Libertarian Commentary on The News by Nathan A. Barton - Price of Liberty
11/21/08
Libertarian Commentary on The News
By Nathan A. Barton © 2006


Mission Statement
Revised 8.04.04
 
Editorial Policy Revised 3.19.04
 
See Reader's
Feedback
 
Reader's Forum
 
Looking for Health NEW
 
Commentary
on the News
 
Return to Home Page

January 02, 2006

Libertarian Commentary on the News, Week of 25-30 December MMV (2005)
Last week of the year MMV, and on to MMVI! Nasty things happening out there: freedom is still within our grasp, however. Sadly, that is NOT the case in much of the world. On a scale of 0 to 10 (tyranny incarnate to a truly libertarian (anarcho-conservative) society, the best anyone can do (Switzerland, maybe) is about 3.9 or 4 - the US is maybe a 3, the UK just dropped to about 2, and much of the world is at 1.0 or 1.1, while a few sad-sack nations are at 0.002 or so: North Korea, Saudi Arabia, and Syria.

The Fall of Europe
We start with five stories from our neighbors and cousins to the east, the first one of which is probably the most important - and a warning to Americans. MMV has not been a good year for Europe in general and for the UK in particular, as these stories remind us. And don't expect it to get better in the new year with all this to face.

UK: Now you can be arrested for any offence
Telegraph [UK]
"Police are to be given sweeping powers to arrest people for every offence, including dropping litter, failure to wear a seat belt and other minor misdemeanours. The measures, which come into force on Jan 1, are the biggest expansion in decades of police powers to deprive people of their liberty. At present, officers can generally arrest people if they suspect them of committing an offence which carries at least five years in prison. They will now have the discretion to detain someone if they suspect any offence and think that an arrest is "necessary". The civil liberties organisation Liberty said the change represented "a fundamental shift" in power from the public to the police and the state and was open to misuse." (12/29/05)

With the population basically disarmed, with hooligans running wild (and for that matter, often running the country), and with the Lords and the Monarch completely stripped of power, there is nothing that Her Majesty's subjects can do about this except endure it and pray that someone - Ireland, the US, Belize, SOMEONE will come and rescue them. Sadly, because of the hooligans and thugs and Islamicists running around, far too many people are very much IN FAVOUR of this police state. Furthermore, it is NOT a "major" change, but (like the proverbial frog, it represents a change from a heat level of 5 to one of perhaps 6 or maybe 7.

UK: Battle of Tony's cafe begins Olympic revolt
Independent [UK]
"The bailiffs forced the till shut six months ago and took the tables and chairs. There is no water or electricity and the roof has fallen in. But the regulars at Francesca's Cafe on Broadway Market in Hackney, east London, keep coming back. A dozen locals felt so strongly about plans to demolish the Italian diner, known as Tony's, that they broke into the premises on Boxing Day to save it. Protesters now say that they hope to rebuild it. About 60 of them are occupying it in shifts to stop workmen from completing the demolition they began last week. This battle is not really about Tony's cafe, however -- nice as the pasta and roast dinners may have been. Calogero 'Tony' Platia, the burly 55-year-old Sicilian who ran No 34 for three decades, has simply become the popular figurehead for locals fighting against outside property developers keen to cash in on rising prices." (12/30/05)

Like the US, the UK has problems with eminent domain and "economic redevelopment." As in the US, British subjects are becoming a bit more aggressive about defending themselves against these problems. Sadly, given how much freedom has already been lost in the UK, I give them little chance of accomplishing anything. We see a similar process in the pro-hunting protests which also broke out on Boxing Day. Now, of course, these people can be rounded up by the coppers and hauled away, under the new laws (see previous and next article).

UK: Thousands turn out to defy hunting ban
Guardian [UK]
"Some landowners may be denying police access to fields and woods in order to shield illegal hunts from prosecution, animal welfare groups suggested yesterday. The allegation surfaced as tens of thousands of riders and spectators braved the cold for the first traditional Boxing Day meetings held since hunting with dogs was banned. The Home Office is now coming under pressure to strengthen the Hunting Act, which critics on both sides of the blood sports controversy describe as unenforceable." (12/27/05)

We will soon no doubt see bobbies killing hunters (or suspected hunters) to prevent the harassment of foxes, as this stupid idea is "enforced." And of course, all of these people, their horses, their dogs, and no doubt their children, drivers, and probably their stable lads and ferriers can all be rounded up by the bobbies (see the first article in this section).

Europe "behind on Kyoto pledges"
BBC News [UK]
"The UK is almost alone in Europe in honouring Kyoto pledges to cut greenhouse gases, a think-tank claims. Ten of 15 European Union signatories will miss the targets without urgent action, the Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR) found. The countries include Ireland, Italy and Spain. France, Greece and Germany are given an 'amber warning' and will not reach targets unless they put planned policies into action, the IPPR said." (12/27/05)

This reminds me of the parable of the two sons - one of which agreed to do what his father wanted but did not; and the other who did not accept the instructions but ended up doing it anyway. Both were condemned. So far, the US is taking the honorable course, at least - we don't agree with Kyoto (or at least Congress doesn't) and so aren't playing the game. But I am more interested in seeing how the nations of Europe respond - if they just shrug off the targets, they show that Kyoto is really about power, and NOT about mythical global warming.

UK: New crackdown on prostitution
Guardian [UK]
"The government will announce plans next month for a national zero tolerance campaign against kerb crawlers and street prostitution after shelving plans to introduce licensed 'red light' zones, the Guardian has learned. The proposals are expected to form a key part of the next phase of Tony Blair's drive against antisocial behaviour. Kerb crawlers will risk having their driving licences confiscated and being named and shamed in local newspapers. The Home Office minister Fiona Mactaggart told the Guardian that it was wrong to regard those involved in prostitution as sex workers. She said tough measures were needed to tackle the markets for prostitution. 'I'm not tolerant of the view that prostitution is the oldest profession in the world and there's nothing we can do to reduce it,' she said. 'Prostitution blights communities. We will take a zero tolerance approach to kerb crawling. Men who choose to use prostitutes are indirectly supporting drug dealers and abusers. The power to confiscate driving licences already exists. We want the police to use that power more.'" (12/28/05)

It is, of course, amazing that people still resort to old-fashioned pickups and assignations - and pay in cash, no doubt. Of course, actions like this WILL drive it to the web and de facto red light zones, where it will continue to flourish and be even more likely to become slavery. Notice how the arguments are the same over and over again, and how many of them are actually self-fulfilling prophecies. I agree that prostitutes and their johns are pretty lowlife, but perhaps not as lowlife as those that prey on them, including the Home Office and drug-dealers.

Government-Ruined, Theft-Funded Schools
History is a very important part of education - and like every other part of education, too important to be left to government. Those who write the histories are those who control the destiny of those that read those histories, so these two stories should be of concern.

UK: German history syllabus 'doesn't mention the war'
Independent [UK]
" The Cold War would replace the Second World War in secondary school classrooms under a syllabus published today on how to teach German history. The new unit, designed for 11 to 14-year-olds, is in recognition of the criticism that too much time is being spent on studying Hitler in history lessons and - as a result - UK youngsters are building up a picture of today's Germany as being full of goose-stepping Nazis. .... The new "don't mention the war" syllabus comes a week after an official report from the Qualifications and Curriculum Authority - the Government's exams watchdog which has devised the new syllabus - repeated claims that the study of Hitler was dominating GCSE and A-level history lessons." (12/27/05)

If this were in Germany, it might make (very twisted) sense (as a similar failure to mention WW2 in Japan does). Keep in mind that Germany still has essentially the old Prussian system of education, and the government controls everything - while home-schoolers are often prosecuted and persecuted, and even private schools (that are not state-affiliated church-run schools) are almost nonexistent. There IS no choice, and so we will see the dumbing down continue.

But the UK is not much better off - and the GCSE applies both to "public" (what we would call private) schools and to the general school system - and even to home-schoolers. This will ensure that the consequences of measures such as the new police powers act will not be learned, and so can be repeated by British politicians indefinitely.

Mama's Note: A friend was telling me why it was economically "impossible" to homeschool or send her three children to private school - besides the fact that they wouldn't have the sports, music and "social interaction" they have in government schools. (Of course, she doesn't use the words "government schools.") She was confident that she and her husband could teach their children whatever was lacking and instill in them the moral fiber needed to live a good Christian life.

A few days later she was sharing with me her concern for her children. Seems the middle boy - who had been a model alter server and wanted to be a priest - now hangs out with the wrong crowd and refuses to go to church. All three children have told her they will not go to church after they are 18. How sad, and tragic that she refuses to see the connection.

Textbooks begin judging Clinton impeachment
Fox News
"The impeachment of former President Clinton is in a gray area of history, too long ago to be a current event, too recent to be judged in perspective. Yet history is already judging Clinton in the place where millions of students get their information about him: textbooks. Seven years after he was impeached in a scandal of sex, perjury and bitter politics, Clinton has become a fixture in major high school texts. The impeachment is portrayed in the context of his two-term tenure, a milestone event, but not one that overshadows how Clinton handled the economy, crime and health care." (12/27/05)

My own personal view is that anything that happened less than 20 years ago and has to do with government, politics, or economics should be taught as part of classes on government (civics) and economics, NOT as part of history. History, especially American and US History, should concentrate on events much earlier - to help students understand more about how we got into this mess than what a mess we are in. It is an interesting contrast between the US and UK: we have just enough competition in most of the country in the education field to keep the No-Hitler history syllabus from becoming a reality - and enough to keep the liberals from whitewashing Clinton the way they do FDR and "Honest" Abe But if we ever go to a "national standard" as the No Child Left Behind Act points, we will see this kind of debate go away, just as the debate on evolution is going away in some parts of the nation.

Mama's Note: Do you really think that we would know anything about the true history of Europe and Asia if powerful central governments had been able to write - and teach - ALL the history throughout the last 5,000 years? Most people learned what history they knew by word of mouth, one generation to the next. Even so, very little of recorded history is truly complete - or accurate - and a great deal of it has been totally lost. Remember that the victors of every conflict write the history.

The Home Front
Our internal battles here in the US continue.

Powell hints that warrants would have aided Bush
Boston Globe
"Colin L. Powell, the former secretary of state, yesterday said he supports government eavesdropping to prevent terrorism, but that a major controversy over presidential powers could have been avoided by obtaining court warrants. Powell said that when he was in the Cabinet, he was not told that President Bush authorized a warrantless National Security Agency surveillance operation after the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. Appearing on ABC's 'This Week,' Powell said he sees 'absolutely nothing wrong with the president authorizing these kinds of actions' to protect the nation. But he added, 'My own judgment is that it didn't seem to me, anyway, that it would have been that hard to go get the warrants. And even in the case of an emergency, you go and do it.'" (12/26/05)

Well, we already knew Powell was out of step with this Administration. The constitutional protections have been gutted, and a tame judge would grant whatever was "needed" - but now the time has seemingly come when even a façade is not acceptable and even the appearance of freedom from Big Brother must be removed.

