Libertarian Commentary on The News by Nathan A. Barton - Price of Liberty
11/22/08
Libertarian Commentary on The News
By Nathan A. Barton © 2006


Mission Statement
Revised 8.04.04
 
Editorial Policy Revised 3.19.04
 
See Reader's
Feedback
 
Reader's Forum
 
Looking for Health NEW
 
Commentary
on the News
 
Return to Home Page

June 05, 2006

Libertarian Commentary on the News 28 May to 03 June 2006 Special to The Price of Liberty
As I get ready to head off to my one political convention of the year (I am trying to quit cold-turkey, but it's hard), I have a shorter than usual column this week, with fewer divisions.

The Coming Fall of Europe

UK: "New evidence" in Diana inquiry
Telegraph [UK]
"New witnesses and forensic evidence have emerged in the investigation into the death of Diana, Princess of Wales, the man leading the inquiry said yesterday. Lord Stevens made the disclosure during an interview at the Hay Festival, the literary event in Hay-on-Wye. But he refused to elaborate on the nature of the new material, a fact likely to be seized upon by conspiracy theorists who have argued that the princess and Dodi Fayed were murdered. The former commissioner of the Metropolitan Police was asked by the Royal Coroner two years ago to investigate the crash in Paris that killed the couple in August 1997." (05/31/06)

Like Jimmy Hoffa (see the later article), the press and the mob never seem to let this go, do they?

UK: Passport D-day for soccer hooligans
Guardian [UK]
"More than 3,000 English football hooligans were required to hand over their passports to police by 5 pm on Tuesday to prevent them traveling to the World Cup. The deadline was set for 3,286 people currently subject to football banning orders, who were required to submit their travel documents at their local police station. They will also be required to attend a police station each time England play during the tournament. A huge security operation will also be launched at UK ports and airports ahead of the tournament and police have a watchlist of fans who are not subject to banning orders but against whom they have intelligence." (05/30/06)

Oh, you thought the UK was a free nation? Right. They are certainly doing a better job of containing their football hooligans than they are of controlling Islamic terrorists and their supporters, which treat London and other British sites as secure sanctuaries much as the Viet Cong and NVA treated Laos as such.

Moscow flaunts homophobic policy [sic]
Raw Story
"Moscow's influential mayor said on Tuesday the city banned gay activists from holding a parade because it is morally cleaner than the West, which is caught up in 'mad licentiousness.' The gay activists tried to hold their protest against homophobia and discrimination at the weekend despite the ban, but were detained by police, abused [sic-taunted] by militant Christians and attacked by neo-fascists. They had wanted to lay flowers at the grave of the unknown warrior, a monument to those who died defeating Nazi Germany, but police blocked their path. Mayor Yuri Luzhkov said such an action would have been a desecration of the sacred monument, and rejected Western criticism of his ban as prejudiced and homophobic." (05/30/06)

At risk of being branded the same thing, I think that this city is fully within its rights to refuse recognition and cooperation with a group which supports and encourages behavior which the city deems immoral. Would we expect a city to allow NAMBLA (North American Man-Boy Love Association - a pedophile group) to do the same as these tried? Or a group that advocates the lynching of blacks who date whites? Or perhaps a group which encourages incest between fathers and daughters? But of course, as Luzhkov points out, that is EXACTLY what we are doing in the West (except for the pro-lynching group -it isn't "PC") - and wondering why liberty has been replaced by license. It appears that nothing would have prevented these people from honoring the war dead if they had done so on their own individually or as a group that was NOT protesting "homophobia."

Russian Law Would Impose Fines for Citing Foreign Currencies
CNS News.com
Russian officials and lawmakers could be fined for using the word "dollar" in official business, if a bill currently before parliament passes. The legislation is seen as an effort to stop showing "disrespect" to the Russian ruble...

Another stupid government trick. Solution: if they want the Ruble to be respected, back it with gold or silver.

UK: Erection ban causes chaos
Ananova [UK]
"A council planning department has been thrown into chaos - after the word 'erection' was banned from emails. The word is obviously one of the most commonly used terms in applications for building works, says the Sun. But it was included in a list of obscene expressions to be filtered out by software used by Rochdale Council. Local man Ray Kennedy, 51, sent three emails to the council objecting to a neighbor's new extension. The first two were blocked because they included the word erection, which the computer thought was a sexual reference. The third email slipped through the screening net but by then the neighbor had already got permission for the work to go ahead. ... A Rochdale Council spokesman said: 'The software is not designed by the council and we don't control which words are blocked. We will be apologizing to the resident.'" (05/31/06)

An excellent example of British "stupid government tricks." Amusing and so predictable. Notice the excuses which are all they really have to offer. Not that the rest of the neighborhood should have the kind of veto power they apparently do over someone having an erection on their own property.

Catholic Students Heckle Anti-Birth Control Classmate
CNS News.com
Administrators at a Catholic university in Minnesota have apologized to students, faculty and parents for comments made by a student commencement speaker who echoed the Roman Catholic Church's position against birth control...

Yeah, this isn't a government-run school, but it might as well be, with this attitude. Strange to see a Catholic school administration apologize because Catholic doctrine was stated by one of its students? Of course, most other denominations and religious groups have seen this happen over the years - schools established and expanded for decades by the sacrifices of the members of these groups turn against the founding group and its beliefs. It happened in Harvard, it happened in Princeton, it happened at Texas Christian University. And now Catholic schools are doing it. Makes you wonder when the state will just take them over.

Government-Run,Tax-Funded Schools

Australia: $300 cash handout for parents
The Age [Australia]
"Victorian parents will get a direct cash 'bonus' from the Bracks Government when their children start primary and secondary school, and business taxes will be cut, under Treasurer John Brumby's big-spending pre-election budget. To Opposition cries of 'it's a bribe,' Mr Brumby yesterday told Parliament that the Government would pay parents $300 for every child when they started prep and again in year 7 -- and the first payments would be made just months before the November state election. He said the money would help parents pay for uniforms, books and equipment and was designed to 'support families and highlight the importance of education.' The bonus will go to all parents regardless of their wealth or income and regardless of whether the children go to state or private schools." (05/30/06)

Well, if you ever wondered what the next step of promoting welfare in the school system is, now you know. It seems to be to be a not-so-subtle way of making families even more dependent on government, and of allowing the GRTF schools to compete with private and home-schooling without worrying about such luxuries as education quality.

CA: Voters split on early tyke indoctrination
San Francisco Chronicle
"Attending preschool for free would become a constitutional right [sic] for every 4-year-old in California if voters approve a June ballot initiative that could dramatically reshape the state's public education system. Called a key to improving the state's lagging schools by proponents and a colossal waste of money by opponents, passage of Proposition 82 would place the state in the forefront of a national movement toward standardizing pre-kindergarten education. Illinois, Georgia and Oklahoma already have implemented or are considering universal preschool programs. Most of California's half-million 4-year-olds attend some form of preschool or day care now, but backers of the measure say many programs are of low quality. They say Prop. 82 would add preschool spots and raise the quality of instruction." (05/30/06)

Another example of how the GRTF schools are gaining more power, more money, and how more and more people are being sucked into the system. As the article points out, many states are expanding mandatory education ages, mandating full-time kindergarten, and demanding children be remanded to the custody of these institutions at an earlier and earlier age. Sadly, too many GRTF school teachers and staff are unable to see how hypocritical their position on this is - and how they are destroying the family in an attempt to "save it."

School districts turn to paid readers for grading essays
Seattle Times
"In the Northshore School District, some English teachers don't spend much time reading student papers. In the Bellevue School District, some don't even grade the papers. Both districts now rely on paid readers to evaluate and in some cases grade student essays in English classes; Seattle's Garfield High School is piloting such a program this year. The use of readers greatly reduces teacher workload and gives students more writing practice, but the trend raises questions about teachers' roles in inspiring and guiding students' work. Many English teachers in the region teach five classes a day with 30 students each. If they assign a two-page essay in every class, that adds up to 300 pages to read, edit, comment on and grade. ... By using readers, Bellevue officials estimate their students can write seven three- to five-page essays a semester, compared with two essays in a traditional literature class." [editor's note: Perhaps not a bad idea. The challenge, based on this wordsmith's experience, will be finding "readers" literate enough to correctly evaluate English essay-papers -- just ... "between you and I!" ;{ - SAT] (05/29/06)

Contracting out - what good are the teachers?

AZ: High-tech tags may track kids
Arizona Star
"Millions of consumers pay extra to put tracking devices in their cars in case of theft. But would parents want to shell out more money for something similar for their children? And would schools go for it? The answer seems to be yes. School districts around the nation are starting to hold themselves more accountable for the students they're paid to teach and protect. As part of the growing trend, officials in the Tucson Unified School District already are testing new technology that helps keep track of elementary students during the school day. Using a program similar to the Global Positioning System already in use in consumer and commercial vehicles, Gateway Communications Inc. has been testing the technology on three TUSD buses since January." (05/29/06)

Making them more prisons than they are already.

Home Front in the Wars on Various Things

Bush signs ban on speech, assembly at funerals
Olympia Olympian
"President Bush, marking Memorial Day with a speech paying tribute to fighting men and women lost in war, signed into law Monday a bill that keeps demonstrators from disrupting military funerals. In advance of his speech and a wreath-laying at America's most hallowed burial ground for military heroes, Bush signed the 'Respect for America's Fallen Heroes Act.' This was largely in response to the activities of a Kansas church group that has staged protests at military funerals around the country, claiming the deaths symbolized God's anger at U.S. tolerance of homosexuals." (05/30/06)

This act is wrong, plain wrong. I hope that it fails to stand up in court. At the same time, it is easy to understand why so many people acted on it and why so many are rejoicing to see it passed. No matter what your attitude towards the occupation of Iraq, towards the government as a whole, the behavior of this cult at funerals is bizarre and sick and perverted - and deeply hurtful to the families and friends bidding goodbye to a loved one. Of course, it is precisely the kind of free speech the Bill of Rights is supposed to protect. It shows that a failure to exercise liberty with responsibility and respect for others (whether merited or not!) leads quickly to a large majority of people seeking to end that liberty. Most people would say that this group of fanatics has very definitely crossed over the line where someone else's "nose" was. Solution: stop making funerals public spectacles and let families decide who can and can't come.

Military starts online stress screening
Yahoo! News
"Concerned by rising stress levels in the ranks, the Defense Department has quietly started an online self-screening program in hopes that anonymity will help some service members and their spouses overcome reluctance to confront possible mental-health problems. ... The effort is among the latest of numerous military initiatives undertaken to cope with stress, depression and other mental-health problems that have proliferated since the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan led to tougher overseas deployment schedules." (05/30/06)

Such problems (and various solutions to those problems) have been around for a very long time - this is just making big claims about something that really isn't new.

Senate passes immigration bill overhaul
http://tinyurl.com/n2gb2
Yuma Sun
"Landmark legislation to secure U.S. borders and offer millions of illegal immigrants a share of the American dream cleared the Senate on Thursday, a rare election-year reach across party lines and a triumph for President Bush. The 62-36 vote cleared the way for arduous summertime compromise talks with the House on its immigration measure focusing on border enforcement with no guarantee of success. Republicans and Democrats said energetic participation by Bush would be critical." (05/25/06)

What a joke this is - as will be the House-Senate Conference meetings to attempt to bridge the differences.

Petition Drive Seeks to Undo South Dakota Abortion Ban
(CNSNews.com) - South Dakota's abortion ban, which is expected to serve as the basis for the next Supreme Court debate on abortion rights, should have been decided by the state's voters instead of its politicians, according to the South Dakota Campaign for Healthy Families...

The pro-abortion group has worked overtime getting the signatures necessary to refer the law to the November elections. Isn't it nice to know that morality in a Democracy is subject to vote? Hopefully, someone will introduce an initiative next year to repeal the law of gravity here in South Dakota, also. Then I can fly to work, instead of driving.

FBI Raid on Jefferson Was Justified, Legal Group Claims
CNSNews.com
A legal watchdog group insists that the FBI's recent raid of Louisiana Democratic Congressman William Jefferson's office was perfectly legal, despite the subsequent complaints about the raid by both Republican and Democratic leaders of the House...

This has been my contention all along, since reading the first reports. A judge properly issued a search warrant based on probable cause, and Congress has no special immunity from obeying the law.

Plea deal reached for man whose son was convicted in terror case
USA Today
"A man pleaded guilty on Wednesday to a lesser charge rather than be retried on allegations that he lied to the FBI about his son's attendance at a terrorist training camp, according to court papers. Under a deal, Umer Hayat, 48, an ice cream vendor, pleaded guilty to lying to customs agents about more than $28,000 he and family members were carrying on a trip out of the country three years ago. In exchange, prosecutors agreed to drop charges that he lied to the FBI and to recommend he serve no more jail time after spending nearly a year behind bars." (05/31/06)

I am sadly sure that the Feebs will claim this as a victory in the "war on terrorism" but it sounds like a plea bargain to avoid the tremendous costs of fighting, and a technical violation that has virtually nothing to do with the supposed real issue at stake. If the FBI is intending to get tough on wanna-be terrorists, this isn't the way to do it. Solution: don't prosecute unless you have clear evidence that a conviction is likely, and not just to "strike fear" into someone or some group.

Gagged librarians break silence on Patriot Act
Raw Story
"Connecticut librarians spoke about their fight to stop the FBI from gaining access to patrons' library records at a news conference yesterday organized by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), and in a subsequent interview with RAW STORY. The Librarians, members of Library Connection, a not-for profit cooperative organization for resource sharing across 26 Connecticut library branches sharing a centralized computer, were served with a National Security Letter (NSL) in August of last year as part of the FBI's attempt to attain access to patron's records. The NSL is a little known statute in the Patriot Act that permits law enforcement to obtain records of people not suspected of any wrongdoing and without a court order. As part of the NSL, those served with the document are gagged and prohibited from disclosing that they have even been served." (05/31/06)

I just this week saw an excellent little brochure on the USA PATRIOT Act in the Mancos Public Library, a tiny facility of about 1,000 SF and 25,000 volumes in a small SW Colorado town. Good for the CT libraries, and good for Mancos librarians!

Cities awarded anti-terror grants most likely targets
Fox News
"Cities fiercely competing for multimillion-dollar grants for counterterrorism programs must accept an unsettling premise along with the money: They are likely targets for terrorists. The government wants cities to keep that in mind when they find out how much money they are receiving this year. The Homeland Security Department is awarding $740 million to 46 communities with the nation's highest threat risks. The money is being divvied up under a new formula the department says is based largely on intelligence and law enforcement data about threats and the possible consequences. Three cities - Memphis, Tenn., and Orlando and Fort Lauderdale, Fla. - qualified for a list of eligible communities this year after being passed over in 2005. Eleven others may be booted in 2007 because Homeland Security decided they face a lesser risk than others." (05/31/06)

Well, we can hope. Civilization (society built around cities) is, frankly, over-rated and all too prone to lead to tyranny and destroy liberty. All this is, is a political compromise to slice up the pork a bit differently this year to let another set of politicians get the glory (and votes and campaign bribes). Based on previous years, much will be wasted in various ways, and the "terrorism" threat will not be abated. Solution? Eliminate the grant program AND the tax/borrowing that is used to support it and the DHS bureaucracy that runs it, and allow the states and local communities to decide for themselves what to do to defend themselves against terrorism AND how to pay for it.

Big Cities get less Homeland Security Pork
Homeland Security News
The cities of New York and Washington will get less money in this year's allocation of Homeland security grants, drawing harsh criticism from politicians in both areas, CNN reports. The Department of Homeland Security has announced the recipients of $1.7 billion distributed through various programs to help states and cities prepare for potential terror attacks and natural disasters. For a breakdown of the Homeland security grants by city, Click here.

Poor babies. Jerk that welfare nipple right out of their mouths, and they burst out crying.

States want more power in Homeland Security
Homeland Security News
Seeking a bigger say in Homeland security decisions, the nation's governors have created a 50-state panel to give the states a single voice on national plans to prepare for threats from terrorists and natural disasters.

Strange, I thought that is what the Congress was - "a 50-state panel to give states a single voice." That was before the Imperial Congress, though. This does provide an interesting idea about how to limit or even eliminate the federal government: have ALL aspects of "national government" handled by specialized panels created by the states for specific purposes: a National Defense Council, a National Foreign Affairs Council, a National Economic Policy Council" - and take 99.5% of the power away from Congress and the White House.

Mama's Note: I have a much better idea. Eliminate all of them, period. There is no way a "National" anything can begin to plan or improve the economy, for instance. The only thing that will save our economy - if indeed it is not too late - is a truly free market with NO national government involvement at all, and none other but the local removal of those who steal and commit fraud.

Canadian Border no longer open
Homeland Security News
The United States has tightened security with Canada in its northeast corner to the dismay of businesses and residents accustomed to crossing the world's longest undefended border with little more than a wave of a hand or a flash of a driver's license. Reuters reports that since last week, most travelers from Canada must show identification and submit to background checks at U.S. border posts in Vermont, New Hampshire and Maine, said Ted Woo, U.S. Customs and Border Protection spokesman in Boston.

Perhaps the most significant loss of freedom in a long time - though many of us have had to give up traveling in and to Canada for years due to weapons restrictions.

Our Imperial Courts

SCOTUS shields corrupt from whistleblowers (sic)
Yahoo! News
"The Supreme Court on Tuesday made it harder for government employees to file lawsuits claiming they were retaliated against for going public with allegations of official misconduct. By a 5-4 vote, justices said the nation's 20 million public employees do not have carte blanche free speech rights to disclose government's inner-workings. New Justice Samuel Alito cast the tie-breaking vote. ... Dissenting justices said Tuesday that the ruling could silence would-be whistleblowers who have information about governmental misconduct." [FND editor's note: Predictions that Alito would always side with the government are coming true - MLS] (05/30/06)

I think too much is being made of this: they aren't forbidden from releasing the information - they just have to accept that the consequences may not be all that favorable. We expect loyalty to a business by its employees, and the same can be argued for government employees. No one in their right mind would claim that an employee who has signed a contract promising to keep certain information confidential could claim the First Amendment lets him impair that contract, whether it is a public-sector or private-sector job. However, the most important thing is that the solution to this is a LEGISLATIVE one: all Congress has to do is establish immunity for whistleblowers, which has been done more than once. Just because the Constitution doesn't say they have "cart blanche" doesn't mean that they can't have legal protections. I view Alito's vote as being one for judicial constraint, NOT "pro-government."

Lay, Skilling convicted in Enron collapse
Pawtucket Times
"Kenneth Lay and Jeffrey Skilling were convicted of conspiracy and fraud Thursday by a federal jury that laid blame for one of the biggest business scandals in U.S. history squarely on Enron Corp.'s two former top executives. Jurors found that the men, who received tens of millions in pay and stock options, repeatedly lied to cover up accounting tricks and business failures that led to the company's 2001 demise. The collapse wiped out more than $60 billion in market value, almost $2.1 billion in pension plans and 5,600 jobs." (05/25/06)

The final phase of any project: scapegoating. The entire mess was the result of a situation caused by government tampering with the market system and creating opportunities for thugs to con people - but notice that the Congressmen and regulators aren't being convicted of anything - not even stupidity.

Mama's Note: If politicians were held to the same standards, almost all of them would be in jail.

CA: Woman gets $2 million in matchmaker lawsuit
Los Angeles Times
"Single people everywhere dream of a match made in heaven. Anne Majerik dreamed only of a match made in Beverly Hills. But when her high-priced matchmaker disappointed her, she sued. And on Tuesday, a jury awarded her $2.1 million. Majerik, who paid $125,000 to Beverly Hills matchmaker Orly Hadida, said she was promised time with 'a cultured gentleman' and his 'estate of up to $20 million.' She said all she got were a few introductions to some inappropriate men. Orly, an Israeli beauty pageant winner who goes by her first name, told a far different story. She and her lawyer alleged that Majerik is a serial suer of matchmakers and that the widow used her and the men Hadida set her up with, enjoyed herself and then claimed that she had been 'psychologically damaged by the process' and demanded compensation." (05/31/06)

I don't know who is more gullible here: the court system as a whole, the "matchmaker" for not screening her clients better and documenting things, the "serial suer" or the jury. Stupid people, stupid laws, stupid waste of time all around. Solution? I don't know if there is one - the situation has gotten so bad. Humorously, can you get your legis-gator to sign on to the "Lawyer Predation and Numbers Reduction Act of 2006" which would assign nationwide open seasons on various types of lawyers, bag limits (high bag limits, at first), and special rules for breeding lawyers (I know, it is a gross and disgusting idea, but some things have to be talked about).

Mama's Note: There is one species I'd just as soon see become extinct - soon. Big bag limits (so everyone has a chance to participate) and a big prize for whoever brings in the last one. Forget the breeding! Gross, indeed!

Mideast Tarbabies

Relentless violence kills 54 in Iraq
Moscow-Pullman Daily News
"Car bombs targeting Shiite areas devastated a bustling outdoor market and an auto dealership Tuesday, part of a relentless onslaught that killed 54 people and prompted the United States to deploy more troops to combat insurgents in western Iraq. The bombs also wounded 120 people, officials said. The death toll made Tuesday one of the bloodiest days in Iraq this month, and lawmakers still had not agreed on who should lead the nation's army and police forces. Authorities also captured a suspected terrorist who allegedly confessed to beheading hundreds of people. The operation by Iraqi forces also netted documents, cell phones and computers containing information on other wanted terrorists and Islamic extremist groups." (05/30/06)

That's the Moscow IDAHO Daily News, by the way. This is what finally triggered (at least according to reports) moving 1500 troops from Kuwait (a reserve/rest area) into Iraq, to try and restore peace. This suspected terrorist's confession should be taken with a grain of salt, much as M. Atta's claims, or the nutcase who is running around claiming to be a US Army Ranger who helped kill thousands of Iraqis (and who, it turns out, didn't even make it through basic training before the Army tossed him out on his ear).

Afghanistan wants US troops prosecuted
ABC News
"Afghanistan's parliament has approved a motion calling for the government to prosecute the U.S. soldiers responsible for a deadly road crash that sparked the worst riots in Kabul in years, officials said Wednesday. The assembly passed the nonbinding motion Tuesday, after debating Monday's crash in which a U.S. truck plowed into a line of cars, killing up to five Afghans and sparking citywide, anti-foreigner riots, said Saleh Mohammed Saljuqi, an assistant to the parliamentary speaker. ... Hospital officials say most of the dead and wounded were shot." (05/31/06)

I would assume, and I think with a good deal of justification, that the US WILL conduct Article 15-6 investigations and if there is error on the part of anyone: driver, mechanic, passengers - they will be prosecuted appropriately. But meanwhile, Afghani legislators are behaving no differently than their US counterparts who apparently have supernatural ability to make judgments without having to worry about the facts. And Afghani "citizens" behave, once more, like the Islamic-deluded and irresponsible people they have shown themselves in the past - rioting over cartoons, traffic accidents, seemingly anything at all.

US reportedly ready for Iran talks
Houston Chronicle
"The United States is ready to meet with Iran and other nations for talks on Tehran's nuclear ambitions if the Islamic republic gives up uranium enrichment, diplomats said Wednesday. ... One of the diplomats told The Associated Press that the Bush administration was planning to make an official announcement on Washington's conditional readiness to join in such talks later in the day. The development is significant because the United States has had no official direct talks with the Iranians since the two countries cut diplomatic ties following the occupation of the U.S. Embassy in Tehran by radicals in 1979." (05/31/06)

As I recall over the past few months, the US has ALWAYS been open for talks, but Iran has refused to do so. It may be that DC is putting too many caveats on the offer of talks, but then Iran has made it clear right along that they aren't interested in talking - except to make bombastic threats and accusations. (Which makes them sound just like the US, doesn't it?)

Pentagon: Iraq insurgency steady until '07
USA Today
"The Sunni Arab heart of the Iraqi insurgency seems likely to hold its strength the rest of the year, and some of its leaders are now collaborating with al-Qaeda terrorists, the Pentagon said Tuesday. In a report assessing the situation in Iraq, required quarterly by Congress, the Pentagon painted a mixed picture on a day when the U.S. military command in Baghdad said 1,500 more combat troops have arrived in the country. The extra troops are part of an intensified effort to wrest control of the provincial capital of Ramadi from insurgents." (05/30/06)

Hope or just blind faith?

Mama's Note: And just what will be accomplished if they do gain "control?" More people dead, more soldiers wounded and maimed, more infrastructure destroyed, more hate and more "terrorists" recruited... there doesn't seem to be any real benefit to anyone in this except job security for the military brass and the government "leaders." What a horrible waste of everything, espcially the lives and property of so many innocent people.

Iraq war proves deadliest for journalists
MSNBC
"Transferred Tuesday to the U.S. military's largest hospital abroad, CBS correspondent Kimberly Dozier remained in stable but critical condition, according to U.S. doctors in Landstuhl, Germany. 'Right now,' says Landstuhl Hospital commander Bryan Gamble, 'She is doing as well as can be expected.' But Dozier's camera crew -- Britons Paul Douglas and Jim Brolan -- were killed by the same roadside bomb, while embedded with the U.S. Army in Baghdad." (05/30/06)

They understand the risks, and they won't be the last.

Officers not a target of Iraq death probe
Glasgow Daily Times
"Three officers relieved of command from a Marine battalion are not targets of investigations into whether their troops killed as many as two dozen Iraqi civilians and tried to cover it up, the attorney for one of the officers said Tuesday. Capt. James Kimber learned about the deaths only after the 3rd Battalion, 1st Marine Regiment returned from Iraq in March, attorney Paul Hackett said. Separate investigations seek to determine whether the Nov. 19 killings in the western Iraqi city of Haditha were criminal and whether the Marines involved and their commanding officers tried to hide the truth." (05/30/06)

It sounds as though separate investigations are going on, to determine if these officers were involved after the fact. And this is the proper way to handle it, no matter how the Mainstream Media tries to slant it.

Abbas stuns Hamas with talk of referendum
Des Moines Register
"In a bold initiative, the Palestinian president gave Hamas 10 days to accept the idea of a Palestinian state alongside Israel, saying Thursday he'll submit the plan to a referendum by mid-July if the Islamic militants refuse. Mahmoud Abbas' surprise announcement is a political gamble that could either help resolve the Palestinians' internal deadlock or lead the Hamas-led government and Fatah into a deeper crisis." (05/25/06)

Gee - a democratic solution in the ultimate Arabic "nation." No wonder Hamas is stunned.

Palestinian Rockets Rain on Southern Israel
CNS News.com
Islamic Jihad reportedly is claiming responsibility for Wednesday morning's rocket attack on the southern Israeli town of Sderot. The early-morning barrage came just one day after Israel publicized for the first time that it was sending commando units deep into the northern Gaza Strip to ambush and intercept the rocket-firing squads...

Peace didn't last very long, did it?

PLO: No Peace Through Unilateral Israeli Action
CNS News.com
Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert has been trying to gain support for a plan to merge Israeli settlements and evacuate others to give Palestinians most of the West Bank. But Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) negotiators Wednesday said Olmert's plan would end the possibility of a Palestinian state...

Nothing Israel can or will do will satisfy the PLO or the Arab world. Nothing.

Our Right to Defend Ourselves and Others

SC: 2 gunned down in botched robbery
Myrtle Beach Online
"Two men were killed early Monday in a gunfight sparked by an armed robbery attempt near the intersection of Cassandra Lane and 22nd Avenue South, Myrtle Beach police said. ... A police incident report said that Smith and a friend, Charles Melvin Stocker Jr., 26, of Hopkins, were near Cassandra and 22nd when McCullough and another person approached and tried to rob them at gunpoint. During the robbery, McCullough shot and killed Smith, police said. Stocker then pulled a gun he had and fired on McCullough, police said. Horry County Deputy Coroner Tamara Willard said both men were shot multiple times while within a few feet of each other." (05/30/06)

Sounds like the bad part of town. Such gun battles are, thankfully, rare. But clearly, the robbers were intending to kill to rob.

NH: Burglar chased by teen faces robbery charge
Nashua Telegraph
"Gagnon and Carey broke into a house on Derry Street in Hudson shortly before 2 p.m. on Jan. 17, 2005, according to court records. A 16-year-old boy was home, in the basement at the time, and heard them breaking into the house, LaFrance said. The boy went upstairs, and saw two strangers outside, in the rear of the house, apparently trying to force their way inside, the teen told police. The boy ran up to his mother's bedroom, took a handgun from her dresser drawer and hid in the bedroom closet, he told police. The boy could hear the burglars rummaging around downstairs, and in time, they came upstairs. One of the burglars spotted the empty holster on the bed, and remarked that there must be a gun in the house, LaFrance said. Prosecutors believe that Gagnon and Carey, like most burglars, were drug addicts looking for items they could quickly pawn or trade for drugs, LaFrance said. When the burglars opened the closet door, however, the teen confronted them with the gun, and told them he would shoot if they didn't back off. The teen then chased the duo from the house, yelling at them, LaFrance said. 'To be truthful, they're lucky they didn't get shot,' she said." (05/26/06)

Not a shot fired, as is often the case. Having the weapon prevents crime and doesn't HAVE to mean someone is hurt or dies, but it often keeps innocent people from being hurt, as was probably the case here.

ID: Shooting leaves one dead
KTVB News
"A Valley County man is dead, and the man who pulled the trigger says he did it in self-defense. The 26-year old shooter admitted to police that he killed the man, but he says he did it for his own protection. ... According to police 11 people were at a party in the home when a fight broke out. Police say a number of metal weapons were used in the fight. The shooter tells police the Prescott brothers attacked him with the weapons, and that's when he shot James Prescott in self-defense." (05/30/06)

Sounds like a coroner's jury really needs to sort this one out. I seldom recommend such, but this week, there are several situations where the claim of "self-defense" needs to be proven.

OR: Intruder shot multiple times
KPTV News
"A 9-1-1 call from a woman in Boring reported that a man who had been harassing her, broke into her residence and her boyfriend shot the intruder multiple times. It happened at about 2:30 a.m. Clackamas County Sheriff's officials say the woman told them the intruder had been stalking her. She says the man physically forced his way into her residence. The man, reported to be 49-years-old, was shot multiple times with a handgun in the upper torso and is reported to be in stable condition." (05/30/06)

A much clearer situation than some, this week. I do wonder what ammo the boyfriend was using, though. Yes, someone pumped up can absorb a lot of lead, and this may be such a case. There are stories from the frontier that tell of men surviving and still fighting with 10 or more bullets weighing them down.

NC: Squabble leads to gunfire
McDowell News
"Capt. Dudley Greene of the Sheriff's Office said Freeman and several others were in his yard, when 34-year-old Mark Anthony Salyer of Southern Way showed up unannounced. Witness said a confrontation ensued and Salyer brandished a weapon, the captain stated. That's when Freeman shot Salyer once in the chest with a .45-caliber handgun." (05/30/06)

Although there are some questions to be answered, this seems like a clear case of home invasion and a threat of deadly force, to which Freeman responded well within his rights.

MI: No murder charge for man who shot rapper Proof
Detroit Free Press
"The man who shot and killed Detroit rapper Proof acted in self defense and will not face murder charges, Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy said Tuesday. Mario Etheridge, 28, shot Proof, whose real name is Deshaun Holton, after Proof allegedly shot and killed Etheridge's cousin, Keith Bender Jr., a U.S. Army veteran. ... The C.C.C. club on 8 Mile was the place where Proof, 32, a close friend of Eminem and a member of the rap group D12, was shot three times in the head and chest after a fight about 4:30 a.m. April 11 -- more than two hours after the club was required by law to close. Before his death, Proof, shot the 35-year-old Bender, police said. Bender died a week later. Etheridge, who prosecutors said shot Proof, was charged last month with gun felonies, but not with the killing. Police said Etheridge, a bouncer at the bar, shot Proof after the rapper shot Bender in a fight over a pool game." (05/30/06)

The gun felonies seem to be a way for the state to get around the inconvenient fact that a business has a right to protect itself, its employees, and its customers from attack.

India: Catholic priest seeks pistol, stirs row
Navhind Times [India]
"Fr Jacob Augustine, a Catholic priest here, has applied for a pistol license, kicking up a controversy. Fr Augustine had applied to the Kottayam Collectorate for a license in January, but a section within his church is protesting against this move. The 42-year-old priest is also the manager of the Amal Jyothi Engineering College, owned by the Catholic Diocese of Kanjirapally, 50 km from here. 'There are several priests in our church who possess a licensed weapon. Moreover, since I manage a big institution, which has got lot of assets, I do not think possessing a gun is wrong,' Fr Augustine told IANS." (05/29/06)

There is a problem with priests bearing arms? That isn't for the state to decide, that is for the church to decide.

Fedgoons will help NYC in frivolous gun suit
New York Times
"Casework supporting the city's federal lawsuit against 15 gun dealers in five states will be funneled to federal law enforcement agents around the country for possible criminal investigations and prosecutions, officials said yesterday. The New York office of the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives will collect and evaluate the evidence on illegal purchases of guns that has been gathered by the Bloomberg administration and send it to offices with jurisdiction over those dealers, officials said.In all, five federal judicial districts could wind up pursuing criminal cases, since the city conducted its two-month sting in Georgia, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina and Virginia. " (05/27/06)

Did anyone expect anything else? I love the tee-shirt (now offered even by Townhall): "'Alcohol Tobacco Firearms and Explosives' should be the name of a convenience store, not a government agency."

IN: Shot fired during robbery attempt
Martinsville Reporter Times
"A Mooresville business was reportedly the target of an armed robber Friday night, but the owner fired first. According to Mooresville Police Department preliminary reports, the owner of Hasting's Jewelry, 354 S. Indiana St., saw a man walk up to the entrance of his store shortly before 6 p.m. The man pulled a red hood over his face, took out a handgun and entered the store. The owner, who was not identified, also had a handgun. As the man entered the store, the owner stood up with his weapon. Officers said the robber told the owner, 'Don't do it, man, I'll kill you.' According to police, the owner then discharged his weapon, striking the top of a display case. The bullet ricocheted off a large pair of scissors, then went out a window. After the shot, the would-be robber fled the business." (05/28/06)

Again, no one hurt, although that might not have been intentional on the part of the owner. This article does, however, show a common bias on the part of the media: "reportedly the target" - as if they don't really quite believe the unnamed owner.

Mama's Note: Seems the owner here needs a lot more practice and training with his weapon. The ricochet could have killed someone outside the window.

TN: business owner fights back against armed robbers
ABC 24 News
"Adam Obsiye South Memphis convenience store and his native Somalia would seem to have little in common. But his friends say they do. Ali Mohammed says, 'It's the same over here and over there. Same. People over there killing people. People over here killing people. It's the same thing. Ain't nothing different. Ain't no peace.' Memphis Police say as Obsiye was closing up shop Sunday night, two armed men stormed into his store. A third man waited outside. When they two robbers inside demanded money from Obsiye, the store owner grabbed his pistol and started shooting. He hit one in the thigh as they ran out of his store." (05/29/06)

Ali is right - which is why we need our freedom to keep, bear, and use arms to defend ourselves. As the next story points out, Somalia and Tennessee aren't alone in this.

Iraq: Guns becoming as important as food
Inter Press Service
"Guns have come to be seen in Iraq as a need second only to food. Under Saddam Hussein possession of weapons was highly regulated. But after the invasion of Iraq, the military collapsed and many armouries and ammunition dumps were left unprotected. In an environment of a lack of security, these came to supply a growing appetite for guns. To begin with people bought guns -- or took those discarded on the streets -- as a defence against the eruption of lawlessness after the fall of Baghdad. Recently, after the bombing of the al-Askariyah shrine in Samarra in February this year, a wave of reprisal killings drastically increased the desire of each Iraqi family to have at least one gun. 'I think it is important for every Iraqi to have a weapon to protect himself and his family,' Abu Hasan, a weapons merchant in Baghdad told IPS." (05/29/06)

Here in the American West (and the frontier, anywhere in the Americas) a firearm was MORE important than food - in part because it could obtain food for you and your family: five bullets, five pieces of game (admittedly, usually squirrels or rabbits) was NOT just mythology. And guns provide protection for self, family, and neighbors.

FL: Teen shoots intruder
Sun Sentinel
"Javaris Granger wished his father was there instead of him. His father was on the phone, urging Granger, 15, to get the gun they used for shooting practice. 'Do what you have to do,' his father said. Granger did. He aimed the gun and fired at the violent intruder. Family and friends are awed by Granger's bravery. 'Anyone who takes charge like that is definitely a hero,' said Maxine Chandler, his mother. Before the McArthur High School freshman fired the gun, he kept a cool head and remembered his father's shooting and safety lessons during the chaos early Saturday morning." (05/25/06)

Amazingly, the Grangers aren't in court for contributing to the delinquency of a minor by allowing the son to have a handgun. Good for Javaris. (I suspect that the pistol might actually have been Javaris's, but with the current stupid federal and state laws, anyone under 18 can't own a handgun, so the fiction is maintained. Other families I know have ALL members of the family, some as young as 10 or 12, who have their own pistols, and have been trained as well.)

IN: Home Invasion, 7 dead
My Way News
Seven family members, the youngest just 5 years old, were shot to death in their home, and police said Friday they were seeking at least two suspects. The attack appeared to have been a home invasion, but not random, Deputy Police Chief Tim Foley said. He said investigators were considering several possible motives.

Apparently none were armed - one was actually pulled into the house to be killed while a friend (who called the cops) watched. The cops arrived too late.

Founders faced many issues still here today
Philadelphia Inquirer
"When the Founders ratified the Second Amendment in 1791, they had in mind English politics of the 1680s, when a Catholic king (James II) was thought to be scheming to impose his religion on a Protestant nation by using a powerful army. After James was deposed, England adopted a bill of rights, including a right to bear arms. A century later the Founders supported militias and an armed citizenry, not to protect Protestants against Catholics, but to allow the states or the people to defend themselves against a national government gone wild." (05/31/06)

An interesting article from a mainstream media outlet.

TN: Crime victims stop would be robbers
WSMV TV News
"Usually criminals worry about being caught by police but in Murfreesboro criminals need to watch out for their victims. In the last two months, five different victims took bold risks in stopping crime. Tim Davis' Salt and Pepper Christian bookstore is full of statements that mirror is own beliefs. From commandments to bumper stickers, it all points to character and when a man tried to rob him, he believes he knows exactly what Jesus would do. Tim pulled out a pair of scissors and chased his robber down the street holding him at bay until police arrived. 'If you roll over and take it, they will do it again,' Davis defended his action. ... Guillermo Acosta sacrificed his own life while defending his neighbors during a robbery at La Tienda / La Carreta grocery story. A robber stormed into JD's Market and pointed a gun at Karim Barakat. Mr. Barakat remained calm but when the robber pointed the gun at his beloved wife, Barakat pulled out his own gun and shot the robber. A man robbed on East State Street exchanged gunfire with his robber." (05/31/06)

A whole list of Tennesseans reminding us why it is the "Volunteer State." At lest the first one, though, I have my doubts about: brave and risk-taking yes, but stupid, too. A pair of scissors? And NOT "what Jesus would do," either: Jesus told His disciples to take a sword.

GA: Teen burglar shot by homeowner
WSTB TV News
"Police say a man shot and wounded a teenager he found in his home - attempting to rob him. Police say 27-year-old Ronald Ramsey arrived at his Lawrenceville home Tuesday afternoon and found 17-year-old Alrazi Basher of Duluth inside, robbing him. Officials say when Basher tried to flee the home, Ramsey shot at Basher and hit him and his vehicle." (05/31/06)

Was this a legitimate "self-defense" incident? I really do not think so. The kid was already running away, and there was no threat to the gunner or his family or neighborhood. There was no attempt to stop a fleeing felon with a threat of force, which would be legitimate. Yes, I wasn't there, so I don't know what his fears were at the time, but I think a coroner's jury ought to find out.

More News and Commentary on Page 2

Nathan Barton is writing from his secret bunker complex on the eastern slopes of the Paha Sapa, swilling Doctor Pepper (and gallons of water each day, milady) and plotting to reelect Gaius Julius Caesar dictator of the Republic - or was that Senator Palpatine? Granville James Corbin? W? Q?

Be sure to visit my blog, Liberty's Outpost.

Special Feature! Add your signature to the NEW Declaration of Independence
By Robert Greenslade

Several people have asked about buying Gadsden Flags (the rattlesnake "Don't Tread on Me flags used by the June 23d Movement and other Property Rights Organizations: you can get them for $10.00 plus shipping here.


To Read previous Commentaries, go to the archives page and click onto the link for the day. The commentaries are linked from the daily front pages.


Your feedback is always welcome! Please use the form below. If you enter your email address, the author can respond to your comment. Not all feedback can be answered personally, of course, but you will find most of it on the Mailbag page. Please allow at least one week for it to be published. Thanks for reading The Price of Liberty!

Please note: Information about readers is never given or sold to anyone for any purpose. Remember, however, that many people can read and recover anything posted to web sites or email unless it is carefully encrypted. MamaLiberty)

Visit the Rational Review News Digest

Links to Previous
Commentaries
are on the front page for each day. Check the archives page.

[Some article sources require registration, use this link)


Submit Feedback

Name: