Libertarian Commentary on The News by Nathan A. Barton - Price of Liberty
11/21/08
Libertarian Commentary on The News
By Nathan A. Barton © 2005


Mission Statement
Revised 8.04.04
 
Editorial Policy Revised 3.19.04
 
See Reader's
Feedback
 
Reader's Forum
 
Looking for Health NEW
 
Commentary
on the News
 
Return to Home Page

November 28, 2005

Thanksgiving Libertarian Commentary on the News for Week of 20-26 November 2005
For all our problems in the American Union today, I still count my blessings and give thanks that my family and I are not in most of the rest of the world. Curtailed as our freedoms are, and as fervently as we long for and work for a new birth of liberty in this land, we cannot help but be grateful that we have kept as much and lost as little as we have. This week, we again need to remember that our liberties are dependent on our efforts to keep them!

Government-run, Taxpayer-funded Schools
A few items to start out, today, tied with other news of interest.

Rhode Island: Schools fail on recruitment notification
NBC 10 News
"Rhode Island school districts have been put on notice that they must clarify their policies regarding military recruitment in schools. NBC 10's Kelley McGee reported that a provision in the No Child Left Behind Act gives military recruiters access to student information unless their parents sign a form that allows students to opt out of the process. This form is supposed to be sent home with every student, but a recent survey of Rhode Island schools by the American Civil Liberties Union found otherwise. 'The one thing that's very clear is that the vast majority of parents and students had no idea that this information about them was being released to the military without their knowledge,' said Steven Brown, executive director of the ACLU's Rhode Island affiliate." (11/22/05)

I know I'm preaching to the choir, but you HAVE to get your kids out of these schools. At the same time, if these parents pay so little attention to the news and the world around them that they don't know military recruiters can get the info unless they act, they are probably also too lacking to get their kids out.

Colorado: Charter student suspended for making gun comment
Durango Herald
"An Excel Charter School student has received a 10-day in-school suspension for making a comment about bringing guns to school. The student was frustrated with a teacher on Wednesday and said "this is why kids bring guns to school," according to Deborah Uroda, spokeswoman for Durango School District 9-R. Uroda wouldn't release the student's age or grade level. Excel has 111 students enrolled in grades 6-12. After the comment, an Excel secretary called authorities, and a Durango Police Department officer spoke with the student. The student's father was also called in. "They determined it wasn't an actual threat," Uroda said. "If it was an actual threat, that becomes a law-enforcement issue. If it's not, that becomes a school discipline issue.'" (11/18/05)

No free speech in schools, even charter schools, when they are government-run, taxpayer-funded. Durango used to have people with common sense in charge - and used to have teachers with some brains and understanding of children. Notice how quickly they called in the cops - even though it wasn't supposed to be "a law-enforcement issue."

Home Front News
Our internal wars against freedom (on the one side, described by some as a "war on terrorism") and fighting FOR liberty continues:

California: How rapists prey on vulnerable border crossers
Washington Times
"Among the thousands of women who will illegally cross into the United States this year from Mexico, some will be raped by the same men who demanded $1,500 to $2,000 for safe passage -- their underpants often hung on a border fence as a trophy. 'I thought the wailings we heard at night were the coyotes barking at the moon,' said Tim Donnelly, who headed the Minuteman Civil Defense Corps border vigil here. 'I didn't know until later that those sounds were the cries of women being raped in the Mexican desert, some less than a hundred yards away from the border. There was absolutely nothing anyone could do about it,' said Donnelly, grimacing as he turned away to hide his emotions. 'It's something you never forget.'" (11/21/05)

It is sickening, and just who do we blame for this? Is it wrong to not be able to cross the border to come to the aid of some woman being raped? Is it because we make it so easy to cross the border that this happens?

Mama's Note: And heaven forbid anyone even suggest that these women should be armed so they can protect themselves. There are a lot of heavy issues involved here, and none of what is going on is the right way to take care of any of them, but I can fully understand the desire of the Mexican people to get out of the corruption and misery caused by the Mexican government. Too bad they don't understand just what it is they are coming into here.

Denver Firefighter under suspicion
Rocky Mountain News
A Denver firefighter described as having "anti- U.S. sympathies" is under investigation for possible ties to domestic terrorist groups after his arrest early Tuesday for allegedly selling machine guns, a federal arrest affidavit says. Stan Taran Ford, 34, has been charged with federal firearms violations. He is being held without bond pending a detention hearing Monday Ford joined the department in February 1999. Tuesday's arrest comes after an investigation of the firefighter that lasted more than two years, according to court documents.

A very troubling case, as the feds and various locals bought stuff from this guy, helping him try to buy various things from Fort Carson (70 miles south), and generally seem to have led him on. There is not enough information to see whether he really sold "machine guns" or just semi-automatic weapons, although the prices quoted seem to be what full-auto would bring. But he does appear to be a genuinely bad-actor.

Mama's Note: Why? Because he bought and sold guns? I don't care what kind of guns they were. Remember that anyone the government doesn't like can be called a "terrorist." There simply isn't enough information in that story to determine if he was doing anything morally wrong at all.