Pentagon snooping fits state's post-9/11 pattern
San Mateo County Times
"President Bush's authorizing warrantless wiretaps within the United States grabbed headlines last week, but a pattern of domestic snooping stretches back to California and the weeks after 9/11. Almost daily, it seems, new revelations emerge about domestic surveillance programs. U.S. News & World Report reported Friday that the government has been secretly monitoring radiation levels at mosques and other private Muslim buildings in six U.S. cities outside California. The New York Times reported Thursday that undercover city police had infiltrated political protest groups in New York City. A week earlier NBC News reported that the Pentagon had assembled a 400-page database listing "threats" from domestic protesters, including the Quakers. The document listed 1,500 "suspicious incidents" over 10 months in 2004 and MMV (2005). An eight-page excerpt posted on the MSNBC Web site includes six entries in California, including protests at military recruiting offices at the University of California's Berkeley and Santa Cruz campuses. " (12/27/05)

As I point out in the last article's commentary, the velvet glove is wearing mighty thin. This is typical of America's wars, unfortunately, from the American Revolution on - a very few wars have NOT seen this rise in tyranny and dehumanization of both the enemy and those Americans seen as soft on the enemy, from raids and lynching of Tories in the Mid-Atlantic and New England in the American Revolution through killing of "Injun-lovers" during the Indian Wars, to the abuse of Copperheads during the War Between the States, the tarring, feathering, and killing of German-speaking Americans and pacifists in the Great War, the internment of Japanese in World War Two, and the cries of "Babykiller" during 'Nam. And it is NOT all government, by any means - much is due to the perverse nature of humans which only liberty and responsibility can seem to contain and protect us from.

Mama's Note: Which wars did not see tyranny and dehumanization - on both sides? Tyranny and dehumanization are among the words that define "war" to start with.

New Orleans: Police chief backs shooting
CBS News
"The knife-wielding man shot to death by police in a daylight confrontation that was caught on videotape had a long arrest record, the police chief said Wednesday. Anthony Hayes, 38, was shot Monday after allegedly lunging at police with a 3-inch blade. Part of Hayes' confrontation with 18 officers, though not the shooting itself, was videotaped by at least three bystanders. Hayes is seen waving his arms and brandishing the knife." (12/28/05)

Can someone explain how big bad cops should be so afraid of a guy with a three-inch blade in broad daylight that they have to gun him down? Of course, what we've seen of NO police, they would probably have been unable to defend themselves without artillery to back them up.

Phone giants mum on spying
Orlando Sentinel
"In the days following revelations that the Bush administration ordered the National Security Agency to spy on domestic telephone and Internet communications without a court order, one involved party has remained silent. The nation's telephone giants--which control the data pipelines--have neither commented on nor denied their reported participation, nor have they reacted to the charge that they may have been complicit in violating privacy rights. But historically the telecom companies have cooperated with the government on wholesale wiretapping, and the Bush administration's anti-terrorism programs appear to be no exception. Without commenting directly on a classified topic, industry officials--when asked--suggested that they would not stand in the way of a request for help." (12/29/05)

Nothing new here - anyone who understands the system knows what is going on.

World Wars
Our Home Front and the Mideast Tarbabies are just part of a larger, global series of conflicts, which we are all involved in, like it or not.
Fighting isn't limited just to the States, or just to the Middle East. Some of these stories are related directly to those conflicts. But the fight for liberty and for tyranny continues around the world.

Guantanamo hunger strike numbers surge
National Nine News [Australia]
"The number of Guantanamo Bay prisoners taking part in a nearly five-month-long hunger strike has surged to 84 since Christmas Day, the US military says. Forty-six detainees at the prison for foreign terrorism suspects at the US naval base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, joined the protest on the key Christian holiday last Sunday, said Army Lieutenant Colonel Jeremy Martin, a military spokesman. ... 'There's been a significant increase in the number that have been added to the hunger strike,' Martin said. Lawyers for some of the detainees call the strike a protest of the conditions in which the prisoners are being held and their lack of legal rights. Medical personnel were force-feeding 32 of the hunger strikers with plastic tubes inserted into the stomach through the nose, the military said." (12/30/05)

Through history, most prisoners of war ("detainees") have not had the opportunity for hunger strikes, since usually the problem has been not getting enough to eat to stay alive - look at North Vietnam, various Stalags, or Andersonville or one of the dozens of Federally-run POW camps during the War Between the States. This is, of course, the fault again of the FedGov, which can't decide whether these people are criminals or prisoners of war (or both, as the Soviet Union decided that Wehrmacht prisoners were during WW2).

Mama's Note: I'd like someone to explain exactly what the government expects to gain by keeping these people prisoners at all, much less under inhuman conditions. What ARE the actual conditions? Then, what is this "hunger strike" all about and what do the prisoners hope to gain by it? With all that information out on the table, maybe we could begin to discuss all of this more rationally.

Pentagon shakes up emergency hierarchy
Yahoo! News
"Heading a military service isn't quite the position of power it used to be. In a Bush administration revision of plans for Pentagon succession in a doomsday scenario, three of Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld's most loyal advisers moved ahead of the secretaries of the Army, Navy and Air Force. A little-noticed holiday week executive order from President Bush moved the Pentagon's intelligence chief to the No. 3 spot in the succession hierarchy behind Rumsfeld. The second spot would be the deputy secretary of defense, but that position currently is vacant. The Army secretary, which long held the No. 3 spot, was dropped to sixth. The changes, announced last week, are the second in six months and reflect the administration's new emphasis on intelligence gathering versus combat in 21st century war fighting." (12/29/05)

I suppose this might also be likened to "rearranging deck-chairs on the Titanic." Others might liken it to deciding which kindergartner takes over the classroom when the teacher is gone. Assuming Congress has not dictated the order (their typical micromanagement), it seems to be the boss's prerogative who goes first, etc. Since competence is not a requirement for political appointments (which all of these are), then loyalty is as good a factor as any, I suppose.

Libyan court orders retrial of Bulgarian nurses
Sydney Morning Herald
"Libya's Supreme Court has overturned death sentences against five Bulgarian nurses and a Palestinian doctor and ordered them retried on charges of infecting children with the HIV virus, in an attempt by Libya to resolve a case that has poisoned its ties with the West. Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi is believed to have been looking for face-saving way out of the standoff over the case, which brought condemnations from Europe and the United States and stalled his campaign to bring his country out of its international pariah status. The verdict, welcomed by Bulgaria, came after European and Libyan negotiators reached a deal by which the West will provide aid to families of the 426 children infected in the 1990s with the virus that causes AIDS. About 50 of the children have reportedly died." (12/26/05)

This is a sick little "government" deal to try and regularize relations with Gaddafi, at the expense of a number of people who were in the wrong place at the wrong time, trying to help a population that wants them dead - sort of like American and other coalition troops in Iraq. Children who have AIDS or have died of it because of dark-age medical procedures and a complete lack of decent infection control supposedly are the victims of an urban-legend style plot to kill off the Arab people. While this court has ordered a new trial, a rescue may yet be needed.

Russia: Dozens treated after apparent chemical attack
Sydney Morning Herald [Australia]
"More than 70 people were sickened by an unidentified gas released in a store in Russia's second-largest city on Monday. Boxes with wires and timers attached to containers possibly holding gas were found in other outlets of the chain, officials said. A spokesman for the Emergency Situations Ministry, Viktor Beltsov, said 78 people sought medical care and 66 of them were hospitalised." (12/26/05)

This was due, or so it is claimed, to "business rivals" and NOT to terrorists. But if you have business rivals that are willing to poison customers to get them to go buy from them, it seems to me that they are still thugs, yes, and terrorists. Who has taught businesses to compete like this? Government, of course.

Mama's Note: I smell a very large, dead rat here. Nobody in business gets any benefit whatsoever from dead or sick customers! The entire story is so crude and stupid that it is impossible to believe. Russia is famous for this kind of thing.

Sri Lanka: Ten soldiers killed by mine
Reuters
"Fueling fears of a return to civil war, suspected Tamil Tiger rebels killed 10 soldiers in the island's far north on Tuesday in the second mine attack in less than a week, the military said. The blast followed a string of guerrilla ambushes on the military and the assassination of a pro-rebel member of parliament at a Christmas mass that are straining a 2002 truce to breaking point." (12/27/05)

How short our memories are! A year ago, Ceylon was trying desperately to recover from one of the worst natural disasters of the last century, and Tamils and other folks working together, but today, the damnable desire of some humans to have power over others is leading back to a mess.

Israel: Air raids target Gaza Strip
International Herald Tribune
"The Israeli military on Tuesday fired a barrage of artillery and missiles at the Gaza Strip, hitting two offices of the militant Al Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades and a bridge the army said was used by militants to reach areas where they fire rockets. Hours later, about two dozen armed Al Aqsa militants took over the governor's office and two other government buildings in northern Gaza -- the latest outbreak of lawlessness that has undermined the rule of Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas. Israel's pre-dawn aerial strikes were part of the army's attempt to halt rocket fire on Israeli towns bordering Gaza. Prime Minister Ariel Sharon has approved a buffer zone in northern Gaza, although the army said it has not yet implemented the plan. Enforcement -- including firing at anyone who enters the area -- is not likely to begin in the coming 12 hours, the army said." (12/27/05)

Speaking of messes, it is now obvious that once again the Israelis have been suckered in by the Palestinian "leadership" and their unreliable American allies. I am at a loss to suggest just how to resolve this situation, because inevitably one (or both) sides will have to lose - and losing means annihilation.

Chile: Pinochet ruled fit to stand trial
Washington Times
"Former Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet is fit to stand trial for the 1975 disappearances of six dissidents, judges have ruled. The Chilean Supreme Court on Monday rejected calls from Pinochet's lawyers that the 90-year-old was unfit to stand trial because he suffers from a number of maladies including dementia, El Mercurio newspaper reported Tuesday." (12/27/05)

While I think this is a fruitless effort and will accomplish nothing except a vague sense of "closure" for millions of taxpayer dollars, it does give one hope that one day, Clinton and many others will be brought to justice as well.

Mideast Tarbabies
News from the "center" of the planet in so many ways continues to sound very bad. The end of the year is a good time to remember that so much good and so much evil has come from the Middle East in the past - and is today

Israel: Frantic search for kidnap victims
Guardian [UK]
[Late news item from WND on Friday: this woman and her parents were freed by their captors. No word on what was given to get them released] "Palestinian investigators and British consular officials were last night urgently trying to make contact with the Palestinian group who abducted a British aid worker and her parents in the Gaza Strip, more than 24 hours after they disappeared. Unlike previous kidnappings of westerners in Gaza, usually resolved within hours, the kidnappers made no contact with the authorities to make demands or arrange for the release of Kate Burton, 25, and her parents Hugh and Helen. They were snatched by seven armed men in Rafah, a deprived town in a very poor area. ... Palestinian police set up roadblocks throughout the southern Gaza Strip and representatives of all sectors of Palestinian society, including Hamas, demonstrated for the release of Miss Burton and her parents." (12/30/05)

How like the Islamicists that lord over the so-called Palestinian lands - someone is there, with her family, idealistically trying to help, and so they are kidnapped for their efforts. Of course, this is a "deprived" and "very poor" area - like 99% of Arab lands and people in general, because of the thugs who rule. At the same time, these tactics are typical of anti-western guerilla movements of the past century, whether communist or some other flavor of totalitarian extremism. And generally they have worked well against the West - and don't work well against those who do this sort of thing or nonwestern societies, for two reasons: first, they don't produce the kind of aid volunteers that the West does; second, their "aid workers" are always armed because that IS the kind of aid they provide; and third, they don't care what happens to individuals just because they are people.

Iraq: Sunnis, Shiites decline talks, fighting continues
AM 940 Montreal [Canada]
"Sunni Arab and secular Shiite groups refused Thursday to open discussions with the Shiite religious bloc leading in Iraq's parliamentary elections until a full review of the contested results is carried out. ... In insurgent violence on Thursday, a suicide bomber detonated his explosives belt on a street near the Interior Ministry, killing one police officer and wounding four, police said. Earlier police said four people had been killed. Also in Baghdad, gunmen assassinated an Iraqi driver working with a French company, and a university student in northwestern Baghdad was killed in a drive-by shooting, police said. U.S. air strikes launched by two F-16 fighter jets in Kirkuk province killed 10 insurgents on Tuesday, the military said Thursday." (12/29/05)

Bloodletting continues. When you consider how blessed we are here in the United States and even in Canada to have avoided these sorts of situations for most of our history (the American and Texan Revolutions and the War Between the States (including Bleeding Kansas) being the notable exceptions), we should indeed be grateful. Imagine if Lee and the other CSA generals had NOT surrendered gracefully, or if the Nisei had opted to stay and fight for their homes in California. Or if Young and Conner had not sat down and negotiated in 1857.

Mama's Note: "Surrendered gracefully?" I don't understand that comment in the least. They surrendered under great duress because they refused to see the remnants of their people killed, perhaps not realizing the brutal treatment and degradation they would be subjected to afterwards. That "war" continued to be fought for many long years, and in some ways has never really been resolved. The bogus "free the slaves" idea has obscured the fact that every person in Confederate territory became a slave of the state upon that surrender.

Israel: Suicide bomber kills IDF soldier, civilians
Fox News
"A Palestinian homicide bomber trying to enter Israel blew himself up Thursday at a military checkpoint in the West Bank set up to foil the attack, killing an Israeli soldier and two other Palestinians. The army said it had set up the checkpoint shortly after receiving warnings that a homicide bomber was headed toward Israel. The bomber was traveling in a taxi that was stopped at the roadblock for a security check." (12/29/05)

As in Iraq, so in Israel. This seems to have been the "good news" in a proper response to a threat: the bomber could have set himself off in a crowded market instead of a remote temporary checkpoint. A later news story reported that the target was a children's Hanukah party. So much for "freedom fighters."

Kuwait: Death sentences for six in terror plot
Voice of America
"A Kuwaiti court handed down death sentences Tuesday, to six Islamists linked to the al-Qaida terror network. The six condemned men were among a group of 37 people accused of plotting to attack Kuwaiti security forces and U.S. troops in the Gulf emirate." (12/27/05)

Really al-Qaida, or just caught in the wrong place? Whichever, these people are very unlikely to be around long enough to get a Tookie Williams type sendoff, or to file charges for abuse and maltreatment as US detainees are able to.

Iraq: Inmates, guards killed in prison shootout
Reuters
"Four inmates and five security personnel were killed in a shootout at a Baghdad high-security jail after at least one prisoner grabbed a weapon and opened fire, the U.S. and Iraqi armies said. An American soldier was among six people wounded. There were varying accounts of casualties from other sources. ... Gunmen killed two soldiers and wounded seven in an ambush on an Iraqi army patrol .... A family of four, including two daughters and the parents, were stabbed to death by assailants in Hilla .... A civilian was killed and two wounded when U.S. forces shot at their car in Khalidiya, 85 km (53 miles) west of Baghdad, police said. The U.S. military said it was unaware of the incident. ... Three policemen were wounded when a car bomb attacked their patrol in the town of Samarra ..." (12/28/05)

The bloodshed continues, just as here in the US. I wonder if the family was even armed, or had they been stripped of their weapons by their religious opponents or some misguided occupation authority?

Our Imperial Courts
An important aspect of the "Home Front" is the battle for the judicial system. Five stories today point out some of the issues that we will see exploited or challenged in MMVI (2006).

Justices rule against woman who spanked
Rapid City Journal
Without ruling that spanking an unruly child with a belt goes beyond the boundaries of a state law allowing corporal punishment, the South Dakota Supreme Court decided that a Huron woman went overboard in correcting her daughter. The unanimous decision Thursday upheld an earlier ruling by Circuit Judge Jon Erickson, who said it was child abuse when the girl was struck several times on the buttocks with a belt.

It is almost as if this case were intentionally done to encourage South Dakota voters to approve a constitutional amendment initiated and just certified to be on the MMVI (2006) General Election ballot, called "J.A.I.L." (Judicial Accountability Initiated Law) which would create a special grand jury and process outside the traditional legal system, to investigate judicial misconduct. Of course this case started in August 2004, well before the petition drive even started. The woman spanked the 11-year-old six or seven times with a belt (no bruises) after the child continued to throw tantrums and disobey after a variety of other punishments including time-outs, grounding, and removal of privileges. The girl ran away from home and reported on her parents to the Department of Social Services, who prosecuted this woman.

Mama's Note: All of these people need to spend a few days walking the streets of downtown Los Angeles or any other major city. Those streets are full of people and youngsters who are homeless, involved in every kind of crime and vice, and have no future except for more of the same - or death - because they had no discipline or moral compas as children. God help them all.

New Mexico: "Absurd" ban on Letterman lifted
BBC News [UK]
"A judge in New Mexico has lifted a restraining order on talk show host David Letterman sought by a woman who said he sent her coded messages by TV. The Santa Fe resident had obtained the order on the grounds that Mr. Letterman had caused her mental cruelty for 11 years, forcing her to go bankrupt. ... She accused the host of using code words, gestures and 'eye expressions' to send her messages since she began sending him 'thoughts of love' after his Late Show programme began in 1993. One alleged message was for Ms Nestler to come east to New York to be trained as the Late Show's co-host." (12/28/05)

Yeah, this judge has at least some brains - but what about the imbecile who issued the restraining order in the first place? He has to be nuttier than the woman. And do you think he might get thrown out of office next time he comes up for retention? Please, be real.

Foes cite Alito's stance on liberty
Boston Globe
"During his years on the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, Judge Samuel A. Alito Jr. repeatedly tried to limit the court's interpretation of the 14th Amendment's protection of 'life, liberty, and property' -- one of the key legal underpinnings of the Roe v. Wade abortion case. The appeals court had ruled in a series of cases that the 14th Amendment protects people against arbitrary decisions by their local government, such as zoning board officials who deny permits for no good reason. Alito, now a nominee to the Supreme Court, rejected such rights, writing that 'only in extreme circumstances is it proper to invoke' 14th Amendment protections." (12/27/05)

I am of two minds on this, until I have a chance to study the issue more. The 14th Amendment was part of that hideous package of amendments passed by the Radical Republicans while their Democratic and Southern foes languished in jails or POW camps, and so has been tainted from the gitgo as part of Lincoln's "enslaving free men" program. Too, I know of no state constitution which does NOT have a bill of rights that provides for protection of life, liberty and property from local and state government (and should protect them from the feds, too, if the role of states versus fedgov were correctly defined).

Debate looms on citizen babies
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
"A proposal to change long-standing federal policy and deny citizenship to babies born to illegal immigrants on U.S. soil ran aground this month in Congress, but it is sure to resurface -- kindling bitter debate even if it fails to become law. At issue is 'birthright citizenship' -- provided for since the Constitution's 14th Amendment was ratified in 1868. Section 1 of that amendment, drafted with freed slaves in mind, says: 'All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States.' Some conservatives in Congress, as well as advocacy groups seeking to crack down on illegal immigration, say the amendment has been misapplied over the years, that it was never intended to grant citizenship automatically to babies of illegal immigrants. Thus they contend that federal legislation, rather than a difficult-to-achieve constitutional amendment, would be sufficient to end birthright citizenship." (12/27/05)

I am putting this in the Court section and not in Home Front because it also is a 14th Amendment issue, and is as complex as the above one. It should be up to states to define who is and is not a citizen, and then for the fedgov to apply the criteria.

Black Panther case shifts a debate on Alito
Boston Globe
"Supreme Court nominee Samuel A. Alito Jr., who has been accused by opponents of being hostile to civil rights claims, once urged the Reagan administration not to try to block a civil rights suit by the Black Panther Party against former government officials who had spied on the group, according to records released yesterday. The nominee's supporters said a 1981 memo by Alito, written while he was a Justice Department lawyer, cuts against his portrayal by left-wing groups as an ideologue who sided against civil rights suits whenever he has had the opportunity. Opponents, however, said the memo doesn't change their view of the nominee, given his overall record on civil rights matters." (12/29/05)

Both sides continue to grasp at straws and pour through kindergarten records for information to support or attack Alito.

Mama's Note: It's fast getting to the point where nobody but an absolute zero will be confirmed for anything. Integrity and the rule of law are the only criteria that should be considered.

Our Right to Defend Ourselves
We start out with a rare mention of defense rights in the popular media, and continue on to just a few of the 35,000 times it is estimated that people used weapons to defend themselves or prevent evil from being done this week. No question, the right to defend ourselves is on more people's minds around the world this week, especially here in the US. So, as usual, it is appropriate to look in some detail at things we can use to illustrations WHY it is so important, and what is being done to take it away from too many people.

MTV Program "Fair to Owners" but Not to Facts
CNSNews.com
A pro-gun lobbying group is complimenting MTV for treating law-abiding gun owners fairly in its "True Life: I'm a Gun Owner" documentary, which aired Thursday night. But Gun Owners of America argued that the producers featured misleading and inaccurate statistics and focused almost exclusively on antigun anecdotes, giving viewers a false impression about the effects of gun ownership in America. "Guns are a source of security, status, enjoyment and pride, but they also destroy lives," the program's narrator began. "Should one be in your home?" "They very well answered that question, unfortunately, in the minds of many of their viewers that 'No, you shouldn't have a gun in your home,'" Erich Pratt of Gun Owners of America said, "because there were no positive anecdotes or statistics that were presented."

MTV is definitely one of the best propaganda methods available to big government, big business, big environment, and big labor, so it is no surprise to see this result. Pratt gave a fair response, but his response will never be seen nor heard by MTV viewers, who are left with (as usual) a biased and incomplete picture of a vital issue.

Australia: Murder trial for woman who shot robber
Sydney Morning Herald [Australia]
"The security guard Karen Brown will stand trial for murdering a man who bashed and robbed her outside the Moorebank Hotel in July last year. A magistrate ruled on Friday that although it could be said she had a strong defence for killing William Aquilina, there was a reasonable prospect that a jury would reject her defence and convict her of murder." (12/24/05)

Of course, the jury will be "instructed" to follow the law and NOT to find what is right - the original purpose of the English jury. It doesn't matter if your own life or those of loved ones are in danger - in Australia, the wielder of a gun is evil incarnate.

Alabama: Man kills brother in DeKalb shooting
Huntsville Times
"A DeKalb County man was killed and his brother and sister-in-law were hurt in a gun battle Friday morning in Collinsville, a Sheriff's Department spokeswoman said. Gary Kenneth Craig, 57, died after being shot once or twice during a gunfight with his brother, James Earl Craig, 62, said investigator Rhonda Jackson. The brothers were neighbors in Collinsville. .... Jackson said an alcohol-related dispute led to James Craig removing his brother from his home. Gary Craig then got a rifle from his pickup truck and fired through his brother's front door, striking his brother and sister-in-law. James Craig returned fire, killing his brother, Jackson said." (12/24/05)

What a horrible incident! Drinking leads to so many troubles, of which this shooting is just one example. Fortunately, drinking like this usually, quickly or in the long run, leads the irresponsible drinker into a capital offense (stupidity defined as such). Still, I really feel the horror of having to shoot your own brother, even when there appears to be no choice.

Texas: Dallas store clerk shoots robbery suspect
Dallas Morning News
"A convenience store clerk shot a man who was trying to rob the store Tuesday afternoon in Old East Dallas. About 1:45 p.m., two men entered a Shell convenience store off Interstate 30 near Winslow Avenue and began to act suspiciously, police said. When the clerk saw one man reach for gun near his belt, the clerk shot him in the chest. The man was hospitalized in critical condition, and the other suspect fled." (12/27/05)

It happens every day, and far too many store workers are NOT armed, and so get hurt, killed, and robbed.

Washington: Suspect killed in failed robbery attempt
KXLY TV News
"Kootenai County sherriff's deputies were called to Lew's Smoke Shop at 6891 W. Seltice Way inside the Stateline Village Shopping Center at approximately 10-minutes before 8:00pm Monday. That's [sic] when the store clerk called to report that he had shot an attempted robber. When the officers and medical personnel arrived, they found an adult white male, wearing a ski mask, lying dead on the floor of the store, with a weapon inside the waist of his pants." (12/27/05)

As I've said above, too many store employees are getting shot and robbed - this kind of culling of the criminal population is sadly necessary.

Oklahoma: Teen shoots mom's estranged husband
KOTV News
"Authorities say a teenager shot his mother's estranged husband in the face when the Duncan man showed up at their home near Marlow. Stephens County Assistant District Attorney Dennis Gay says the woman had been granted a protective order against the shooting victim, whose name wasn't released yesterday. Gay said police weren't sure what led the 15-year-old boy to believe his mother was in danger but he told police he fired on the man to protect her." (12/27/05)

Apparently it was NOT his father - a sad situation in so many families today where relationships are so bizarre as to resemble the worse of past historical societies. Still, this kid had the guts to protect his loved ones.

Mama's Note: Here we go again with the criminal being called a "victim!" Words have meaning, and we need to do what we can to point out when words are used falsely or in the wrong context.

California: S.F. city attorney, NRA agree to delay for part of gun ban
Mercury News
"San Francisco City Attorney Dennis Herrera said today that the city will delay the implementation of part of an ordinance banning handguns for two months as part of an agreement with the National Rifle Association. Proposition H, which was approved by San Francisco voters by a margin of 58 to 42 percent on Nov. 8, had been scheduled to go into effect Jan. 1. Under the agreement announced today, part of the ordinance won't go into effect March 1. .... Under terms of the agreement, the NRA will refrain from seeking a temporary restraining order in the case, and accept a briefing schedule that will assure a hearing on the merits of the law in the San Francisco Superior Court by mid-February, according to the city attorney's office. Without such an agreement, a likely scenario would have required three court hearings: one on a temporary restraining order, another on a preliminary injunction, and still another on the merits of the legal challenge, according to the city attorney's office. Referring to a recent court ruling, Matt Dorsey, a spokesman for Herrera, said in a news release, 'After losing its case in the California Court of Appeal, the NRA finds itself unable to challenge Prop H before its effective date without resorting to procedural roadblocks.' "(12/29/05)

It is staggering that this is happening, and I was completely astounded to find that there is NO right to keep and bear arms in the California Constitution, which has in my opinion, the most lawyerly of any bill of rights or declaration of rights of any American constitution I have ever read - and "lawyerly" is NOT a complementary adjective as I use it - weasel-worded to the Nth degree. Still, even under the federal constitution, I cannot understand how New York's Sullivan Act or this piece of tripe can be upheld by any court, no matter how crooked.

Mama's Note: Anyone who cares at all for liberty and justice should get out of California NOW, while they still can. It won't be long before the unofficial criminals take over completely, especially in the cities, and honest people won't have anything but a fingernail file to protect themselves with because the official criminals will have confiscated everything else.

Colorado: Burglar falls twice running from armed homeowner
Channel 7 News
"Arapahoe County authorities say a 22-year-old man suffered serious head injuries Wednesday morning when he tried to run away from homeowner with a gun. Kris Gibson was taken to a hospital for treatment and then taken to jail. Authorities say Gibson broke into a home at Olathe Street and East Maplewood Avenue at about 4:30 a.m. The homeowner -- whose name hasn't been released -- said a noise woke him up and when he went to check it out, he saw someone downstairs. He grabbed his rifle and ran after the man. "The suspect ran from the house. The homeowner pursued him outside the residence. The homeowner fired a shot into the ground in an attempt to keep the person here," said Arapahoe County Sheriff Grayson Robinson. While trying to run away, the suspect fell twice. Gibson struck his head on the floor while running down the stairs in the house and fell again on an icy driveway outside the house. He left a bloody trail and was found lying down in a field a short distance away." (12/28/05)

See, sometimes you don't even have to hit them to hurt them. Kinda like barking squirrels, I guess.

Idaho: Smoke shop clerk fatally shoots masked intruder
Seattle Post Intelligencer
"Joseph Kalani Hatchie, 47, facing medical bills and eviction from his family's rental home in Otis Orchard, Wash., just east of Spokane, on Monday kissed his wife goodbye before leaving to drive his brother home. He then allegedly put on a gray ski mask just before 8 p.m. and walked into Lew's Smoke Shop in this northern Idaho border town and pointed his son's unloaded pellet gun at the clerk. The clerk reached under the counter and pulled out a .40 caliber semiautomatic and shot Hatchie 10 times, according to police. Lew's Smoke Shop had been robbed twice before in the last five years, according to the Kootenai County sheriff's office. On Tuesday, the department displayed the pellet gun - designed to look like a Walter P-9 semiautomatic - alongside real weapons. "We wanted to do this display just so you understand what this poor clerk saw last night and, in that split-second, what decision he had to make," sheriff's Capt. Ben Wolfinger said. He said the county prosecutor will determine whether the shooting was a justifiable homicide or if charges will be filed against the store clerk, who has not been identified." (12/29/05)

Ten times seems a wee bit excessive - this guy needs more training. Still, just because he emptied the magazine doesn't mean that the shooting was not justified. This county needs to decide VERY quickly to let this clerk off.

Wisconsin: Police treating shooting at club as self-defense
Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel
"A shooting that left one man dead and another critically injured in a bar early Saturday is being treated as a self-defense case, police spokeswoman Anne E. Schwartz said Tuesday. LaCharles Hester, 27, was killed and another man, 23, who was not identified, was wounded in the chest by a bartender .... The bar owner was trying to clear the bar when Hester pulled out a gun, fired into the ceiling and pointed the gun at the bartender and other people in the bar, Schwartz said. The bartender, 36, who was not identified, drew a gun from his holster and shot Hester in the back of the head, she said. The 23-year-old man then tried to take the gun away from the bartender and it fired, hitting the 23-year-old in the chest." (12/27/05)

I expect that a big deal will be made of the bartender shooting the man in the back of the head, but this is still clearly within justifiable self-defense AND defense of his patrons.

Florida: Man shoots home invader
First Coast News
"Police say a suspect was shot early Thursday morning by a man who was protecting his home and his pregnant wife. Police are calling it a home invasion robbery. A 17-year-old boy is in police custody, while his brother is in the hospital in critical condition. The two men allegedly parked their vehicle a few hundred yards from a home near a row of trees in MacClenny. They turned off the electricity to the home and unplugged the phone connection. Police say the suspects then walked up to the home and stole an anchor that was inside of a boat in a shed. They say the pair then used it to break the glass door in the back of the home. According to a police report, the owner of the home heard a noise and grabbed his gun from inside the house. Police say he stayed upstairs in the bedroom with his wife who is pregnant. The suspect then allegedly walked up the stairs to the bedroom with a flashlight and opened the bedroom door. That's when, police say, the victim fired his gun and shot the suspect. Officers arrived on the scene as the 17-year old was running to his vehicle. He is now in police custody. " (12/29/05)

"Boy" or "man"? This probably fits into the category of "old enough to do the crime, old enough to do the time" and the 17-year-old "boy" should be treated like the mad dog he is. I hope that a lot of other people learn their lesson from this.

North Carolina: Would be victim fights back
NBC 17 News
"Two suspected robbers got more than they bargained for Wednesday night when their intended victim fought back and wounded one of them, police said. Damian Powell was headed to an apartment on Farrington Drive, off Six Forks Road in north Raleigh, at about 8 p.m. Wednesday when two teens approached him, police said. One of the teens flashed a gun, and they demanded money, police said. Powell wasn't about to become a victim. He knocked the gun out of the teen's hand and ran to his car to get his own gun, police said. He and the would-be robbers then exchanged gunfire in the apartment complex parking lot, and Powell apparently wounded one of them as they fled, police said." (12/29/05)

Carry your weapons with you!!!

More News and Commentary on Page 2

Nathan Barton is a libertarian engineer and writer, enjoying the cooling evenings in the Rockies and the Four Corners, where "monsoon" rains cause some creeks to overflow their banks, but nothing like the mess down in the South. His views are his own and do not necessarily represent the views of anyone else, including the sources of his news and other libertarians! Be sure to visit my blog, Liberty's Outpost.

Special Feature! Add your signature to the NEW Declaration of Independence
By Robert Greenslade

Several people have asked about buying Gadsden Flags (the rattlesnake "Don't Tread on Me flags used by the June 23d Movement and other Property Rights Organizations: you can get them for $10.00 plus shipping here.


To Read previous Commentaries, go to the archives page and click onto the link for the day. The commentaries are linked from the daily front pages.


Your feedback is always welcome! Please use the form below. If you enter your email address, the author can respond to your comment. Not all feedback can be answered personally, of course, but you will find most of it on the Mailbag page. Please allow at least 48 hours for it to be published. Thanks for reading The Price of Liberty!

Please note: Information about readers is never given or sold to anyone for any purpose. Remember, however, that many people can read and recover anything posted to web sites or email unless it is carefully encrypted. MamaLiberty)

Whose values?

Visit the Rational Review News Digest

Links to Previous
Commentaries
are on the front page for each day. Check the archives page.

[Some article sources require registration, use this link)


Submit Feedback

Name: