism. His hawkishness is carefully calculated to offset his liberalism.

Mama's Note: Oh, what a campaign that would be. Queen Hillary on the left, and Rambo McCain on the right... with all of us caught in the middle. Now, if the Libertarians ran Ron Paul, things could get interesting... but you know that's not going to happen, and I wouldn't wish that on Ron for anything.

Politics 2006 and Beyond:
Rising star Obama weighs White House run
Rocky Mountain News
"Sen. Barack Obama acknowledged Sunday he was considering a run for president in 2008, backing off previous statements that he would not do so. The Illinois Democrat said he could no longer stand by the statements he made after his 2004 election and earlier this year that he would serve a full six-year term in Congress. He said he would not make a decision until after the Nov. 7 elections."

Of course Obama is now "presidential timber" - he just announced that he is breaking his pledge to serve. Just another thug.

Mama's Note: Somehow, I just don't think this guy is a viable candidate, whatever his integrity. Every time I hear or see that last name I have to think hard about who he is... and it always sounds weird - like an African dictator or something.

Politics 2006 and Beyond:
GOP losses could spark partisan warfare
Zanesville Times Recorder
"The White House is bracing for guerrilla warfare on the homefront politically if Republicans lose control of the House, the Senate or both -- and with it, the president's ability to shape and dominate the national agenda. Republicans are battling to keep control of Congress. But polls and analysts in both parties increasingly suggest Democrats will capture the House and possibly the Senate on Election Day Nov. 7."

"Partisan warfare" - does that mean Democratic suicide-bombers blowing themselves up outside "conservative" churches or Young Republican assembly places, while GOP death squads mow down rubber-chicken-eaters at Jefferson-Jackson Day banquets? One can only hope.

Politics 2006 and Beyond: (and War on Some Drugs)
CO: Pot issue's fate at polls hazy
Denver Post
"If Amendment 44 passes Nov. 7, Colorado could become the first state where voters have approved marijuana for recreational use. Safer Alternative for Enjoyable Recreation launched the campaign to legalize pot after a successful initiative in Denver last year. 'Law enforcement should not have to worry about a person smoking a joint in their own house,' said Mason Tvert, SAFER's campaign director. But not everyone agrees with Tvert and his group, who promote marijuana as a healthier and safer alternative to alcohol use. ... Opponents and supporters point to a 9News-sponsored poll from Sept. 28 that shows 29 percent of voters approve of the initiative while 36 percent would vote no. Thirty-five percent indicated they were undecided."

This is clearly a much different issue than the medical marijuana issue on the ballot elsewhere, and passed in many places. One might suspect that the big splashy bust made in Northern Colorado this week (see "War on Some Drugs" section below) might be part of an effort to influence voters on this measure.

Politics 2006 and Beyond: (and War on Some Drugs)
SD: State will decide on medical marijuana
Sioux Falls Argus Leader
"About three times a day, Valerie Hannah uses the only drug she says gives her relief from constant pain. But she can't go to the drugstore to get it, because marijuana is illegal. That's why the Deerfield resident is advocating the medical marijuana measure on the Nov. 7 ballot. 'I think what this measure would do would protect people like me,' said Hannah, 42. If voters approve Initiated Measure 4, South Dakota would join 11 other states that allow some patients to grow and smoke marijuana to help ease their medical problems. Residents of those states still can face federal drug charges."

Meanwhile, South Dakota is seeing a wave of vandalism as "pro-choice" supporters deface election signs urging a "Yes" vote to sustain the new law banning almost all abortions - vandalism that not one of the many groups sponsoring an $8 million dollar effort (that's about 10 dollars per resident of South Dakota) to keep the state from outlawing killing children in the womb, have condemned or even deigned to notice.


Page 2 Click HERE Link checked!! Our Right To Defend Ourselves and more!

Nathan Barton is writing this from a wonderful place in the West, which might be in the Black Hills of South Dakota or Wyoming, or might be in one of the Four Corners States. Exactly where it is, the breezes blow with the scent of liberty, and the sound of the pines or the pinions is the sound of freedom. For thousands of years, people have fought and died for the liberty that Americans in the great spaces of the West enjoy, and he writes these commentaries in the hopes that continued generations will be able to do so, until the end of Time.

Be sure to visit my blog, Liberty's Outpost.

Special Feature! Add your signature to the NEW Declaration of Independence
By Robert Greenslade

Several people have asked about buying Gadsden Flags (the rattlesnake "Don't Tread on Me flags used by the June 23d Movement and other Property Rights Organizations: you can get them for $10.00 plus shipping here.


To Read previous Commentaries, go to the archives page and click onto the link for the week. The commentaries are linked from the weekly front pages.


Your feedback is always welcome! Please use the form below. If you enter your email address, the author can respond to your comment. Not all feedback can be answered personally, of course, but you will find most of it on the Mailbag page. Please allow at least one week for it to be published. Thanks for reading The Price of Liberty!

Please note: Information about readers is never given or sold to anyone for any purpose. Remember, however, that many people can read and recover anything posted to web sites or email unless it is carefully encrypted. MamaLiberty)

Visit the Rational Review News Digest

Links to Previous
Commentaries are on the front page for each week.
Check the archives page.

[Some article sources require registration, use this link)