A BRIDGE TOO FAR (Unable to locate a link for this item)
Wall Street Journal (reprinted via Chuck Muth News)
"Congress limped out of town last week for its Thanksgiving recess, and just in the nick of time. With its Iraq duck-and-cover, the failure to extend expiring tax cuts, and the refusal to control spending, the Members were doing more damage to the republic every day they stayed around. Amid the carnage, however, there was one small triumph last week: Senate Appropriations powerhouse Ted Stevens decided to pull funding for the infamous $320 million 'Bridge to Nowhere' in his home state of Alaska. "...The one hero of this episode is Senator Tom Coburn (R., Okla.), who sponsored an amendment to block funding for the bridge and use the money to repair vital bridges on the Gulf Coast destroyed by Hurricane Katrina. Mr. Stevens erupted on the Senate floor and threatened to quit if the measure passed. The vote failed. However, Mr. Stevens threw in the towel last Tuesday, announcing that he was taking this 'drastic action' because his state had been 'so unfairly maligned in the national press' in recent weeks."

Thanks to Chuck for this one. Good news! Stevens needs to retire. For that matter, getting rid of about 110 of the 100 senators would be a good idea.

Abu Ali convicted in Bush assassination plot
Cincinnati Enquirer
"An American Muslim student charged with joining al-Qaida and plotting to assassinate President Bush was convicted Tuesday on all counts. The federal jury rejected Ahmed Omar Abu Ali's claim that Saudi security officers whipped and tortured him into a false confession. Abu Ali, a 24-year-old U.S. citizen born to a Jordanian father and raised in Falls Church, Va., could get life in prison on charges that included conspiracy to assassinate the president, conspiracy to hijack aircraft and providing support to al-Qaida. Sentencing is scheduled for Feb. 17." (11/22/05)

This, at least, was not by tribunal - and we should not be surprised that there are at least some "Muslim-Americans" who seek to completely wipe out not just our government but our entire society.

Katrina: Evacuees in hotels get reprieve
Houston Chronicle
"Stung by charges it is pushing hurricane victims out before the holidays, FEMA extended its hotel housing program today by a month in 10 states that have received victims of Katrina and Rita. Evacuees in those states -- Texas, Louisiana, Georgia, Florida, Mississippi, Alabama, California, Tennessee, Arkansas and Nevada -- now have until Jan. 7 before the Federal Emergency Management Agency stops paying their hotel bills. The deadline is shorter -- Dec. 15 -- for victims in all other states, said FEMA acting director R. David Paulison." (11/22/05)

What seems to be left is the most hardcore of the hardcore welfare class, and a very few people who are too old or too handicapped to be able to do anything for themselves with the change in conditions, although they were able to subsist on their own in New Orleans in some way. I expect to see another extension, or some version thereof, in January.

Mama's Note: HOTELS? My hair stood on end when I read this earlier. This is totally insane. There is most certainly something else that could be done to help these people, but with the usual inefficiency of government, this is the easy way out. The people in charge of this have no real incentive to do anything else. It isn't THEIR money they are wasting here.

The answer isn't to simply toss them out, of course! Some private charity needs to take charge and find these people appropriate accomodations and assistance. It's not rocket science, for crying out loud!

Report: 9/11-Iraq link refuted days after attack
MSNBC
"Ten days after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, President Bush was advised that U.S. intelligence found no credible connection linking the attacks to the regime of Saddam Hussein, or evidence suggesting linkage between Saddam and the al-Qaida terrorist network, according to a published report. The report, published Tuesday in The National Journal, cites government records, as well as present and former officials with knowledge of the issue. The information in the story, written by National Journal contributor Murray Waas, points to an abiding administration concern for secrecy that extended to keeping information from the Senate committee charged with investigating the matter." (11/22/05)

Yet, other information reported AFTER that time, indicated exactly the opposite. As with so many things, these will be argued by lawyers, politicians, and historians for centuries. To echo Buchanan, a pox on both their houses.

Mideast Tarbabies
After last week, it is actually a bit quieter this week regarding the mess in the Old World, both events here in the USA and actually in that poor, benighted region.

Iraq Troop Withdrawals Driven By Politics
SpaceWar.com
Washington (UPI) Nov 22, 2005 - The U.S. military will recommend the number of troops that can be prudently withdrawn from Iraq - if any - but the final decision for the American military presence there will be up to policy officials in Washington. And they will consider political factors as well when they craft a final plan, a top U.S. general in Iraq said Tuesday.

Don't you just hate obvious headlines like this? I can hardly wait to see what DC comes up with! (Sarcasm, folks.)

Iran raises stakes on UN inspections
Cincinnati Enquirer
"Raising the stakes before a key vote by the U.N. nuclear agency, lawmakers approved a bill Sunday requiring the government to block inspections of atomic facilities if the agency refers Iran to the Security Council for possible sanctions. The bill was favored by 183 of the 197 lawmakers present. The session was broadcast live on state-run radio four days before the International Atomic Energy Agency board considers referring Tehran to the Security Council for violating a nuclear arms control treaty. The council could impose sanctions." (11/20/05)

Iran still continues to egg on the rest of the world.

A deadly legacy: the cluster bomb
Independent [UK]
"Tony Blair is facing fresh fury over the use of controversial munitions in the Iraq war. Campaigners lambasted the Ministry of Defence over its use of deadly cluster bombs and shells during the invasion, warning that they could contravene international law. MPs are to table a raft of new questions today over the affair amid fears that thousands of bomblets released during the war will leave a deadly legacy for Iraqi civilians. They warned that any unexploded bomblets could kill or maim civilians for years to come. The dispute over British use of cluster bombs will be intensify this week with the publication of a report by the pressure group Landmine Action, which raises questions over the efforts made to ensure that the weapons did not harm civilians." (11/21/05)

This claims yet another standard munition to be against international law - a straining of gnats that distracts from the basic problems with the invasion of Iraq in the first place - that it was a preventative war.

AZ Rep.hatched idea of "clarity of vision" vote
Arizona Republic
"The credit (or blame) for Friday night's vote to put U.S. House members on record about whether deployment of U.S. troops in Iraq should be terminated immediately goes to Rep. J.D. Hayworth, R-AZ. Not to mention Hayworth's wife, Mary. It was Hayworth who hatched and then pitched the idea of a vote on troop withdrawal from Iraq during a meeting Friday morning behind closed doors with his GOP colleagues. More than 200 Republicans were gathered in the room, talking about a tax bill, when Hayworth, a member of the tax-code-writing House Ways and Means Committee, stood to take his turn at an open microphone." (11/19/05)

Last week's foofahrah (remember it) was typical politics as usual - trying to catch your opponent with a pie on their face (or perhaps, just catch them with egg on their face) and was ultimately meaningless.

Mama's Note: Every single vote in either house of congress should be public record, available immediately. Everything brought to a vote should be decided on one at a time - after suitable discussion, not rubber stamped in massive "bundles" of hundreds or thousands of things, most known to only a few people. At this point, they shouldn't be allowed to pass any new "law" unless they repealed at least two others. I know... dream on.

Iraq: At least 60 killed in bombings
CBS News
"Suicide bombers killed 52 worshippers at a Shiite mosque near the Iranian border on Friday. In Baghdad two car bombs destroyed the blast wall protecting a hotel housing international journalists and killed eight Iraqis. ... Also on Friday, insurgents attacked U.S. and Iraqi troops in western Iraq, setting off gunbattles that left 32 insurgents dead, a U.S. military statement said. ... America's death toll rose Thursday as the U.S. military reported a U.S. Marine killed the day before in Haditha, 140 miles northwest of Baghdad. An Army soldier died Thursday in a traffic accident near Beiji, 155 miles north of Baghdad and a second soldier died in another accident near Balad, the command said." (11/18/05)

Three major attacks, and only one of the three on the forces that supposedly are the enemy of everyone in Iraq - the Muslim-on-Muslim killing continues to grow, despite Coalition attempts to keep (or establish) the peace.

Iraq: GIs kill three in civilian vehicle
Las Vegas Review-Journal
"U.S. soldiers fired on a civilian vehicle Monday because they feared it might hold a suicide bomber, killing at least two adults and a child northeast of the capital, American and Iraqi officials said. The troops fired on the car because it was moving erratically outside a U.S. base in Baqouba, 35 miles from Baghdad, said Maj. Steven Warren, a U.S. spokesman. 'It was one of these regrettable, tragic incidents,' Warren said." (11/21/05)

The tone of the news story and the media is evident in the headline and first sentence. Sorry folks, but the murderers roaming the streets don't have special markings on their cars - they are all "civilian" vehicles: technically, all the "military" vehicles on Iraqi roads belong to the "good guys." This kind of thing will just keep happening, again and again.

Iraqi leaders call for timetable for US withdrawal
USA Today
"Leaders of Iraq's sharply divided Shiites, Kurds and Sunnis called Monday for a timetable for the withdrawal of U.S.-led forces in the country and said Iraq's opposition had a 'legitimate right' of resistance. The final communique, hammered out at the end of three days of negotiations at a preparatory reconciliation conference under the auspices of the Arab League, condemned terrorism, but was a clear acknowledgment of the Sunni position that insurgents should not be labeled as terrorists if their operations do not target innocent civilians or institutions designed to provide for the welfare of Iraqi citizens." (11/22/05)

This article would appear to be the only thing that they could agree to. Notice that even the Sunnis willing to participate in these negotiations condemn (albeit indirectly) the Muslim-on-Muslim attacks - assuming you consider journalists to be "innocent civilians."

Mama's Note: I notice that nobody has even suggested asking the people of Iraq if they want the US (and any of the others) to stay. Now that would be a world demonstration of "democracy," for sure. Not going to happen, of course, since the US government has no interest whatsoever in what the people of ANY country really want.

Sharon moves to dissolve Israel's parliament
Houston Chronicle
"In a bold gamble, Prime Minister Ariel Sharon asked Israel's president today to dissolve parliament, pushing for a quick March election just hours after deciding to leave his hard-line Likud Party and to form a new centrist party. Sharon's decision to leave Likud sent shock waves through Israel, redrawing the political map, finalizing his transformation from hard-liner to moderate and boosting prospects of progress in peacemaking with the Palestinians." (11/21/05)

The new "Forward" Party is likely to lose the new election, and thus send Israel into further confusion.

Mama's Note: A "quick March election?" Does this mean there won't be ANY government until after the election? I highly doubt it, but it would be interesting to see what would happen if that's what happened. They might discover they didn't really want to elect anyone in March.

The spoils of war
Independent [UK]
"Iraqis face the dire prospect of losing up to $200bn (£116bn) of the wealth of their country if an American-inspired plan to hand over development of its oil reserves to US and British multinationals comes into force next year. A report produced by American and British pressure groups warns Iraq will be caught in an 'old colonial trap' if it allows foreign companies to take a share of its vast energy reserves. The report is certain to reawaken fears that the real purpose of the 2003 war on Iraq was to ensure its oil came under Western control." (11/22/05)

More mainstream media attempts to make purses out of pig's ears: this report is no less biased than any report emerging out of either Congress or the US Administration (or the British government) - but is accepted at face value, and supposedly will be the cause of further fearmongering.

UK: Legal gag on Bush-Blair war row
Guardian [UK]
"The attorney general last night threatened newspapers with the Official Secrets Act if they revealed the contents of a document allegedly relating to a dispute between Tony Blair and George Bush over the conduct of military operations in Iraq. It is believed to be the first time the Blair government has threatened newspapers in this way. Though it has obtained court injunctions against newspapers, the government has never prosecuted editors for publishing the contents of leaked documents, including highly sensitive ones about the run-up to the invasion of Iraq. The attorney general, Lord Goldsmith, last night referred editors to newspaper reports yesterday that described the contents of a memo purporting to be at the centre of charges against two men under the secrets act. Under the front-page headline 'Bush plot to bomb his ally,' the Daily Mirror reported that the US president last year planned to attack the Arabic television station al-Jazeera, which has its headquarters in Doha, the capital of Qatar, where US and British bombers were based. ... Charges under the secrets act have to have the consent of the attorney-general. His intervention yesterday suggests that the prosecution plans to ask the judge to hold part, if not all of the trial, in camera, with the public and press excluded." (11/23/05)

Clearly, Blair is feeling pressure and taking a harder line, which only lends credence to the absurd claims of the Mirror: if the US president wished to shut down Al-Jazeera, there are dozens of ways other than bombing a friendly capital to do so. Both sides of the "war" issue demonstrate more and more stupidity.

Investigator probes alleged CIA prison flights
USA Today
"The head of a European probe into alleged secret CIA prisons in eastern Europe is investigating 31 suspected flights that landed in Europe and is trying to acquire past satellite images of sites in Romania and Poland, according to a report obtained by The Associated Press Tuesday. Dick Marty, a Swiss senator leading the investigation for the Council of Europe, presented a first report on his work at a closed meeting of the human rights watchdog's legal affairs committee in Paris." (11/22/05)

Perhaps a Swiss investigator can find some truth, but what he has so far is a bunch of unsupported claims, similar in tone to rumors that periodically sweep the Third World that their children are being stolen by the US to be harvested of their organs.

Iraq: Possible troop cut coming
MSNBC
"Barring any major surprises in Iraq, the Pentagon tentatively plans to reduce the number of U.S. forces there early next year by as many as three combat brigades, from 18 now, but to keep at least one brigade 'on call' in Kuwait in case more troops are needed quickly, several senior military officers said. Pentagon authorities also have set a series of 'decision points' during 2006 to consider further force cuts that, under a 'moderately optimistic' scenario, would drop the total number of troops from more than 150,000 now to fewer than 100,000, including 10 combat brigades, by the end of the year, the officers said." (11/22/05)

At least a part of this drawdown has been planned and announced for months, as to follow the December 2005 elections; a slight addition to the number of troops returned is also surely due to the impact on the troops themselves, but will surely be claimed as a "victory" by "anti-war" groups. Opposition in Congress might have a very small amount to do with this, but not what the commentators are making it out to be.

General: Iraqi army can't be rushed
CNN
"Despite calls in Washington and Iraq to pull out foreign troops, the U.S. general in charge of helping Iraq create an army says training troops to replace coalition forces cannot be rushed. 'We are moving at a measured pace,' Army Gen. Martin Dempsey told CNN. 'We want this army over time to be representative, to be cohesive, to be a role model for the potential of what could work for the rest of society,' he said." (11/22/05)

Words that would seem to be both reasoned and calm, and which will be ignored, therefore, by everyone.

Mama's Note: Given what they have to work with, the massive tensions between the different ethnic groups and so much more, it is probably not possible to produce any kind of "cohesive" or "representative" armed force in Iraq, no matter how much time they put into it. The real question, however, is why bother? Let these people separate into their natural divisions and then let them alone to build their own society, each to suit themselves. They are never going to wear the Washington DC straight jacket willingly, and they can't ever be an effective armed force the way they are.


The Coming Fall of Europe
More strange news and scary events from Europe.

Last Scots WW1 Vet dies at 109
The Scotsman
SCOTLAND'S last surviving veteran of the First World War, and the country's oldest man, died peacefully at a nursing home yesterday aged 109 - severing the last tangible link between the nation and the 690,235 Scots who served in the Great War
The man, a veteran of the Black Watch Regiment, participated in the 1914 Christmas truce, sometimes called the last civilized act of war in history. Today is 2005, and World War I ended with the Armistice 87 years ago. There are still some American Veterans of the "War to End All Wars" left, but not many, and this is a good time to think about how long it takes to really get to the end of an era.

Sadly, Scotland, the UK, and Europe have forgotten the lessons learned long before the survivors passed on.

UK: Lords threaten rough ride for anti-terror bill
Guardian [UK]
"Tony Blair warned the House of Lords last night not to defy public opinion by moving to wreck the government's terror bill today as further objections to the measures emerged from chief police officers and the civil liberty lobby. On the eve of the second reading in the Lords, leaders of the Conservative and Liberal Democrat parties gave Downing Street notice that they would give the bill "a thorough going-over" and scrutinise its provisions line-by-line before sending it back to the Commons. After a revolt by 49 Labour backbenchers, MPs have already modified a central clause of the bill. It would now permit the police to hold terrorist suspects for 28 days without charge pending further investigation - instead of the current 14 and the 90 days initially proposed. But the much-trumpeted support senior police officers gave that clause does not extend to the entire bill, the Guardian has learned. The Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo) privately opposed four of the government's 14 main proposals announced after the July 7 London bombings. Other proposals could damage community relations, Acpo believes." (11/21/05)

It seems to me that it is Blair who is bucking public opinion, right AND justice.

Mama's Note: None of the governments in the world are even considering any of the things that would truly reduce the threat of terrorism, of course. None of these "bills" and restrictions or detentions will have the least affect on the real causes and operation of people who want to kill others, for any reason - but can certainly up the ante. Truly free people could defend themselves and eliminate the threats in no time. How sad so few people can even contemplate such a thing.

Germany: Protestors halt nuclear convoy
Yahoo! News
"Anti-nuclear protestors repeatedly halted a controversial shipment of highly radioactive nuclear waste from France bound for a temporary storage facility in northern Germany. The activists said the train with 12 containers carrying more than 170 tonnes of treated nuclear power plant waste was stopped in the city of Goettingen for about 30 minutes and then later in the village of Bienenbuettel en route to the Gorleben site. Eighteen demonstrators were briefly detained in Goettingen. In the town of Harlingen, police removed 150 activists staging a sit-in on the tracks and detained 23. Demonstrators later set fire to bales of hay placed next to the tracks and police had to move in with water cannon. Thick plumes of smoke were still rising when the train rolled by at a snail's pace. Police also cleared a blockade of 160 tractors near the town of Klein Gusborn late Sunday, on the last leg of the 600-kilometer (370-mile) trip, where more than 600 people joined the protest following demonstrations throughout the weekend. Authorities had to forcibly clear the blockade, with more than 70 of the tractors seized and taken to a nearby field." (11/21/05)

The German government, in large part, brought this on itself - it has created such fear-mongering that this kind of protest is all but encouraged by the Government. But if Europe wishes to improve their environment and maintain a high-tech society, they will have to understand that nuclear power is often the least undesirable of the options.

UK: Peers fight planned "glorifying terrorism" ban
Guardian [UK]
"Opposition peers called on the government last night to scrap its proposed new offence of glorifying terrorism, as a Home Office minister confirmed that it had abandoned its proposal to extend the maximum pre-charge detention period to 90 days. ... Lord Hurd, the Tory former home and foreign secretary, added: "We need not to worry so much about the loudmouths as about the quiet acts of subversion and training by dangerous people, up and down the country, who on the whole keep their mouths shut.'" (11/21/05)

In reality, all the Lords can do is "jaw-jaw" and not really stop this stupid law from passing. Sadly.

Germany: Professor stopped on motorway [autobahn] in wheelchair
Ananova [UK]
"An 'absent-minded' professor was stopped by police as he tried to drive 110 miles down a German motorway in his wheelchair. Police stopped Wolfgang Hain, 67, on the A43 motorway near Herne in North Rhine Westphalia driving six mph in his electric wheelchair -- in traffic travelling at speeds above 100 mph. Officer Peter Feldkirch said: 'He seemed a bit absent-minded but was fully aware of who he was and where he was going. But I'm not sure if he realised that it would take him 20 hours to get home.' Hain was given a fine and escorted to the nearest B road where he was allowed to continue his journey." (11/21/05)

Whew! You don't think that people at his university would have wondered about him heading out on the street and up the on-ramp?

Britain: Nestle under fire for "sexist" TV ad
News.com [Australia]
"Confectionery giant Nestle is under fire in Britain over chocolate bar adverts suggesting football is 'not for girls.' The company is promoting a bar called Footie with wrapper slogans including: 'It's definitely not for girls,' 'no passes to lasses' and 'no wenches on the benches.' Wrappers also contain an image of a woman holding a handbag framed in a no-entry road sign. The Women's Sports Foundation said such advertising undermined attempts to encourage girls to play more sport and improve fitness levels in teenage girls. 'We'd rather not see this kind of advertising,' she said. 'Research shows that 40 per cent of girls have dropped out of sport by the time they reach 18. It's a serious problem with implications for health and fitness.'" (11/21/05)

Put this in the stupid people tricks in Europe category: these people need to get a life, and stop taking adverts so seriously.

Privacy Issues and News
More news of interest regarding the defense of our privacy, just as important as the defense of our persons, homes, and other liberties.

Lie detectors may be next step in airline security
CNet
"A new walk-through airport lie detector made in Israel may prove to be the toughest challenge yet for potential hijackers or drug smugglers. Tested in Russia, the two-stage GK-1 voice analyzer requires that passengers don headphones at a console and answer 'yes' or 'no' into a microphone to questions about whether they are planning something illicit. The software will almost always pick up uncontrollable tremors in the voice that give away liars or those with something to hide, say its designers at Israeli firm Nemesysco." (11/17/05)

Of course, the number of false positives will be spectacular, as people cheating on their spouses (illegal in many countries, still, and at least recognized as immoral by most people), people who just walked off with the damask napkins from the airport restaurant, and people planning to sneak Cuban cigars home to the US will all get caught by this pretty piece of expensive machinery. It isn't just drug smugglers and hijackers that have something to hide - and remember that for many fanatics (Islamic and otherwise), their action in hijacking or bombing is NOT going to be "illicit" in their own mind.

Australia: Suburban spies raise privacy fears
Sydney Morning Herald [Australia]
"Prying neighbours have been setting up video cameras outside their homes -- ostensibly to catch thieves -- and then using them to spy on bathrooms and bedrooms in the house next door, according to 'disturbing' complaints received by the State Privacy Commissioner. The acting commissioner, John Dickie, said much of the spying had occurred in northern Sydney and followed disputes between neighbours. Mr Dickie said many complaints involved multiple cameras, including one incident in which a household set up six cameras to spy on the neighbouring property." (11/22/05)

Hmmm. Go look in your neighbors' trees and on their utilities poles!

Religious News
A couple of items today, with p

Vatican astronomer: Intelligent design not science
Fox News
"The Vatican's chief astronomer said Friday that "intelligent design" isn't science and doesn't belong in science classrooms, becoming the latest high-ranking Roman Catholic official to enter the evolution debate in the United States. The Rev. George Coyne, the Jesuit director of the Vatican Observatory, said placing intelligent design theory alongside that of evolution in school programs was 'wrong' and was akin to mixing apples with oranges. Intelligent design isn't science, even though it pretends to be,' the ANSA news agency quoted Coyne as saying on the sidelines of a conference in Florence. 'If you want to teach it in schools, intelligent design should be taught when religion or cultural history is taught, not science.' His comments were in line with his previous statements on 'intelligent design,' whose supporters hold that the universe is so complex that it must have been created by a higher power." (111/9/05)

The RC Church for decades has (wrongly in my opinion) been willing to accept evolution, but theistic evolution - that is, God-directed evolution. If this is indeed an official position of the Vatican, it indicates a further erosion of the RC Church's acceptance of Scripture. As well, it indicates that (as is often the case through history) respected scientists are often wrong, for Coyne obviously does not understand just what "intelligent design" is all about.

Vatican closes door on gay seminarians
Detroit Free Press
"The Vatican is toughening its stand against gay candidates for the priesthood, specifying in a new document that even men with 'transitory' homosexual tendencies must overcome their urges for at least three years before entering the clergy. A long-awaited 'Instruction,' due to be released next week, was posted Tuesday on the Internet by the Italian Catholic news agency Adista. A church official who has read the document confirmed its authenticity; he asked that his name not be used because the piece has not been published by the Vatican." (11/22/05)

Given the RC Church's position (which does agree entirely with Scripture), this is only logical. The exact same position might be taken regarding an axe murderer who wished to become a priest: it is not necessarily enough for him to say that he's stopped killing people with axes - a few years' evidence that he has indeed repented would be reasonable.

Mama's Note: A large body of hard evidence shows that 99% (or close) of the sexual scandal in the church was caused by homosexuals, both in the priesthood and in other positions of trust with children. (That does not excuse the Bishops who did nothing to eliminate this abomination!) I'm afraid there is NO indication that homosexuals would ever be stable enough to be trusted this way, and it's a very bad idea to even consider them for admission no matter how long they wait. The formation time for the priesthood is already many years, and if these people couldn't be weeded out before as unsuitable there is nothing to indicate those in charge would be any more successful in the future. The children are just too precious to take a chance. And that goes for homosexual women who would enter religious orders too.

Thousands celebrate teen as new Buddha
Washington Times
"Thousands of pilgrims are pouring into the dense jungle of southern Nepal to worship a 15-year-old boy who has been hailed as a new Buddha. Devotees say that Ram Bomjon, who is meditating silently beneath a tree, has not eaten or had anything to drink since he sat down at his chosen spot six months ago. Witnesses say they have seen light emanating from the teenager's forehead. 'It looks a bit like when you shine a [flashlight] through your hand,' said Tek Bahadur Lama, a member of the committee responsible for dealing with the growing number of visitors from India and elsewhere in Nepal. Photographs of Ram, available for about 10 cents from his makeshift shrine, have become ubiquitous across the region. 'Far and wide, it's the only topic of conversation,' said Upendra Lamichami, a local journalist. He said no claim had emerged of Ram breaking his fast or moving, even to relieve himself." (11/22/05)

This kind of rumor periodically sweeps the East, just as other visions periodically have swept the West for centuries as well. Today, we hear about them much more quickly. Of course, those of us with a more suspicious mind might wonder (a) is he really still alive or even actually a human or just a manikin, or (b) are there reliable observers on duty 24 hours to see, or does he sneak to the nearest Burger King just before midnight closing to relieve himself and stoke up on Whoppers and Cokes?

Mama's Note: Who cares? Any rock can sit forever dumb and need nothing to eat or drink. That has nothing to do with holiness. Our Lord was called a drunkard and a glutton.

Our Right to Defend Ourselves
Some bad news and some good news in this field today.

Mall Shooter Confronted by Armed Man, Surrenders to Soldiers
The Seattle Times, C-News
The man who was critically wounded during Sunday's shooting rampage at Tacoma Mall drew a pistol and confronted the gunman before he was cut down by gunfire, his family said Tuesday. Brendan "Dan" McKown was delivering a bank deposit for a mall gift store when gunshots scattered shoppers at around noon. McKown was among six people hit.Police say Dominick Sergio Maldonado, 20, of Tacoma, marched through the mall shooting randomly at shoppers before taking four hostages in a Sam Goody music store. He surrendered about four hours later. Police on Tuesday were still trying to determine how Maldonado, a convicted felon, had obtained the two weapons he allegedly carried into the mall. The federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives was helping Tacoma detectives trace the history of the weapons, Fulghum said. Police searched Maldonado's car and bedroom, finding a formula for making the deadly poison ricin, as well as bomb-making diagrams and materials, and body shooting targets. Two of the hostages, both. military., eventually helped disarm Maldonado and walked him out of the store. "The look in his eyes toward the end was a scared kid," said Jon Black, 32, an active-duty army soldier[from nearby Fort Lewis]. "He had tears in his eyes when we were taking the weapons away from him and he was in tears as we were taking him out." A second hostage, Joseph Hudson, who served as an army medic in Iraq, told police "that he was more frightened inside the store than he ever was in Iraq."

This sounds like a very disturbing situation, which could influence things in Washington State in many ways. First, the man was obviously deranged, and claimed that his rampage was due to "child abuse" at a police volunteer-run camp 8 years ago. Second, McKown apparently thought that he could deter the shooter by warning him off with a hand-gun, instead of shooting immediately - and lost his bet (a reminder to us all - TRAIN and PRACTICE!). Third, it is claimed that one of the "assault weapons" was sold through a want ad (which will add fuel to efforts to get newspapers to stop such weapons want ads, and to tighten down on "third-party" sales. Fourth, it may make more active-duty (and reserve!) soldiers decide that they need to be armed for their own defense and that of their families, even in the homeland. One man (McKown) wasn't able to stop the shooter (but I am disturbed by the tone of some of the news stories that somehow McKown "deserved" to be shot since he was carrying a weapon of his own), but if three or four people had been carrying weapons, it would have been different - without wounding five more people. At the same time, for all his mistakes, McKown should be HONORED because he was willing to put his life on the line for others, as were the two soldiers.

Missouri: Intruder cuts man, runs from pistol
Springfield News-Leader
"Police said the 24-year-old victim was on the telephone when he heard noises in the house. When he hung up, he saw an intruder with a knife. The victim was cut in the arm before he went into his bedroom to get a pistol. The victim fired at the intruder, who was running out the door. It was unknown if the suspect was hit." (11/20/05)

A bizarre little business, indeed. I suspect there was a bit more to it than "excuse me, Mr. Burglar, but since you've cut my arm, let me go into the bedroom and get my pistol, please?"

Cowboys take up AK47s to combat drug runners on Mexican frontier
Telegraph [UK]
"Welcome to the Wild West 2005, where modern-day cowboys still guard their land from interlopers - but using AK47s and four-wheel drives instead of Winchester rifles and horses. Mr McCaslin's small mine sits on a knoll of red earth and scrub near the Mexican border. Like his 19th-century predecessors, he is sure there is money in "them thar hills" after a geological survey indicated there may be rich veins of silver. Today, however, he has other priorities. For the mine also sits in the middle of a network of trails used by heavily-armed Mexican trafficking gangs to smuggle people and drugs into America." (11/20/05)

Typical media attempts to portray people who use or have weapons to defend themselves as nothing but nut-cases. This seems to be a good example of properly preparing for a likely situation, since we know that wetbacks have frequently been known to steal from homes, ranches, and industrial sites, and since drug dealers are known to be armed, usually heavily.

Los Angeles: Police recruits take to sidewalks
Christian Science Monitor
"With her factory-fresh police belt holding revolver, mace, two nightsticks, and one radio, Jeanine Giordano strides into Hollywood Star Market. 'Sir, we are just walking a foot beat up and down the street. ... I'm sure you've seen us,' says the young police recruit to a Korean working behind displays of beef jerky and pen lighters. 'If you have any problems or questions,' she adds after a conversation, 'go ahead and let us know.' The clerk's nervous frown melts into a broad smile. Score one for the new attempt by the Los Angeles Police Department to repair one of the most tarnished, adversarial images of any police force in the country." (11/18/05)

It would be amazing if the LAPD can reform itself and its image, but if I were the storekeepers of LA, I'd trust more on that S&W or Kaer under the checkout counter than on the LAPD to do anything to protect an individual store or business.

Group ranks most dangerous US cities
CNN
"For the second year in a row this destitute city of Camden, New Jersey, has been named the nation's most dangerous, according to a company's annual ranking based on crime statistics. Last year, the distinction seemed to hurt city boosters' feelings more than it harmed revitalization efforts. This time, city leaders are offended by the ranking, calling it unfair. 'We're doing so many nice things now. It's unfortunate that somebody always wants to bad-mouth Camden,' Mayor Gwendolyn Faison said." (11/21/05)

Statistics do lie, but these are pretty clear, and it is hardly bad-mouthing Camden to quote statistics to show what cities are more dangerous or not. If you want to hear what bad-mouthing Camden is: "Camden is a pitiful excuse of a town, has been completely absorbed by slums, resembles an asylum run by the inmates, and is one of the few cities of which it can be said, it is an improvement to move to Philadelphia." That is running down Camden.

Spain: Belgian arrested for shooting burglars
SUR [Spain]
"Following a shooting in a villa in Vélez-Málaga police arrested a Belgian and four Romanians. The Belgian (C. H.) is accused of shooting two burglars who had broken into his neighbours' house. After being detained, 47 year old C.H. gave his version of events. Apparently, he saw a small moving light on the second floor of his neighbours' house and as they had gone on holiday a few days before, he became suspicious. He approached the house wielding a gun and found the gate open and everything ransacked inside. When he was in the living room, he heard footsteps behind him and when he turned around, he supposedly started pullling the trigger. ... According to the inquiry, the two Romanians lived together and supposedly had broken into the house on Monday November 7th. The following day, police went to the villa in the carretera de Bentomiz, and found the door open. They checked that there was no-one inside and in the living room, discovered blood stains and bullet marks in the furniture. Police then found out that the owners of the villa had gone to Belgium a few days previously leaving the care of the house in the hands of a relative, also Belgian, who lived closeby." (11/21/05)

Clearly he did not report the incident for the same reason that a hiker in the backwoods of the Rockies does not report it when he has to shoot a lynx, a mountain lion, or a bear which is attacking him or his animals: you don't get praise for defending yourself, others, or property, you get arrested.

New Mexico: Woman recounts attack
Rio Rancho Observer
"Melissa O'Connell will be the first to tell you she's the exception, not the rule. Among women who become victims of violent crime she is an anomaly. Three years after waking up around midnight with a masked male intruder on top of her, shining a flashlight in her eyes and holding a gun and preparing to rape her, O'Connell is alive to talk about it. The serial rapist, who had gained entry into her house that July evening through a window or the sliding glass door, is dead. He's dead because O'Connell managed to wrestle his gun away and shoot him at least twice. O'Connell survived to tell her story many times to many people, including a national television audience when she appeared on the Oprah Winfrey show to accept a 'Chutzpah award,' given to women who show extraordinary amounts of bravery and courage in threatening situations. O'Connell told her story again to the Women Against Crime (WAC) class Monday evening." (11/21/05)

She was, indeed, lucky. I hope that she learned her lesson and now keeps a weapon by her bed or under her pillow, like smart people do.

Mama's Note: "Under her pillow?" You've got to be joking. That's not possible, unless maybe you have an incredibly large pillow or a very hard head. Besides being too lumpy to sleep on, the darn thing would be running around loose in the bed half the time if I tried to keep it there. The bedside table is plenty close enough, and much safer for everyone.

South Africa: Gun owners in for shock
News 24 [South Africa]
"Owners of firearms are set for a rude awakening early next year. According to the Central Firearms Register those who fail to comply with the act on the control of firearms will be arrested, their weapons confiscated and they'll have to appear in court. Statistics have shown that are more than 500,000 firearms licences countrywide need to be renewed before December 31. ... Van Tonder said gun owners had to fill in numerous forms and make statements. These include SAP 517 and SAP 517E forms. They also had to make statements and write motivations. They had to hand in four colour-identity photographs and a number of certified copies of, among others, their identity document, arms licence and proficiency certificate. 'The paper war is just too much for the older gun owners in particular,' he said. ... Director Phuti Setati, national police spokesperson, said gun owners who refused to renew their licences, could be sentenced to up to 12 months in prison." (11/22/05)

For years, the warning has been sounded around the world: registration leads directly to confiscation. This latest example shows just how it works. South Africa continues to decline.

Texas: Homeowner fatally shoots intruder
Click2Houston
"Police said a couple was sitting inside their home when someone broke into the home on Lacy Street at Detering Street in the Rice Military area at about 9 p.m. 'He came in armed with a bat, went through a side door, shattered the glass to make his way into the residence,' Houston Police Department Homicide Detective Mike Walker said. The husband told the intruder he had a gun and to leave, but police said the intruder persisted up the stairs, forcing the homeowner to shoot him. The suspect was pronounced dead at the scene." (11/22/05)

It does not appear that the homeowner was arrested. Good!

Indiana: Homeowner's brother shoots teenage intruder
Northwest Indiana Post-Tribune
"A teenager who apparently broke into a Glen Park home Monday afternoon was seriously wounded when the resident's brother fired at him with a shotgun, police said later. ... The homeowner's brother, Johnny Yarbrough, 34, told police he shot Walker after the teen broke into the house, pointed a gun at his sister and demanded money." (11/22/05)

Another example of the right thing, at the right time and place.

Arkansas: Woman shoots intruding ex-husband
KARK News
"A Little Rock man continues to recover after Police say his ex-wife took a gun and shot him in self-defense. The incident happened Monday morning at 7105 Fourche Dam Pike in Little Rock. Police say 50 year old Judy Melton shot her 50 year old ex-husband Eddie Melton. According to Little Rock Police, Melton showed up at the residence, got very angry because his ex-wife wouldn't let him in, and then he proceeded to kick in the door, and she shot him. ... Judy Melton is not facing charges at this time, but the case will be reviewed by the prosecutor." (11/21/05)
Again, this seems to be a simple case, easily proven, and more suitable for a coroner's jury than anything - except, unfortunately, the aggressor did not die of his stupidity.

More News and Commentary on Page 2

Nathan Barton is a libertarian engineer and writer, enjoying the cooling evenings in the Rockies and the Four Corners, where "monsoon" rains cause some creeks to overflow their banks, but nothing like the mess down in the South. His views are his own and do not necessarily represent the views of anyone else, including the sources of his news and other libertarians! Be sure to visit my blog, Liberty's Outpost.

Special Feature! Add your signature to the NEW Declaration of Independence
By Robert Greenslade

Several people have asked about buying Gadsden Flags (the rattlesnake "Don't Tread on Me flags used by the June 23d Movement and other Property Rights Organizations: you can get them for $10.00 plus shipping here.


To Read previous Commentaries, go to the archives page and click onto the link for the day. The commentaries are linked from the daily front pages.


Your feedback is always welcome! Please use the form below. If you enter your email address, the author can respond to your comment. Not all feedback can be answered personally, of course, but you will find most of it on the Mailbag page. Please allow at least 48 hours for it to be published. Thanks for reading The Price of Liberty!

Please note: Information about readers is never given or sold to anyone for any purpose. Remember, however, that many people can read and recover anything posted to web sites or email unless it is carefully encrypted. MamaLiberty)

Whose values?

Visit the Rational Review News Digest

Links to Previous
Commentaries
are on the front page for each day. Check the archives page.

[Some article sources require registration, use this link)


Submit Feedback

Name: