Libertarian Commentary on The News by Nathan A. Barton - Price of Liberty
11/22/08
Libertarian Commentary on The News
By Nathan A. Barton © 2006


Mission Statement
Revised 8.04.04
 
Editorial Policy Revised 3.19.04
 
See Reader's
Feedback
 
Reader's Forum
 
Looking for Health NEW
 
Commentary
on the News
 
Return to Home Page

May 29, 2006

Libertarian Commentary on the News, Week of 21 - 28 May, 2006 Special to TPOL
This week, we have a lot of comments and a lot of news to comment about! I want to start off with some comments on comments on comments, however - words to remember in a year like 2006.

Kiss off watered-down and adulterated libertarianism
Free Market News Network
by Michael Cloud
"When false friends or weak allies water down liberty with less valuable or worthless ingredients, freedom loses. And so do we. Take a look at a few weak, watered-down, diluted brews of liberty and libertarianism. Compare watered-down and adulterated libertarianism with the Pure Stuff. Libertarians do NOT 'doubt' the value of Big Government and government intervention: we are sure that they are damaging and destructive. We oppose them. Libertarians are NOT individuals 'who are unconvinced' or 'remain unpersuaded' or 'aren't sold on' or 'are less than excited by' Big Government, high taxes, or government intervention. Libertarians ARE convinced, persuaded, and sold on the belief that Big Government doesn't work, that government interference and intervention into the voluntary, peaceful relations of individuals is destructive, wrong, evil. We oppose these actions of government. We work against these things. We try to reduce and remove them." (05/25/06)

Strong words. Similar to the following, from a former member of the GOP, talking about his party's leadership, especially on the national level. "The only religion most Republicans have is the religion of personal power and profit. In this religion, they are indeed "fanatics" but to claim them as "Christian fanatics" is foolish. True, many of them claim to be "Christian" just as many of them claim to be for freedom and liberty and the Constitution. Bushwah! One can scarcely call them "hypocrites" because to be a hypocrite you have to believe what you are saying and not doing. Just as they wrap a flag around them and claim to be "patriots" while not knowing or caring about the true meaning of the word, just as they put up billboards urging voters to "protect freedom" without any clue as to what freedom really is, so they also bow down before the cross of Jesus Christ without the slightest inkling of what the Savior really preached or what He expects of His true disciples." Will either party pay attention? I hope so, but I am optimistic and say that I hope it is the LP that does, first.

Culture Wars - At Home and Abroad
I don't know about the readers of TPOL (although I welcome your feedback on the subject - use form at the bottom of the pages) but I am tired of having my culture attacked, supposedly in the cause of freedom, liberty, and "tolerance" by a variety of people - many of whom claim to be and usually seem to be libertarian. Too many seem to take the attitude that people are lovers of liberty IN SPITE OF their religious beliefs. This is seldom the case: in fact, I and many others are libertarian BECAUSE of our religion. I am not claiming that there are no problems with American society, but that is far from the published statements of many who see NO redeeming values in it. Let's look at a few items.

Christian, Jewish Women Promote Biblical Women's Rights
CNSNews.com
Jerusalem - American Christians are teaming up with Israeli parliamentarians to advance the status of women worldwide by stressing Judeo-Christian values. One evangelist said the more a society embraces Judeo-Christian values, the less likely women are to be abused...

This is, indeed, very much the truth. Not even considering the fact that the modern "post-Christian" world could not have even developed without their being a "Christian" society to follow - no society/religion: Islam, Buddhism, Confucianism, Shinto, Greco-Roman Paganism, even most AmerInd religions; has established a higher status for women.

Saudi Schools Still Teach Hatred for West, Report States
CNSNews.com
The Saudi government has not only broken its promise and failed to eliminate anti-western rhetoric from its public school textbooks, some Saudi-funded schools on U.S. soil continue to incite violence, a Persian Gulf watchdog group alleged Wednesday...

To anyone who knows anything about Islam (and is honest), this is just what would be expected. And since GRTF schools have failed to eliminate "anti-western rhetoric" from the curriculums of tens of thousands of primary, middle, secondary, and post-secondary schools, aren't we being a bit hypocritical to nag the Saudis about it?

Christ as Commodity
Townhall
And so we get ChristianT bookstores stuffed with ChristianT books (not just Bibles, theology, and devotionals, but ChristianT romances, and ChristianT action-adventure books, and ChristianT westerns.), ChristianT music, ChristianT movies, ChristianT clothing, ChristianT keychains, ChristianT action figures, and ChristianT nightlights. Christianity isn't a religion, it's a brand name.

It is the modern version of the moneychangers in the Temple, and just as evil and damaging. Nathanael Blake's commentary is worth reading, and points out one reason why people really committed to following Christ are being condemned as evil theonomists and "religious extremists" - too many so-called Christians have about the same relationship to their "religion" as the average fan does to their favorite rock group.

Congress Should Not Decide 'Gay' Marriage, Groups Say
CNSNews.com
Two groups with widely divergent views on same-sex marriage gathered in Washington, D.C., Monday to present a surprisingly similar message: Churches, not the U.S. Congress, should settle the contentious issue...

And the best way to do this is to separate state and marriage, along with state and church, state and school, and for that matter, state and anything more important than what color to paint the stripes on the highway.

Mama's Note: And just why should government be involved in that either? I have never yet heard even one half good reason for it. Highway stripes one day, seat-belt laws the next.

Gay storks make good parents
Ananova [UK]
"Four gay storks have proved they are as capable of raising a family as their heterosexual counterparts. Staff at the zoo in Overloon, near Eindhoven, were unsure if the gay and lesbian storks would still have the same natural urge to raise offspring. But after giving one egg to a pair of gay males to sit on, and another two eggs to a pair of lesbian storks, they say the gay storks took to parenthood straight away. Zoo spokeswoman Esther Jansen said all three chicks had hatched successfully: 'The gay storks look after the eggs and the chicks just as well as our heterosexual birds.'" (05/24/06)

No surprise this is popping up all over, as yet another action in the campaign to legitimize homosexuality. Unlike humans, who apparently have very little if any instinctive parental abilities, storks and other birds do. The article, of course, does nothing to explain how they know these storks are homosexual, why they are homosexual, or much else.

Mama's Note: This whole story is highly suspect, from several points. I've raised all kinds of birds, from common chickens to Canadian Honker geese. With the notable exception of Banty chickens (and not all of them), most birds will not accept and brood eggs they did not lay in the first place. The very idea that any animals are homosexual is a real stretch, and as Nathan says, unsupported by any proof here. All animals can display some same sex activities, especially during the normal mating season, but I highly doubt there are many - if any - truly homosexual animals. Absent any real proof, there is no reason to give this story any credibility at all.

Newspaper Cartoons Lampooning Jesus Spark Outrage
CNSNews.com
(CNSNews.com) - A pro-family organization is lashing out at a student-run newspaper at the University of Oregon for the publication of two cartoons, one showing a sexually aroused Jesus and the other showing him kissing another man...

The cartoons were actually published in March, on-campus groups filed a grievance in April (under the various "PC" rules that virtually every state "institute of higher learning" has today - usually used by liberals to bash people who speak poorly of homosexuals and such), and now this comes - the AFA is getting a little carried away, but does have at least one thing to complain about legitimately: the student paper is funded by university funds, and this entire issue was designed (by the admission of the publisher and editor) with the intention and hope of eliciting an extreme reaction from the people whose faith it attacks.. Still, such attacks and pictures are to be expected, and are actually far more demeaning and graphic than anything the Danes published. But there has been, and there will be, worse. No one needs to get beat up, expelled, or killed over this. Fortunately, unlike Islam, Biblical Christianity has no death penalty recommended or required for someone who demeans or belittles or slanders or attacks God (much less a "prophet" or "apostle" or "angel") - or for that matter, for ANY crime.

The Coming Fall of Europe
I know, most of these stories are from the UK this week, but the entire region is showing more and more signs of catastrophic failure, even as some progress is being made in some areas.

Events in the UK are distressing because we Americans ARE the spiritual heirs of "Free Englishmen" even if we aren't directly descended from them. But events in places that I love (such as Germany, which was home for four years) are also hard to bear - watching the rapid decay of society and the loss of freedoms so painfully won over centuries. Of course, I am also fearful that I am seeing what the American Union will be like in 5 or 10 years hence; our own society is well down the path that Europe has been following for 40 years. So these news items should be a warning to us all.

Scotland: Push for police powers to keep DNA from all arrests
The Scotsman
POLICE will be given new powers to take and retain DNA samples from anyone who is arrested in Scotland under controversial new laws proposed by the Labour Party.

Oh, you thought that they were telling the truth when they said it would only be used in case of "major" crimes like rape or murder?

UK: Miniluv wants the keys
CNet
"The British government is preparing to give its police the authority to force organizations and individuals to disclose encryption keys, a move that has outraged some security and civil-rights experts. The legislation that gives the police such authority is contained within Part 3 of the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act. The RIP Act, also known as RIPA, was introduced in 2000, but the government has held back from bringing Part 3 into effect. Now, more than five years after the original act was passed, the Home Office is seeking to exercise the powers within Part 3." (05/18/06)

People were warned that this would happen. The delay is curious.

UK: Eight held in terror raids
Guardian [UK]
"Detectives arrested eight people today as part of a nationwide anti-terror operation. Around 500 police officers from five police force areas carried out the raids at several locations in the early hours of this morning. The raids were intended to crack down on individuals suspected of 'facilitating terrorism abroad,' police said. ... A spokeswoman for Greater Manchester police, which led the operation, said the arrests were not made in connection with Northern Irish terrorism but refused to confirm that those arrested were suspected of Islamist terrorist offences." (05/24/06)

This sounds more and more like the old days of the Star Chamber and of Catholics or Protestants or "Anabaptists" being taken in for "questioning." Tyranny, sadly, never goes out of style.

UK: Police target anti-war protester, steal banners
Independent [UK]
"The veteran peace activist Brian Haw was stripped of his antiwar banners and placards by up to 50 police officers in an early-morning raid in Parliament Square yesterday. There were chaotic and farcical scenes as police wrestled with nine dishevelled protesters led by Mr. Haw, and a 40-metre line of antiwar placards, including two donated by the graffiti artist Banksy, was dismantled and dumped in a metal container. Two demonstrators, Martin McGrath and Maria Gallastegui, who tried to climb the metal container to salvage the placards, were arrested. ... The battle between police and the 57-year-old protester has been going on for some time. Last July, the Serious Organised Crime and Police Act came into force, bringing with it powers to halt demonstrations in Parliament Square and its vicinity, a provision widely seen as having been designed with Mr. Haw in mind." (05/23/06)

Long expected, this turned out to be less a fight than expected.

UK: Inquiry rejects high-security schools
Independent [UK]
"The head of a government inquiry into pupil behaviour has rejected demands for airport-style security to be set up in schools in the wake of the murder of 15-year-old schoolboy Kiyan Prince. Sir Alan Steer, the headteacher of Seven Kings High School in Ilford, Redbridge, warned such a move 'might actually create more problems than you solve.' ... 'You would create a certain atmosphere in schools,' he said at a conference organised by the National Union of Teachers on pupil behaviour. 'Schools should be comfortable, warm, sociable places, and you've got to get the balance right between security and creating the right atmosphere.' Sir Alan pointed out that Kiyan was knifed to death outside the school -- and therefore any airport-style security check would not have helped him." (05/22/06)

Heaven forbid that a GRTF-school look like or feel like the penal institution it really is. Strangely enough, this headteacher (equivalent of a US principal) is right in what he says about the fact that security wouldn't have stopped it - you see, he might want the checkpoints EVERYWHERE.

Slovakia: Students, teacher arrested
Ananova [UK]
"A teacher who took his class on a school trip to a historic cathedral was arrested for giving unlicenced tours. The group, from Budapest in Hungary, were in St. Michael's Cathedral, in the Slovakian capital Bratislava, when they were all arrested. Slovakian police said the teacher had broken the law by not having a licence to give guided tours and that the pupils had broken the law by listening." (05/22/06)

Isn't this exciting - Imagine: giving tours is a government -protected profession. Just like hairdressing and medical practice. It is funnier than most because we have one government agency beating up on another government agency - in a place that shouldn't be a government-controlled place at all. Imagine the lesson in freedom these kids are learning.

"Watergate" shakes Paris, but not voters
Christian Science Monitor
"The scandal has all the elements of a thriller: backstabbing politicians, a shadowy spy-master, mystery informants, secret foreign bank accounts, multimillion-dollar arms sales and illegal bribes. And it has been shaking Paris for nearly a month, as daily revelations add to the Byzantine complexity of the allegations swirling around President Jacques Chirac and his prime minister, Dominique de Villepin. But though the 'Clearstream affair' has been branded 'the French Watergate,' most French voters remain unmoved. The reasons why provide grounds for both hope and misgivings about the health of French democracy." (05/22/06)

Sadly, the people in question and the people trying to have a "democracy" are the end products of a 430-year genetic "unbreeding" program which has seen the brightest and best either killed in a series of foolish wars, or driven off to some other place. So don't expect much - you can't make an apple pie out of mud - at least not without a couple of years to wait for the tree to grow and fruit.

UK: Fears rise of British betting crisis
Independent [UK]
"Fears are rising that Britain is in the grip of an out-of-control gambling spree. As the shortlist of local authorities vying to host one of 17 new casinos was revealed yesterday -- including at least one 'super-casino' -- campaigners warned that the liberalisation of betting laws could lead to an explosion in problem gambling and family misery." (05/24/06)

Meanwhile, Scotland's government is excited about getting "Vegas-style" gambling monster complexes built. Go figure.

Mama's Note: As one with at least half of my genetic makeup directly from the thrifty, even tight fisted Scots, I can't imagine casino type gambling going over very well there. The hardy folk of Scotland have historically don't their "gambling" on the seas and in battle... I sincerely hope they have not changed this much.

Government-Run, Tax-Funded Schools
Or, if you prefer the truth, Government-ruined and theft-funded schools - what we laughingly call "public" schools.
What folly we see, constantly, in an institution supposedly dedicated to teaching (presumably, teaching truth and not error). Lovers of liberty, if they have any choice, should not let their children remain and "learn" in these institutions.

MA: Five suspended at elementary school
Boston Globe
"Five students at a Roxbury elementary school -- four girls in the first and second grades and one boy in the fifth grade -- were suspended yesterday for sexual harassment stemming from an incident on a school bus that involved lewd language and touching, according to a spokesman for the Boston public schools. The R.W. Emerson School students made 'explicit statements about and to each other, and there was some level of very minor touching going on,' said School Department spokesman Jonathan Palumbo, who would not provide details. John Chery, the father of a 7-year-old girl who was suspended, said his daughter told him they had choked, scratched, and touched one another during the Thursday morning bus ride. Chery said the school principal, C. Sura O'Mard-Gentle, told him and his daughter yesterday that one of the other girls who was suspended had referred to the events as 'the rape game.'" (05/20/06)

First and second graders? Cool. We've now gotten the corruption level down that low on the age scale. Their teachers and administrators must be so proud. I was fortunate that I only rode a school bus perhaps a dozen times in 12 years in K-12 schools, but enough to know what chambers of horrors they could be. Get your children out of these places, people. Please.

CA: Big food fight on Bay Area's school menus
San Francisco Chronicle
"It's war at the Santa Clara Unified School District. But parents aren't fighting over the curriculum, or over bilingual education or even over school closures. They're brawling over cupcakes - and chocolate bars, and hamburgers and candy. School food has become a national obsession. And no place is the fixation more evident than in the Bay Area, where activists are determined to put an end to obesity and teach kids how to eat right. They're filling school yards with edible gardens, applying for grants to put salad bars in cafeterias, teaching students and parents how to cook healthful meals and replacing cookies with strawberries at school dances. It seems simple. It's not. All agree that schools need to clean up their nutritional act, but there is bitter dissent over how it should be done and how far it should go." (05/22/06)

Our society provides far too many of us with too much time on our hands, and without the social constraints that once kept the Mrs. Grundy's down to a minor inconvenience. Maybe the schools ought to get out of the food business entirely. Once upon a time, and not that long ago (40 years or less), schools didn't serve lunch, didn't serve snacks (didn't have kindergarten in which to serve them!), didn't feed kids breakfast, and didn't have vending machines lining the hallways. There might be an evil entrepreneur across the street or down the block that sold candy (GASP), comic books (DOUBLE GASP), and - cigarettes (HORRIBLE GURGLING SOUND BEYOND A GASP). But that also depended on exactly how kids wanted to spend their generous 25-cent weekly allowance. Sodas, po'chips, chitlins, and that monstrous beverage called "coffee" were available only from an evil smelling metal pot and semi-functioning refrigerator in that evil den of horrors (really -ask any student) called the "teacher's lounge." Today of course, the students have cash to spend that means a typical suburban American high school has a greater combined personal income that is twice that of all of sub-Saharan Africa, Pizza Hut has the contract for lunch and Taco Bell for breakfast, Pepsi delivery trucks have reserved parking spaces, every classroom has a latte maker, and the teacher's lounge is the place for quick student-teacher trysts. Only in YOUR "public schools."

Mama's Note: Sarcasm, folks - please don't write to inform me that Nathan has finally lost his mind. :)

MA: "Tough love" vs. torture
Boston Globe
"When New York regulators meet today to consider limiting a Massachusetts school's use of electric shocks as punishment, it will not be the first time that states have tried to rein in the unorthodox methods at the Judge Rotenberg Educational Center. Massachusetts officials tried to close the school in 1985 after a student with autism died while being forced to listen to loud static through a helmet. They tried again in the mid-1990s when the school began giving mild shocks to students for misbehavior. Each time, judges protected the Rotenberg Center, siding with parents who said the school had improved the lives of children with autism, mental retardation, and emotional problems after gentler methods had failed. And doctors concluded the death was caused by the student's neurological disorder. Now, the center -- the only school in the country to rely so heavily on painful punishments -- faces a challenge from the state that supplies almost two-thirds of its 251 students." (05/22/06)

This sounds like nothing but a contract-run government school, based on the source of the students. Stupid government officials continue to ship off their "wards" (victims) to this place while trying to close it down? For twenty years or more?

Mama's Note: This story was truly nauseating. These people first poison and pollute these children - both before and after birth - then drug them, isolate them from their families, and finally torture them because they are so messed up from the previous outrages!! Children with these problems need serious help, systemic cleansing, lots of love, and total withdrawal from all of the horrible "legal" drugs. Since when do we punish people for being poisoned and sick? Oh yes, I almost forgot the "war on drugs..."

FL: Saudis held after boarding school bus
Miami Herald
"Two Saudi men who boarded a school bus full of children and gave conflicting reasons why there were there were arrested and held without bail, authorities said Sunday. Mana Saleh Almanajam, 23, and Shaker Mohsen Alsidran, 20, were charged with misdemeanor trespassing and were jailed after a judge said Saturday she wanted more background information on them. A hearing was scheduled Tuesday. The two men arrived in the country six months ago on student visas and are enrolled at the English Language Institute at the University of South Florida. Investigators said they boarded the school bus Friday, sat down and began speaking in Arabic." (05/21/06)

I'm sure that they will soon be released in a "gesture of reconciliation" to the offended masses of Muslims, who of course would never do anything horrible to children. But if you think Arab weirdoes are the only dangers children face on school buses, read the next story from the wonderful Socialist Paradisical Republic of Mass.

Home Front
The Home Front in this year of 2006 here in the United States is a might bit confusing to anyone: I have a hard time figuring out when someone is an enemy and when they are not. And based on the news and commentary, I'm not alone. This week, we see a variety of the battles being waged here in the US (except things I've classified as purely cultural). Of particular note is the entire spying business (including the role of Gen. Hayden), the VA records theft, and the Imperial Congress's immunity to the law.

Senate Confirms Gen. Hayden as CIA Director
Washington Post
A 78-15 Senate vote gives a broad bipartisan endorsement to the architect of National Security Agency's domestic spying program.

Where are all the Demos who are so much against the war and the administration? Where are all the Republicans who claim to believe in freedom and limited government? Obviously, not in the US Senate. (See the quote at the beginning of the column.) At the same time, this is evidence that on things that they really consider important, the Bush White House is able to maneuver in the sewer currents of the Congress.

Gonzales: Bush can do whatever he likes with reporters, too
CNN
"Attorney General Alberto Gonzales said Sunday he believes journalists can be prosecuted for publishing classified information, citing an obligation to national security. The nation's top law enforcer also said the government will not hesitate to track telephone calls made by reporters as part of a criminal leak investigation, but officials would not do so routinely and randomly. 'There are some statutes on the book which, if you read the language carefully, would seem to indicate that that is a possibility,' Gonzales said, referring to prosecutions." (05/21/06)

The knots in this man's brain must be frightening to behold.

Mama's Note: What "brain?" A bowl of overcooked spaghetti has far more integrity, I think.

ACLU seeks to rally against phone snooping
Philadelphia Inquirer
"A civil rights group was launching a nationwide Don't Spy On Me campaign Wednesday to urge the public to demand that the Federal Communications Commission and state utility commissions probe whether phone companies broke laws by sharing customer records with the government's biggest spy agency. On its Web site Tuesday night, the American Civil Liberties Union said it was demanding action at the FCC in Washington, D.C., and in 17 states. It was to advertise the start of its program in newspapers across the country Wednesday. The campaign, symbolized by a telephone with an eye on it, urges members of the public to go to an ACLU Web site to add their names to complaints being filed with the FCC and with state utility commissions to show there is a large population of people upset by the sharing of their records." (05/23/06)

Well, for once, I can say, good for the ACLU. People think all I do is bash them, but I am not today. Really. I think they are doing the right thing in this case (although I confess that I won't be writing a donation check to them soon, because of other actions/problems. And the ACLU isn't the only ones fighting this, as the next story relates.

Mama's Note: Maybe... And just what is all this complaining supposed to accomplish? I don't remember the government being at all anxious about adverse public opinion recently. Of course, it is so easy for them to manipulate what most people think that I highly doubt this will bother them in the least. You notice that they managed to swing the national ID deal in spite of massive public outcry over it. Don't hold your breath...

Suit seeks to stop phone records release
Honolulu Advertiser
"A lawsuit filed Monday on behalf of author Studs Terkel and other professionals seeks to stop AT&T from giving customer phone records to the National Security Agency without a court order. The plaintiffs, who also include a doctor and a state lawmaker, said they rely on confidentiality in their work and are worried their clients will be less likely to phone them if they think the government collects lists of the numbers they are calling." (05/22/06)

Frankly, smaller informal groups mean more likelihood that it will sink in to the government types that we mean business, not just the usual legal wrangling that gets nothing done, except making lawyers rich(er).

The snooping goes beyond phone calls
BusinessWeek
"Furor and confusion over allegations that major phone companies have surrendered customer calling records to the National Security Agency continue to roil Washington. But if AT&T Inc. (T ) and possibly others have turned over records to the NSA, the phone giants represent only one of many commercial sources of personal data that the government seeks to 'mine' for evidence of terrorist plots and other threats. The Departments of Justice, State, and Homeland Security spend millions annually to buy commercial databases that track Americans' finances, phone numbers, and biographical information, according to a report last month by the U.S. Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress." (05/29/06)

Well, I hope that their data is more accurate than my local phone books are. I shouldn't have to spend $200 a year for a Cole's Directory when my spending is paying for the advertising dollars to support three or four local phone books.

Verizon refuses to come clean
New Standard
"Telecom giant Verizon is refusing to confirm or deny participation in the illegal National Security Agency (NSA) wiretapping program, as citizens in Maine urge the state's Public Utilities Commission (PUC) to investigate whether the company handed over its phone records. In a tightlipped 44-page response to the PUC last Friday, Verizon argued that the Commission lacks the authority to investigate a complaint that the telephone company was involved in the NSA program. The company further claimed such information is protected by the'state-secrets privilege.' The complaint, filed on May 8 by a group of Mainers and the Maine Civil Liberties Union, petitioned the PUC to order Verizon to disclose whether it had released customer e-mail and phone records to the NSA." (05/23/06)

Verizon will regret hiding behind Uncle Sam's jacket-tails. Not that Verizon exactly has a clean record for paying attention to the freedom of its customers or its employees.

Mama's Note: Click onto the boycott banner above and read about just one of Verizon's other criminal actions.

Personal data on 26.5 million vets stolen
Cincinnari Enquirer
"Thieves took sensitive personal information on 26.5 million U.S. Veterans, including Social Security numbers and birth dates, after a Veterans Affairs employee improperly brought the material home, the government said Monday. The information involved mainly those veterans who served and have been discharged since 1975, said VA Secretary Jim Nicholson. Data of veterans discharged before 1975 who submitted claims to the agency may have been included. Nicholson said there was no evidence the thieves had used the data for identity theft, and an investigation was continuing." (05/22/06)

See my comments below on this and the next story

Confidential Data in Online Public Records Could be Protected
CNSNews.com
The theft of a computer disc containing the names, dates of birth and Social Security Numbers of some 25 million U.S. military veterans has provided another reminder of how easily a person's identity can be stolen. Three questions dominate the ongoing debate about Internet access to public records...

There are many, many facets of this that need to be addressed. Waiting a few weeks to make the theft public, to make sure that the thief didn't realize what he had and hopefully flogged it off on someone else is one thing. Waiting to notify the FBI that long is something else - even if they know the FBI is incompetent. But more important is the question none of the news stories and commentaries have asked: IS it necessary that personal information like this be kept in a centralized database, or ANY database, operated by the Federal government, even for veterans? Just as classified strategic and operational information is often kept "compartmentalized," would it not be wise to do the same thing with personal information?

Filing: Tape shows lawmaker taking $100K
Seattle Times
"A congressman under investigation for bribery was caught on videotape accepting $100,000 in $100 bills from an FBI informant whose conversations with the lawmaker also were recorded, according to a court document released Sunday. Agents later found the cash hidden in his freezer. At one audiotaped meeting, Rep. William Jefferson, D-La., chuckles about writing in code to keep secret what the government contends was his corrupt role in getting his children a cut of a communications company's deal for work in Africa." (05/21/06)

This man is indeed stupid. This story leads to the next two stories, which shows that he is NOT alone in his stupidity in Congress or the White House.

House leaders demand FBI return documents
Bloomington Pantagraph
"In rare, election-year harmony, House Republican and Democratic leaders jointly demanded on Wednesday that the FBI return documents taken in a Capitol Hill raid that has quickly grown into a constitutional turf fight beyond party politics. 'The Justice Department must immediately return the papers it unconstitutionally seized,' House Speaker Dennis Hastert, R-Ill., And Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., said in a statement. Within hours, according to several Republican officials, White House aides were involved in talks with Hastert's staff concerning the possible transfer of the documents, possibly to the House ethics committee." (05/24/06)

See how alike these two parties are? These are the people that claim to represent us, and rule us. House ethics committee? Let's also convene a committee of inmates to determine which people in the prison system should be let out.

Raid on Jefferson's Office Prompts Hearing
CNSNews.com
Rep. F. James Sensenbrenner (R-Wis.), chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, says his committee will hold an oversight hearing next week on constitutional questions raised by the FBI raid on Rep. William Jefferson's congressional office last Saturday night. But some say that congressmen who have allegedly engaged in criminal behavior should be fully investigated and prosecuted...

Our imperial kongrus-kritturs mustn't be bothered by judges issuing warrants on probable cause, eh? Frankly, it wouldn't hurt my feelings if a MC (Member of Congress or Miserable Cuss?) were expelled for getting too many parking tickets.

Guard soldiers may go to border next week
Elmira Star-Gazette
"The first wave of about 800 National Guard soldiers will head to the U.S-Mexico border as early as next week, including planners and leadership personnel who will stay longer than the planned 21-day missions, the National Guard chief told lawmakers Wednesday. Lt. Gen. Steven Blum said 200 soldiers are preparing to go to each of the four border states -- California, Texas, Arizona and New Mexico -- around June 1. He said the initial troops will be part of a longer-term force of project managers who will stay on the job over time to provide continuity in the new border program." (05/24/06)

Later news stories in the week stated that troops WOULD be armed and would be in locations where they might have to defend themselves, apparently including engineers who would be constructing things right on the border. Despite cries of foul, it IS supposed to be the reason for our military to exist: to protect us against invasion. The original reason for our military was NOT to "project power" around the globe, institute "regime change" or even, defend our "allies." The line between invasion and simply free travel has often been confused in history, and no less today. But the wisdom of sending troops into a situation where the current administration has no idea exactly what they are doing is questionable to say the least.

Mama's Note: Not to mention the fact that this will mean the states have that many fewer National Guard troops available to perform their more legitimate roles. I don't know if fighting forest and brush fires is truly a legitimate NG role, but it is certainly more consistent with the idea that these troops belong to the individual states, not the federal government.

CA: Delicate immigration dance
San Francisco Chronicle
"When Mexican President Vicente Fox stars at an official state dinner in Sacramento on Thursday night -- during a trip that includes a visit with Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and a speech to the Legislature -- his famous 'enchilada completa' still won't be on the menu. That was the recipe for immigration reform that the Mexican president promised to lobby hard to achieve in his six-year administration: a guest worker program; a path to legalization for millions of Mexican immigrants, legal or illegal, in the United States; and agreements from both sides of the border to protect Mexican workers from human rights abuses." (05/24/06)

I see no more reason for the President of Mexico to be allowed to lobby DC than for the Chairman of the Politburo of China or the Queen of the UK to be allowed to do so. If either of the other two tried it, the screams of outrage would be ear-splitting - so what do we hear about Fox? As for "human rights" - talk to some Zapataistas and a good many other people in Mexico about which country protects human rights better.

Senate Passes Immigration Bill in 'Do Something' Spirit
CNSNews.com
The Senate voted 62-36 to pass an immigration reform bill on Thursday, with 23 Republicans voting for it, four Democrats voting against it, and just about everyone saying it's unclear what the final bill will look like, once the Senate and the House try to hammer out a compromise on their very different bills...

Notice that they no longer care whether it DOES anything or not - it just has to be passed, and then they can all race home for their Memorial Day week-long mini-vacation and crow about how they all be protecting us, y'betcha!


Anti-Gang Strategy Taking Shape at Justice Department
CNSNews.com
U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales has announced a new national strategy to crack down on violent street gangs. The government now believes there are more than 21,500 gangs in the U.S., And more than 700,000 gang members...

Hmmm. Does this include those in the blue and black suits with the funny hats? You know, you see them all the time, roaming the streets frittering their time away in customized, decorated cars paid for with stolen money - and sometimes just plain stolen. They also like donut shops, I'm told.

Mama's Note: The definition of "gang" can also easily be stretched to fit just about anyone. Do you meet with a few like minded folks at the gun range on a regular basis? Are you a "violent gang?" The "reasonable laws" made to control behavior we don't like will always be used against everyone eventually. The natural law against any aggressive action should be enforced by all of us, all the time. That's all the "law" we really need.

House Republican Pushes 'Free Market' Immigration Bill
CNSNews.com
A Republican congressman is touting yet another immigration bill - a "free market" bill, which is intended to strike a balance between amnesty and mass deportations. Essentially, the bill introduced by Rep. Mike Pence would separate illegal aliens into two groups: those who want to become citizens and those who want to come here for temporary jobs...

Something like this does have at least a glimmer of hope of reconciling the issue between open borders (free travel) and open immigration (free rides).

Mama's Note: I fail to see how this legislation does anything for a free market. Absent all this nonsense and the welfare state, those who want to work and become Americans would simply do so, and those who did not would either go home or starve. It really is that simple.

Nuclear smuggling "easy"
CNN News
On March 28, 2006, undercover investigators penetrated both northern and southern U.S. borders, and smuggled in enough radioactive material to produce two dirty bombs. Although monitors at border checkpoints were capable of detecting the radiological material, the agents were able to provide papers that they had counterfeited using a basic computer program, which allowed them to gain access to U.S. Soil Air cargo shipments on board of passenger aircraft within the U.S. are highly vulnerable to any misuse [according to a former DHS official]. Only a very small percentage of the goods are being inspected prior to getting on board an aircraft. To emphasize that the Netherlands, Great Britain and Israel inspect 100 percent of all air freight prior to departure.

Of course, since virtually ANY amount of material is enough to make a "dirty" bomb (that is, a conventional explosive bomb with radioactive material in its casing or around it so that it is scattered by the explosive and contaminates an area), this is hardly the hideous situation it is being made out to be. But as people who buy and bring drugs across borders can tell you, it is impossible to stop all smuggling.

New Orleans: Nagin reelected
BBC News
The people of the hurricane-hit US city of New Orleans have narrowly re-elected Ray Nagin to lead them as mayor. Mr Nagin won 52% of the vote in a second round run-off, beating fellow Democrat Mitch Landrieu.

Barf. Of course, this was very clearly a race between two evils, kinda like Sodom and Gomorroh having a vote to elect either Baal or Moloch "god of the year." New Orleans continues to deserve everything it gets, including four more years of Mr. Nagging.

Mama's Note: And some people still have hopes of electing a Libertarian government. Please...

Number of US inmates rises 2%
Indianapolis Star
"Prisons and jails added more than 1,000 inmates each week for a year, putting almost 2.2 million people, or one in every 136 U.S. residents, behind bars by last summer. The total on June 30, 2005, was 56,428 more than at the same time in 2004, the government reported Sunday. That 2.6 percent increase from mid-2004 to mid-2005 translates into a weekly rise of 1,085 inmates. Of particular note was the gain of 33,539 inmates in jails, the largest increase since 1997, researcher Allen J. Beck said. That was a 4.7 percent growth rate, compared with a 1.6 percent increase in people held in state and federal prisons." (05/21/06)

Please note that this does NOT include people on parole, people on permanent "offender lists", or people out on bail, not yet convicted or virtually all of Congress and the political appointees of this and the last administration.

Mama's Note: Just think about how many of these people are the sole breadwinners for their families, and how many could contribute significant skills toward building our economy as well. I wonder what percentage of them have been rightfully convicted of violent crime? Think of that next time you are asked to vote for more prisons.

Dixie Chicks withdraw apology
Raw Story
"'I apologized for disrespecting the office of the President. But I don't feel that way anymore. I don't feel he is owed any respect whatsoever,' Dixie Chicks' Natalie Maines tells TIME's music critic Josh Tyrangiel, of her remark to a London audience in 2003: 'Just so you know, we're ashamed that the President of the United States is from Texas.' Time's cover story, 'Radical Chicks,' hits newsstands Monday, May 22nd. 'I got hot from my head to my toes -- just kind of this rush of 'Ohhh's,' says Dixie Chick Emily Robison of Maines' 2003 statement. 'It wasn't that I didn't agree with her 100%; it was just, 'Oh, this is going to stir something up.'' The first single from the Dixie Chicks' new album, Taking the Long Way is called 'Not Ready to Make Nice."' (05/21/06)

How on earth have we created a society in which it is considered appropriate and front-cover news for a pop-music singer's childish criticisms of the leader of the country. No matter how bad he is (and I'm not arguing that), a society in which entertainers are looked on as icons and role models and political pundits is a sick and degraded society.

Mama's Note: I certainly object to the idea that such people actually influence anyone, but their right to speak their mind about anything should not be in question. How anyone can give credence to such yo-yo opinions is quite beyond me.

TN: Group wants voter OK on taxes
Tennessean
"Metro Nashville property tax increases would require voter approval under an initiative that organizers say has the shoe leather and signatures to force a November referendum. The group that quashed a state tax on wages in 2001 has set its sights on Nashville's property taxes, which jumped as much as 5 percent in some areas last year after a vote of the Metro Council. Ben Cunningham of Old Hickory, a leader in the state and local efforts, says that 6,500 signatures have been gathered. The group will likely need about 4,000 valid signatures, but a final number won't be known until after the Aug. 3 primary election. Turnout will dictate the number of signatures needed for a Nov. 7 ballot measure. The local effort is part of a national movement for voter approval of tax increases -- born of California's Proposition 13, a constitutional amendment approved by the voters in 1978 that capped property tax rates." (05/21/06)

I've been kept informed of this campaign since before it officially started, and wish them the very best. It is a START, but a good one, and part of that was keeping it under the radar of the Tennessean and other groups, companies, and persons who benefit from the upward spiral of taxation, and the criminally high levels we already have. It is being pushed, correctly, as a "TABOR" (Taxpayers Bill of Rights) but more action will be needed, as Colorado's rejection of much of TABOR last year shows.

Gasoline prices finally fall, but not much
Houston Chronicle
"The average retail price of a gallon of gas fell about 1.45 cents across the nation during the past two weeks, the first drop since prices began a steady climb in late February, according to a survey released today. Self-serve regular averaged about $2.93 a gallon, down from about $2.95 two weeks ago, said Trilby Lundberg, who publishes the nationwide Lundberg Survey of roughly 7,000 gas stations. The average price of mid-grade was $3.03 a gallon, down from $3.04." (05/21/06)

Right. Why do I doubt this? Just because prices went UP a nickel in my area in the last week?

Mama's Note: I paid $2.72 a gallon this weekend in Worland, WY - up from $2.69 the week before in Newcastle. I suspect that some of the high price is due to the holiday, but at least it's still far below the national average.

Bin Laden: Moussaoui not linked to 9/11
San Francisco Examiner
"Osama bin Laden purportedly said in an audio tape Tuesday that neither Zacarias Moussaoui -- the only person convicted in the U.S. for the Sept. 11 attacks -- nor anyone held at Guantanamo had anything to do with the al-Qaida operation. 'He had no connection at all with Sept. 11,' the speaker claiming to be bin Laden said in the tape posted on the Internet. 'I am the one in charge of the 19 brothers and I never assigned brother Zacarias to be with them in that mission,' he said, referring to the 19 hijackers." (05/23/06)

Of course we believe you, Osama. Just like we believed Moussaoui. Our judges, attorneys, and juries are the most gullible in the world.

Government keeps info from defense in terror cases
USA Today
"Government lawyers are refusing to allow defense attorneys in terrorism-related cases to see court filings on whether warrantless surveillance was used to obtain information against their clients, defense attorneys said. The legal disputes represent a new obstacle for defense attorneys in terrorism cases as the legality of the National Security Agency's surveillance programs is challenged in U.S. courtrooms." (05/22/06)

All's fair in "love and war"?

Mama's Note: One of the bedrock principles for justice - enshrined in the Constitution and centuries of common law - is the requirement that ALL of the evidence be presented to the jury, both for and against the accused. Anyone with the IQ of a bean should be able to see that there can be no justice at all when evidence is hidden. But then, you already knew that there was no justice in this country, didn't you?

LA: Police shot mentally disabled man in back
CNN
"Autopsy results obtained by CNN show a mentally disabled man was shot in the back when he was killed by New Orleans police in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. This contradicts testimony by a police sergeant that the victim had turned toward officers and was reaching into his waistband when shot. 'Clearly he was shot from behind,' said famed New York pathologist Dr. Michael Baden, who examined the body for the family's lawyer." (05/22/06)

It takes a household-name to do the autopsy to prove that the NOPD are a bunch of thugs? Maybe that's why we didn't find all those tens of thousands of dead that everyone claimed - the cops ATE 'em!

Rice lauds BC critics' right to speak
Boston Globe
"On the eve of her controversial commencement speech at Boston College, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice celebrated her critics' right to object to her presence. But she defended the Bush administration's actions in Iraq and challenged her critics' assertions that the Iraq war clashed with Catholic morals. 'Christians are of course on both sides of the argument about the use of force -- when it is indeed just to use force and when it is not,' she said at a news conference yesterday. 'We have overthrown a dictator who brutalized his population. ... Sometimes you have to get rid of really, really bad regimes,' she said. Boston College's announcement on May 1 that Rice would speak at graduation today and would receive an honorary law degree has divided the Jesuit college, and has underscored deep divisions between liberal and conservative Catholics." (05/22/06)

Her words would be more comforting if her actions matched her words. At the same time, will her opponents (and those who oppose the Iraqi occupation) give her the same respect that she is giving them, at least in this speech? And which tack will the rest of the Bush Administration, and a Rice Administration, take? More than a single speech is needed.

Thomas: Bush is in "real trouble"
Raw Story
"'Just how bad are things for President Bush?' asks the New York Daily News in Monday editions. 'Pretty bad, I'd say, if even Clarence Thomas is worried about him.' Excerpts: The other night at a Washington book party for the President's sister, Doro Bush Koch, the Supreme Court justice arrived with his wife, Ginny, on the tented roof of the Hay Adams Hotel, overlooking the White House, and made a beeline for the author. 'We have to pray for your brother. He's in real trouble,' Thomas told a wide-eyed Koch, whose older brother is, indeed, suffering from near-catastrophic public-opinion ratings. Koch - whose memoir of the first President Bush is 'My Father, My President: A Personal Account of the Life of George H.W. Bush' -- politely thanked Thomas and kept a stiff upper lip." (05/22/06)

Is Thomas worried about the poll ratings? Somehow, I don't think so - but he might be worried about other problems the Bush Administration has. Thomas is not the perfect Justice, but he does have his good points. Wonder if the President will listen?

Cheney may be called in CIA leak case
Winston-Salem Journal
"Vice President Dick Cheney could be called to testify in the perjury case against his former chief of staff, a special prosecutor said in a court filing Wednesday. Special Counsel Patrick Fitzgerald suggested Cheney would be a logical government witness because he could authenticate notes he jotted on a July 6, 2003, New York Times opinion piece by a former U.S. ambassador critical of the Iraq war." (05/25/06)

Once more, there is a strange disconnect here regarding what is worth prosecuting and what is not. I suppose Cheney could claim the same sort of immunity from the justice system that the Congrus-kritturs are claiming. Now, wouldn't that be fun?

Navy shoots down a long-range missile
CNN
"For the first time, a Navy ship at sea successfully shot down a long-range missile in its final seconds of flight, the military said Wednesday. The test was seen as an important step toward giving ships the ability to shoot down weapons as they are about to hit their targets. Until now, the Standard Missile 2 was only launched from ships to intercept a long-range missile in the early or middle stage of flight. For the test, a missile fired from the Pacific Missile Range Facility on Kauai was destroyed in its final stage by an SM-2 launched from USS Lake Erie." (05/24/06)

Good news, if it can be replicated. Defense is always to be preferred.

Mama's Note: Ah, pardon me for asking a possibly dumb question, but why in the world wait until the final seconds? I'd think exploding a big missile, especially one with a nuclear head, would best be done as far away from the target as possible - not on top of it. What happened to long range detection of these things?.

Our Imperial Courts
There is NO branch of American governments, from the local township right up to Babylon-on-Potomac that doesn't do its best to limit our freedoms and destroy our liberties, but the judicial system seems more effective even than the other two. This week, a few examples of how the "justice system" is working hard at destroying our freedoms and our society, even the very rule of law that they supposedly exist to preserve.

Judge says man too small for prison
Tallahassee Democrat
"A judge said a 5-foot-1 man convicted of sexually assaulting a child was too small to survive in prison, and gave him 10 years of probation instead. His crimes deserved a long sentence, District Judge Kristine Cecava said, but she worried that Richard W. Thompson, 50, would be especially imperiled by prison dangers. ... Thompson will be electronically monitored the first four months of his probation ... " (05/25/06)

Could I suggest a speedy execution? Or maybe just a castration to go along with his probation? Or how about confinement as a ward nurse's aid in a geriatric facility?

Mama's Note: For pity sake! This can't be the only 5' 1" man in prison - and what makes this particular "size" more vulnerable? Would one more inch of height make him safe? EVERYONE is "imperiled" by prison dangers, including the guards. It is one of the most brutal and dangerous places on earth - which once again makes me wonder just why so many people seem to think that's a good place to put so many of our sons and daughters...

Supreme Court: Police don't need warrants in emergencies
USA Today
"The Supreme Court reaffirmed Monday that police can enter homes in emergencies without knocking or announcing their presence. Justices said four Brigham City, Utah, police officers were justified in entering a home after peeking through a window and seeing a fight between a teenager and adults. Chief Justice John Roberts, writing for the unanimous court, said that officers had a reasonable basis for going inside to stop violence. The decision overturned a ruling by Utah's Supreme Court that said a trial judge was correct to throw out charges stemming from the police search." (05/22/06)

While this just reaffirms past decisions, it still leaves a bad taste in my mouth. There is a tremendous difference between a peace officer barging in to save a life and restore peace, and a "law enforcement officer" using an emergency as an excuse to go in and bust heads and enforce the law. Of course, if the Utah Supremes' had any common sense, they would have read and used their own constitution first, and NOT the Federal one: Utah's is much more specific and supportive of a right to be free from police abuse than the US Bill of Rights is.

More News and Commentary on Page 2

Nathan Barton is writing from his secret bunker complex on the eastern slopes of the Paha Sapa, swilling Doctor Pepper (and gallons of water each day, milady) and plotting to reelect Gaius Julius Caesar dictator of the Republic - or was that Senator Palpatine? Granville James Corbin? W? Q?

Be sure to visit my blog, Liberty's Outpost.

Special Feature! Add your signature to the NEW Declaration of Independence
By Robert Greenslade

Several people have asked about buying Gadsden Flags (the rattlesnake "Don't Tread on Me flags used by the June 23d Movement and other Property Rights Organizations: you can get them for $10.00 plus shipping here.


To Read previous Commentaries, go to the archives page and click onto the link for the day. The commentaries are linked from the daily front pages.


Your feedback is always welcome! Please use the form below. If you enter your email address, the author can respond to your comment. Not all feedback can be answered personally, of course, but you will find most of it on the Mailbag page. Please allow at least one week for it to be published. Thanks for reading The Price of Liberty!

Please note: Information about readers is never given or sold to anyone for any purpose. Remember, however, that many people can read and recover anything posted to web sites or email unless it is carefully encrypted. MamaLiberty)

Visit the Rational Review News Digest

Links to Previous
Commentaries
are on the front page for each day. Check the archives page.

[Some article sources require registration, use this link)


Submit Feedback

Name: