Libertarian Commentary on The News by Nathan A. Barton - Price of Liberty
11/21/08
Libertarian Commentary on The News
By Nathan A. Barton © 2005


Mission Statement
Revised 8.04.04
 
Editorial Policy Revised 3.19.04
 
See Reader's
Feedback
 
Reader's Forum
 
Looking for Health NEW
 
Commentary
on the News
 
Return to Home Page

October 31, 2005

Libertarian Commentary on the News, 24-28 October 2005
I present my eighth weekly summary. As Lady Susan (Mama Liberty) gets back into the swing of things and The Price of Liberty spins up to speed (or is that just inflation?), we'll continue the weekly effort for a while. Please, your comments and even your flames are wanted! The news and views presented herein are mine own selection from the cellar, and not necessarily those of anyone else!

Rosa Parks, 1913-2005
Detroit Free Press
"When Rosa Parks refused to get up, an entire race of people began to stand up for their rights as human beings. It was a simple act that took extraordinary courage in Montgomery, Ala., in 1955. It was a place where black people had no rights white people had to respect. It was a time when racial discrimination was so common, many blacks never questioned it. At least not out loud. But then came Rosa Parks." (10/24/05)

A brave lady, whose legacy was tarnished by blind liberalism, and who outlived the true and honest civil rights movement she helped create.

Government-Ruined, Theft-Funded Schools
A few good stories to remind us and help us encourage people to separate school and state!

ACLU of Southern California demands that school allow student to distribute Flyers opposed to military recruiters
ACLU
"Acting on behalf of a South Bay high school student and his parents, the American Civil Liberties Union of Southern California today sent a letter to the Manhattan Beach Unified School District demanding that school officials allow the student to distribute counter-military recruiting flyers without fear of punishment. Sixteen-year-old Joshua Goldman, a junior at Mira Costa High School, was told in early October by a vice principal that he could not pass out flyers titled "Questions the Army Doesn't Want You to Ask" without prior approval. Goldman had previously passed out leaflets and hung six posters on public and school property. Goldman would like to distribute the same leaflets next week when the military returns to the school for its monthly recruiting event. .... Goldman and his mother Elaine contacted the ACLU after a meeting with the vice principal in which Goldman was told he would face punishment for distributing his flyers to classmates if he did not obtain prior approval. .... The ACLU said that a policy of requiring prior approval would violate Goldman's free speech rights." (10/28/05)

Get your kids out, folks. Of course GRTF schools are going to support military recruiting, and to expect them to look favorably on efforts to counter that is to live in a dream world. And, there are far better places and ways to present such information, anyway.

Parents press for consent before school sex surveys
Boston Globe
"Some Massachusetts parents, outraged that schools quiz their children about sexual behavior, are pushing the state to require parental permission before posing questions like these: 'During the past three months, with how many people did you have sexual intercourse?' 'Have you ever given or received oral sex?' 'Which of the following best describes you: heterosexual, bisexual, gay or lesbian, not sure, or none of the above?' Such questions -- posed in confidential, anonymous surveys conducted by state or local school districts -- are meant to help public health specialists and educators learn more about student behavior and uncover dangerous trends, including the belief among youths that oral sex doesn't count as sex. o some parents, however, the surveys represent another example of schools reaching too far beyond the basics, delving into intensely personal issues that are best left to families, not just sex, but suicide and depression." (01/23/05)

Get your kids out, people!

Texas: Students suspended over paper gun
KGBTV News
"A piece of paper folded to resemble a gun led to the brief suspension of three Dallas-area students. DeSoto Independent School District officials later revoked the punishment. All were suspended after eleven-year-old Destiny Thomas on Monday folded some computer paper to look like a gun. The girl says another student at Amber Terrace Intermediate School had showed her how to fold the paper -- flat. Thomas and two other students were suspended and ordered to attend an alternative school for 30 days. The DeSoto student code says no weapons or replicas are allowed, but officials later reviewed the interpretation and dropped the punishment for the children." [Editor's note: Well, at least the school officials had some common sense ... but still. Get your kids OUT of publik schools before they are permanently damaged - MLS] (10/21/05)

Mary Lou is right - get them out! This kind of insanity should be grounds for firing teacher, staff, administrators AND recall of the school board who hired such idiots in the first place. But all that will happen is that they will be replaced by another set of idiots: find a private school or start one of your own, parents.

Internal American Problems and Unrest
This is replacing my "Gulf War III" section, since it appears that things are starting more and more to drop off the headlines down there. But we still have significant problems with preparation for, and response to, natural disasters and panic in response to what might be terrorism.

California: Threat prompts airport closures
NewsDay
"Airports in Long Beach and Orange County were shut down early Tuesday because of bomb threats, officials said. Bomb threats were made by telephone, according to Long Beach airport spokeswoman Sharon Diggs-Jackson and federal Transportation Security Administration spokesman Nico Melendez. At Long Beach, all early flights were canceled, said police Nancy Pratt. Police were searching the airport with bomb-sniffing dogs." (10/25/05)

Panic and disruption: a small taste of what has been happening in the Gulf States. Expect more, as people get more fed up with things.

Average US gas price drops 25 cents
Tampa Tribune
"Retail gas prices across the nation fell an average of 25 cents in the past two weeks as refineries in the Gulf Coast steadily resumed production, according to a survey released Sunday. Still, prices remained slightly higher than pre-Hurricane Katrina levels. The weighted average price for all three grades declined to $2.69 a gallon on Oct. 21, said Trilby Lundberg, who publishes the semimonthly Lundberg Survey of 7,000 gas stations around the country." (10/23/05)

Reports indicate that in some places even in Arkansas and other states near the Gulf Coast, regular unleaded prices have dropped to as low as $2.35 a gallon. And many areas are showing even greater drops (Arkansas, for example, has seen gas prices drop by over 50 cents in the last three weeks.) However, in at least part of the nation, diesel prices have jumped dramatically in the last week, in some cases from $3.09 to $3.49 a gallon. I suspect this is due to the huge sucking sound of federal cost-plus contracts for trucks to deliver construction supplies to the Gulf Coast. And spot shortages continue to plague areas: for example, South Dakota gas prices are now more than 30 cents below Colorado and Wyoming prices, when usually they run about the same.

Mideast Tarbabies
The lead news from the Middle East for most of the week was the results of the election in Iraq on the proposed constitution, which appears to have passed by the skin of the proverbial teeth. But the top billing belongs to this first story. Second in US headlines, of course, was the passing of the 2,000 milestone in US military dead in the war.

Iranian's 'Wipe Israel Off Map' Words Prompt Sharp World Response
SpaceWar.Com
Paris, France (AFP) Oct 26, 2005 - Widespread condemnation greeted remarks Wednesday by Iran's president that Israel should be wiped of the map, with Jerusalem seeing Teheran as a "clear and present danger" and Washington renewing concern about the Islamic Republic's nuclear aims.

There you are folks, so much for "moderate" Iranian fanatics.

2,000 Dead
Tampa Tribune
"The American military death toll in the Iraq war reached 2,000 Tuesday with the announcements of three more deaths, including an Army sergeant who died of wounds at a military hospital in Texas and two Marines killed last week in fighting west of Baghdad. The 2,000 mark was reached amid growing doubts among the American public about the Iraq conflict, launched in March 2003 to destroy Saddam Hussein's alleged weapons of mass destruction. None was ever found." (10/25/05)

At least the irrational claims that thousands of US dead were being concealed from the news and the people have dropped off, thanks to the efforts of many people opposed to the war who are not willing to dream up imaginary boogies, figuring we have enough to fight with real problems. At the same time, more subtle propaganda persists, as this very story demonstrates.

Iraq: Sunni leaders reject constitution
Reuters
"Arab Sunni leaders rejected a referendum which ratified a new Iraqi constitution on Tuesday, saying 'fraudulent' results would discourage them from taking part in December elections and fuel insurgent violence. 'Violence is not the only solution, if politics offers solutions so that we can move in that direction. But there is very little hope that we can make any gains in the elections,' said Sunni leader Saleh Mutlaq. 'I call on the free world. I call on the United Nations to intervene. We will not accept any referendum or election without international observers.' Iraq's Electoral Commission released final results of an October 15 referendum showing 79 percent approval for the constitution, a key part of the U.S. strategy of deflating of Sunni Arab insurgency in Iraq by promoting peaceful politics." (10/25/05)

No one expected most of the Sunni leaders to accept the Constitution, and they did not disappoint anyone, did they?

Iraq: Sunnis seek US pullout as deaths mount
Wired News
"Iraqi Sunni leaders said on Wednesday they would focus on pressing U.S. forces to pull out after failing to block a controversial constitution, hoping a U.S. death toll of 2,000 will encourage Washington to withdraw. 'Our political program will focus more on getting the Americans out of Iraq,' Hussein al-Falluji, a prominent Sunni who took part in talks on the constitution, told Reuters. 'Our message to the American administration is clear: get out of Iraq or set a timetable for withdrawal or the resistance will keep slaughtering your soldiers until judgment day.' ... Insurgents have resumed deadly attacks again after a relative lull in violence during the referendum and the trial of Saddam Hussein last week. Gunmen opened fire on a convoy of bodyguards for Iraq's minister of water resources in western Baghdad on Wednesday, wounding two people. Police said that the minister, Abdul Latif Rasheed, was not present. Gunmen also killed an official at Iraq's Ministry of Culture, Nabil Moussawi, and seriously wounded his driver in southern Baghdad. Insurgents, who struck in dramatic fashion on Monday with a triple suicide bomb attack on a Baghdad hotel used by foreign journalists, set off new blasts on Tuesday in Baghdad and the normally tranquil city of Sulaimaniya, killing at least 15 people." (10/26/05)

They talk about killing American soldiers, but what they really kill are either innocent passersby, or ordinary people trying to make a living, with the occasional government official or bodyguard for spice.

Iraq: Shiite coalition holds
Al Bawaba [Iraq]
"Roadside bombs killed two US troops in Baghdad and in Ramadi, west of the capital, on Thursday, press reports indicated on Friday. These latest deaths raised to 2,007 the number of U.S. military members who have died since the war in Iraq began in March 2003, according to an unofficial count. Meanwhile, the alliance of Shiite religious parties that swept Iraq's election in January has ;decided to remain together to contest the Dec. 15 parliamentary ballot, an official said Friday, according to the AP." (10/28/05)

After moaning and groaning and calling for UN intervention, they are still going to play politics, it seems. So much for principle.

UN: 2,200 cos. gave Iraq illicit funds
Indianapolis Star
"In a scathing final report documenting massive corruption in the U.N. oil-for-food program, investigators Thursday accused more than 2,200 companies, and prominent politicians, of colluding with Saddam Hussein's regime to bilk the humanitarian operation of $1.8 billion. The 623-page document exposed the global scope of a scam that allegedly involved such name-brand companies as DaimlerChrysler and Siemens AG, as well as a former French U.N. ambassador, a firebrand British politician and the president of Italy's Lombardi region." (10/27/05)

Seems to me like we heard this same kind of thing about the War Between the States, WW1, WW2, and even Korea, the Spanish-American War, and many of the Indian Wars: the various companies were supposedly subsidizing and dealing with the enemy.

15 killed in Sunni-Shiite clash near Baghdad
Houston Chronicle
"Sunni Arab militants killed 14 Shiite militiamen and a policeman today in a clash southeast of Baghdad - another sign of rising tensions among Iraq's rival ethnic and religious communities. The U.S. Military reported three more American soldiers died in combat. The Shiite-Sunni fighting occurred after police and militiamen loyal to radical Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr raided a house in Nahrawan, 15 miles southeast of the capital, to free a militiaman taken hostage by Sunni militants, according to Amer al-Husseini, an aide to al-Sadr." (10/27/05)

As I said, and will say again, the real fighting and killing in Iraq these days is Iraqi on Iraqi, and Muslim on Muslim (though there is enough left over for killing Americans, Iraqi Christians, and others they don't like).

Afghan journalist gets two years in jail
Detroit Free Press
"A women's magazine editor has been sentenced to two years in jail after being convicted of blasphemy for publishing anti-Islamic articles, including one challenging a belief that Muslims who convert to other religions should be stoned to death, a judge said Sunday. The case underlines the fragility of press freedoms in the nascent democracy and highlights a struggle between religious moderates and extremists over what form Islam will take in Afghanistan as foundations are laid for its future." (10/23/05)

We CANNOT expect a culture of evil which has existed for 1100-1300 years to change overnight, and this story reminds us of that.

Afghans investigate body-burning incident
USA Today
"A team of top Afghan officials was in the country's south Sunday to investigate charges that U.S. soldiers burned the remains of Taliban fighters they had killed and then used the scene for propaganda purposes. The four investigators were ordered by President Hamid Karzai to work 'urgently' amid warnings that the alleged desecration could spark anti-American demonstrations, Defense Ministry spokesman Zahir Azimi said." (10/23/05)

Whether or not the US used this for propaganda purposes, certainly the Taliban and other Islamicist groups are doing so, as is the antiwar movement in the US.

Baghdad bomb, attacks leave 20 dead in Iraq
Houston Chronicle
"An insurgent blew up his car in a Baghdad square today, killing four people in the first significant suicide bombing in the capital in weeks. More than 20 Iraqis died in a swell of violence, including a bomb that killed a police colonel and four children. Still, with the toll among American service members in the Iraq war approaching 2,000 dead, the U.S. military said it has hampered insurgents' ability to unleash more devastating suicide bombings with a series of offensives in western towns that disrupted militant operations." (10/23/05)

Yet another example of how the killing is really happening: butchers and murdering madmen using the US presence as an excuse, but who will find other excuses whenever the US does leave.

Coerced confession allowed in alleged assassination plot
MSNBC
"A federal judge ruled Monday that prosecutors can use a confession by a man charged with joining al-Qaida and plotting to assassinate President Bush, despite defense claims that the confession was obtained through torture. The ruling came after a six-day hearing in which Ahmed Omar Abu Ali testified that Saudi Arabian security officers whipped his back, kicked him in the stomach and pulled on his beard to obtain a confession." (10/24/05)

Apparently the judge doesn't believe the man - and that is not surprising.

DC: 26 arrested for "mourning Iraq dead"
Common Dreams
"Peace Action joined with other anti war groups in a day of action on Wednesday around the 2,000th unnecessary death of an American soldier in Iraq. Peace Action affiliates, along with allied antiwar groups and coalition partners participated in nearly 2,000 events nationwide. At the White House vigil, hundreds held candles calling for U.S. troops to be brought home from Iraq and for Congress to provide leadership to bring our troops home. Nearly fifty people laid head to toe on the sidewalk in front of the President's home just like soldiers are laid to rest at Arlington cemetery. Park police arrested 26 mourners at the 'die in' including Cindy Sheehan -- the mother who lost her son in Iraq and camped at Crawford, TX asking the President why." (10/27/05)

This kind of "mourning" should be called what it is: political propagandizing of the lowest kind - and despicable. At the same time, arrests are NOT an appropriate response, unless they really did break the law, which doesn't appear to be the case.

Iraq: Insurgents step up attacks
Modesto Bee
"Stepped-up attacks by insurgents over the last two days have killed at least 44 Iraqis, including 12 laborers -- five of them brothers -- who were gunned down at a construction site, police said Monday. In addition, the bodies of eight Iraqis who apparently were kidnapped and killed in captivity were found in the capital on Monday, police said. (10/24/05)

How many times have we heard this: that they are stepping up attacks? Seldom do we see a headline that says, "Relatively Peaceful Day in Iraq" but they do happen. What I do notice is that more and more it is plain, ordinary people being killed by murderous thugs.

Iraq: Reporters' hotel attacked; six dead
Las Vegas Review-Journal
"Suicide bombers including one in a cement truck packed with explosives launched a dramatic attack Monday against the Palestine Hotel, where many foreign journalists are based, sending up a giant cloud of smoke and debris over central Baghdad. American troops and journalists escaped without serious injury but at least a half-dozen passersby were killed. The deafening attack triggered confusion and panic throughout the hotel, and sent cars swerving wildly on a roundabout to escape the blasts. Inside the 19-story hotel, the force of the blasts shattered glass, tore pictures off walls and brought down light fixtures and ceilings." (10/24/05)

Oh, the moans and cries by the media. Hundreds of Iraqis are killed by murderous thugs, but this attack on journos is beyond the pale!

Iraq: Three US soldiers killed
Washington Times
"Two roadside attacks on military convoys in Iraq killed three U.S. Soldiers and injured four others Thursday. Military officials say one soldier was killed and four others injured when their patrol was attacked by an explosive and small arms fire near Ashraf. Two U.S. Soldiers were killed by a roadside bomb in eastern Baghdad, Voice of America said." (10/27/05)

These deaths are almost incidental, compared to the dozens of Iraqis killed by the so-called insurgents.

US commander tours Kashmir, pledges aid
Detroit Free Press
"U.S. Gen. John Abizaid, head of U.S. Central Command, flew over the destruction in Pakistani Kashmir on Sunday, pledging the United States would send more helicopters and keep up relief efforts for the 'long term.' In a bizarre twist, al-Qaida's deputy leader Ayman al-Zawahri called on Muslims to send aid to quake victims, despite Pakistani President Gen. Pervez Musharraf's cooperation with the United States in the fight against terrorism." (10/23/05)

How generous of al-Qaida! The US continues to be generous with taxpayers' money too, I see.

US, Britain press for action against Syria
CNN
"The United States and Britain jointly criticized Syria on Sunday and called for international action to be taken over a U.N. investigation that implicated Syrian officials in the killing of former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice didn't discuss any specific actions that the United States might push for when the U.N. Security Council considers the investigator's report Tuesday, but she said the matter 'really has to be dealt with.'" (10/23/05)

Noise, noise, and more noise.

UN draft demands Syrian cooperation
CNN
"A draft U.S.-French resolution being circulated Tuesday among the U.N. Security Council says Syria 'must detain' Syrian officials or individuals suspected of involvement in the assassination of former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri. The resolution also calls for freezing the assets of and placing a travel ban on any individual named as a suspect in a U.N. Investigation" (10/25/05)

UN demands are like paper money drawn in crayon by preschoolers, they are honored out of amusement and not to offend the offerers rather than because they mean anything. Don't think Syria is buying, though.

The Rush to the Fall of Europe
A few items this week, but enough to show that the disease of silliness and bloated government is alive and well on the "mother continent." Hard to believe these are the peoples that once nearly conquered the known world.

EU turns up its nose at attempt to trademark smell of strawberries
Independent [UK]
"A French perfume company specialising in luxurious cosmetics and toiletries has narrowly failed in an attempt to trademark the scent of ripe strawberries. The Paris-based Eden Sarl is the latest business to have the EU turn its nose up at an attempt to lock down a particular smell and turn it into a unique selling point. The rush of trademark claims followed a successful bid by a Dutch perfume company that registered the aroma of freshly cut grass in 2000. It used the patent to make tennis balls smell as good as the courts upon which they bounce. But Eden Sarl's claim to trademark the smell of strawberries for use in soaps and lotions was quashed yesterday by EU experts, who ruled that, as the fruit "does not have just one smell", its scent cannot be used as one company's unique selling point." (10/28/05)

Like copyrighting notes and letters, this is another attempt to use poorly written and often obscene laws and regulations to take something out of the public domain and gain a monopoly on something used everyday. Nothing prevents this company from using the smell of strawberries to sell their products, but they really want to prevent anyone else from using it - thus the trademark attempt. For once, a EU bureaucrat seems to have done the right thing.

Rome bans goldfish bowls
Yahoo! News
"The city of Rome has banned goldfish bowls, which animal rights activists say are cruel, and has made regular dog-walks mandatory in the Italian capital, the town's council said on Tuesday. ... The classic spherical fish bowls are banned under a new by-law which also stops fish or other animals being given away as fairground prizes. It comes after a national law was passed to allow jail sentences for people who abandon cats or dogs. ... The newspaper reported that round bowls caused fish to go blind. No one at Rome council was available to confirm this was why they were banned. Many fish experts say round bowls provide insufficient oxygen for fish." (10/25/05)

I guess Imperial Rome, all these centuries, with their goldfish bowls and casual cruelty to dogs, cats, hamsters, other small furry creatures and various untermensen, was completely uncivilized, instead of being the epitome of world, classical civilization.

Mama's Note: A little clue to the folks who worry about the oxygen for the stupid fish... clean the bowl once in a while and change the water. That's all it takes. Personally, I don't know anyone who has the time and patience to keep fish this way anyhow. Goldfish are about the dirtiest fish on the globe and I wouldn't have one as a gift. Perfect example of government making laws that are meaningless and counterproductive.

UK: Cabinet fight over rush to ban smoking
Guardian [UK]
"The health secretary, Patricia Hewitt, will face a cabinet-level battle today to win support for a ban on smoking in public places, including all private members' clubs, save for sealed rooms. She wants to get agreement today with a view to publishing the bill on Wednesday. Ms Hewitt has been facing resistance from some government departments who want a more readily enforceable total ban without exemptions. ... In a clear hardening of the government position since its election manifesto, Ms Hewitt is proposing the ban should be extended from pubs, restaurants, workplaces to include private members' clubs. She came up with the 'sealed rooms' idea after all sides shot down the plan offered by her predecessor at health, John Reid, in which smoking would be allowed in pubs that did not sell food. The critics say the sealed room idea is too complex." (10/24/05)

Couldn't happen to a better bunch of autocrats, really. Let the whole idea die a well-deserved death - and let people take care of whether to go someplace with smoke or not on their own. The free market will quickly do the job.

Mama's Note: Sealed rooms? What an idiotic idea. Talk about lack of oxygen! How were the smokers supposed to breathe at all? Or maybe that was the idea... kill them off faster.

Rape that never was sparks a riot
The Scotsman
POLICE are investigating 80 crimes - including the murder of a man - in the wake of racially charged riots that erupted in Birmingham over the weekend: Key points . One man dies as 50 riot in Birmingham over alleged rape of 14-year-old. Riots erupt after Afro-Caribean and Asian communities hold meeting. No evidence that young Caribbean girl was raped by Asian gang, say police.

Well, another case of where any excuse for a riot is welcome, at least to the people who like to riot.

Privacy Issues
More and more privacy issues are popping up on the headlines.

Arizona: Traffic violators face ID theft check
Arizona Republic
"Motorists cited for criminal traffic violations will have to give their thumbprint to Maricopa County Sheriff's deputies or go to jail. 'This will be mandatory. No exceptions,' Sheriff Joe Arpaio said Wednesday. 'If they don't want to give the print, they're going directly to jail. Period.' Arpaio launched the new policy Wednesday across the Valley, expanding and toughening a pilot program in which motorists pulled over for routine traffic stops were asked to voluntarily provide a thumbprint. The goal was to catch people who took the wheel with stolen or phony driver's licenses and ultimately to combat identity theft in Arizona, which ranks top in the nation for the crime." (10/20/05)

This Sheriff has a reputation for wild acts, and this is just another. But unlike many of his actions, this is very much anti-freedom, and needs to be fought. Let us see how many people he is really willing to put in jail for minor traffic violations, who believe that their rights are worth being locked up for.

California: Software glitch reveals private student data
San Francisco Chronicle
"The personal information of tens of thousands of California children -- including their names, state achievement test scores, identification numbers and status in gifted or special-needs programs -- is open to public view through a security loophole in dozens of school districts statewide that use a popular education software system. ... The problem occurs when the districts issue a generic password to teachers using the system. Until the teacher changes to a unique password, anyone can type in a teacher's user name and generic password and gain access to information about students that is supposed to be guarded as closely as the gold in Fort Knox. ... San Francisco administrators immediately shut down access to the service, called OARS -- Online Assessment Reporting System -- after a reporter phoned and said she had been able to access student information for all the children in two middle-school classes where the teachers had not yet changed their passwords." (10/21/05)

One of the major problems with government having vast volumes of information about citizens of any age: they are so easily compromised.

China: Trouble cracking down on Internet
Nashua Telegraph
"Two new Internet bans may offer insight into the Chinese government's biggest fears. One bars Internet news services from inciting 'illegal' assemblies, marches and demonstrations; the other prohibits activities on behalf of 'illegal' civil groups. Together, they evince the communist regime's concerns over growing civil unrest -- and particularly technology's role in fostering protests and strikes. ... Although the Chinese government encourages Internet use for education and business, it keeps a tight watch, blocking material it deems subversive or pornographic. Online dissidents who post items critical of the government, or those expressing opinions in chat rooms, are regularly arrested and charged under vaguely worded state security laws. Authorities also have clamped down on popular discussion forums, barring non-students from university chat rooms and banning anonymous postings. But newer outlets such as text messaging are even more difficult to control." (10/24/05)

What China is doing today, western governments will be trying tomorrow. It seems to have become a testbed for such efforts, and hopefully, for the means to work around them and defeat them.

FCC expands Net spy rule to educational institutions
Oregon Daily Emerald
"The University has less than 18 months to revamp its telecommunications systems so law enforcement agencies will have easier access to information if given a court order to investigate, according to a new order from the Federal Communications Commission. The FCC announced on Sept. 23 that the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act now applies to facilities-based broadband Internet access providers, including higher education institutions, K-12 schools and libraries. The act was first implemented in 1994 to require telephone carriers to make their systems open to federal surveillance with the permission of a court order. It was expanded to account for the increase in broadband Internet usage." (10/27/05)

Now that universities are involved, we might finally get a serious movement established to fight this kind of government intrusion. Keep in mind that they may start it, but any organization dedicated to this must expect the universities (dependent as they are on government money) to drop out later.

Our Right to Defend Ourselves
Another week with good news about people defending themselves, their homes, property, friends, neighbors, and even relatives, but a few sour notes, too.

Arkansas: Police investigate home invasion
Hometown Channel
"Shots rang out in a Fort Smith neighborhood Thursday, part of what police now say was an attempted home invasion. According to police, a man who just got out of jail tried to get back into a home where he once lived. About 1 p.m. Thursday, police said Marvin Wilson, 42, showed up at a home on the corner of 46th and Kinkead. Wilson's brother and another woman who lived inside would not let him in the home. That's when, police said, he got angry, which caused Alonzo Wilson -- Marvin's brother -- to use force to keep him out. Officials said they believe he fired one shot at Marvin Wilson, who was not hit. Marvin Wilson reportedly took off in his car but did not get far." (10/27/05)

Sometimes the stupidity of the criminal class is hard to believe.

Australia: Gun owners to have storage facilities inspected
ABC Queensland [Australia]
"Western Queensland gun owners will face a safety audit to ensure their weapons are being stored correctly. The six-month statewide audit will see police make appointments with randomly selected licenced weapon holders to inspect their storage facilities. Weapons licencing branch Inspector Mike Crowley says the move is all about positive reinforcement."The legislation is very clear on how firearms are to be stored, and this is purely put in place to act as a safety guideline, for not only the individual but the community at large," he said. "It's very important that people who have firearms secure them so they do not fall into the hands of inappropriate people or those people not authorised to possess them.'" (10/27/05)

You would think that the cops would have better things to do - but gun control is such a high priority in Australia that this is no surprise.

Mama's Note: Do they require the robbers and home invaders to make an appointment too? Most of the time this "proper storage" renders the weapon totally useless in an emergency.

Gun possession now OK at FEMA temporary housing
USA Today
"Following complaints from gun-rights groups, FEMA said Monday it is lifting a ban on firearms at emergency housing parks built in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. Under the new federal policy, residents can possess and store firearms. Use of weapons is still prohibited in the parks, said Butch Kinerny, a spokesman for the Federal Emergency Management Agency. Gun rights groups had sought the change, saying the original policy violated Second Amendment protections for gun ownership." (10/24/05)

Finally: but don't expect anyone who makes known that they are keeping their weapons to have an easy go of it: FEMA and local officials will make life miserable for them - and what good is a gun if you can't use it to defend yourself or your family without committing a crime - very, but the risk is greater!

Indiana: Man shot in robbery attempt
WISH TV News
"A man is recovering after he was shot in what Indianapolis police say was an attempted robbery. A security guard called police around 12:45 a.m. Saturday morning after finding a man shot in the side, at the Campus Apartments on West 10th Street. Medics took the man to Wishard Hospital while police discovered he was a suspect in an attempted robbery that had happened just minutes before. Police say the man and another suspect attempted to rob a business across the street, but a delivery driver stumbled onto them and shot one of the suspects." (10/22/05)

An alert and prepared delivery man! Great!

Nevada: Man shoots 1 of 2 people police say tried to rob him
RGJ
"A 38-year-old man with a permit to carry a concealed firearm shot one of two men accused of trying to rob him at a car wash late Monday, Reno police said. Luis Alfredo Aguirre, 18, of Reno was booked into the Washoe County Jail on suspicion of attempted armed robbery. His cousin, Jorge Aguilar, 21, of Reno, was treated Tuesday at Washoe Medical Center for a bullet wound in his liver .... Police said the the cousins are known gang members." (10/26/05)

Good for him.

Mama's Note: And what would have happened if he had not been able to get the "permit?" This would be a whole different story, for sure, and the intended victim might well be dead. The only real purpose of any "permit" system is exactly the same as any other gun registration: eventual confiscation.

Ohio: Home invader shot,killed
NBC 4 TV News
"Police said that a resident shot and killed one of three men who were apparently trying to break into his home early Tuesday. .... According to police, between four and six men were attempting to break into one of the apartments when at one point one of the men was shot." (10/25/05)

More would have been better, but at least the family and home is safe.

Texas: 2 intruders shot in 2 days by homeowners
WFAA News
"Some homeowners have taken the law into their own hands. In the last couple of days, two people have shot burglars they said were trying to get into their homes. The first incident happened Saturday morning in Grand Prairie. A homeowner shot and killed a suspected burglar in the 2800 block of Lake Park Drive. It happened again Sunday night in Dallas when Clyde Buchanan said he shot an intruder in the 2800 block of Arizona Avenue." (10/25/05)

It does say, "we the people" and we have every right to enforce the law on our own when it comes to defending our homes and ourselves, friends, and families.

Thailand: Queen urges self defense for locals
Bangkok Post
"Her Majesty the Queen has suggested that self-defence training be provided for local residents living around a Buddhist temple in Pattani where an elderly monk and two temple boys were brutally murdered on October 16. Gen Napol Boonthap, the deputy aide-de-camp, has been asked to coordinate with the army to provide the training in self-defence to locals living near Wat Phromprasit in Panare district. .... The applicants, including 10 women, were aged from 16-66. They will undergo training for six days, said Lt-Col Pakorn. Afterwards, the trainees would be responsible for guarding their communities. Around 15 shotguns would be handed out to the villagers. ''Her Majesty the Queen wants locals to be trained so they can use weapons in self-defence and to protect their villages and temple,'' Lt-Col Pakorn said." (10/27/05)

Renewing her previous calls for people to defend themselves, she is running counter to the policies of Royally around the rest of the world. Good for her! And for the people who are volunteering to do this.

Michigan considers change to self-defense statute
Times-Herald
"Several years ago, William 'Dick' Turner and his wife came home to find people robbing their Kimball Township home. The thieves stole several guns and were going through jewelry when the Turners interrupted them, he said. The robbers ran out the back door. 'I felt violated,' Turner, 73, said. 'My wife still doesn't feel safe at home alone.' Since then, Turner has taught his family how to load guns in the home in case they need to protect themselves. Legislation introduced in the state House would allow residents who feel they are being threatened to use force against an intruder without facing criminal or civil prosecution. Reaction to the proposed law is mixed." (10/24/05)

No law should be required for this, which is embedded in the national and virtually every state constitution - at best, a simple resolution to clearly and forcefully enforce the state constitution's recognition of the God-given right to defend ourselves should be needed.

Michigan:Sentencing upsets victimized couple
Michigan Live
"After hearing a rapid succession of doorbell rings and with a previous burglary in the back of her mind, she wasn't going to greet unexpected visitors to her Saline Township home while her husband was out. But she didn't have that choice. Within a minute, she heard the door being kicked down and the mother of two did what came instinctively - she called 911 and grabbed the family pistol. Randy Fraley, the man she confronted in the kitchen, bolted out of the house with his arms in the air, yelling for her not to shoot, police reports said. Determined to stop him without inflicting a mortal wound, Sharp fired into the getaway car where his female accomplice awaited. Four of the nine shots pierced the vehicle, leaving it disabled a few blocks away on Braun Road. .... On Monday, Sharp and her husband, Michael, watched with some relief but largely in frustration as Fraley, 36, was sentenced to 7 to 20 years in prison. He pleaded guilty earlier to first-degree home invasion and conspiracy to commit home invasion in two separate Washtenaw County cases. They were frustrated, in part, because it was at least the sixth prison sentence that Fraley, an admitted crack addict, has received since 1989 for property crimes." (10/25/05)

One reason why the above law is needed.

Zaire: Gun owners refused licences set to sue
Independent Online [South Africa]
"A gun lobby group is suing Minister of Safety and Security Charles Nqakula for R3,2-billion for compensation to its members whose appeals for gun licence renewal applications were turned down. In addition, those who have not yet applied say they will defy the law and not apply after seeing how the other members were treated. Black Gun Owners' Association (BGOA) president Abios Khoele said the association's legal team were busy preparing court papers to be served on Nqakula after 15 000 of its members had their firearm licence renewal applications refused." (10/23/05)

A warning to us all that licensing exists only for the sake of later denying the permits, and sooner or later, rounding up the guns (and usually, their owners).

Brazilians reject proposed gun ban
Las Vegas Review-Journal
"Brazilians soundly rejected a proposal to ban the sale of guns in a national referendum Sunday, striking down the bid to stem one of the world's highest firearm murder rates following a campaign that drew parallels to the U.S. gun control debate. Brazil has 100 million fewer citizens than the United States, but a staggering 25 percent more gun deaths at nearly 40,000 a year. While supporters argued that gun control was the best way to staunch the violence, opponents played on Brazilians' fears that the police can't protect them." (10/23/05)

Great news! 64% to 36%. The best thing to reduce the gun-killing rate is to make sure that more and more peaceful and honest citizens are able to defend themselves!

Brazil: President says access to guns won't help citizens' security
Bloomberg
" Brazil's President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva said Brazilians' vote in favor of keeping access to handguns won't make them any more secure. Brazilians voted 64 percent to 36 percent in a referendum yesterday to reject a proposed ban on retail sales of guns and ammunition, the national elections authority said on its Web site. The balloting marks the first time a country put a gun- control measure to a popular vote, according to the human-rights group Amnesty International. 'Common people having guns won't provide security,'' Lula said after casting his ballot in favor of the ban, according to Estado de S. Paulo newspaper." [RRND Editor's note: Heaven forbid that 'common people' have the means to defend themselves-MLS](10/25/05)

Mama's Note: Given the almost total corruption of government in most, if not all the countries of the Americas, the very fact that this was put to a vote is pretty incredible. I highly suspect that government corruption is responsible for much of the murder rate there too. Unfortunately, they will still have the man and fire power to overwhelm the "common people" most of the time. But I hope that the people won't allow the government propaganda to overcome their good sense and will keep their guns permanently.

Stupid Government Tricks
A juicy selection today!

Councilman questions tax financing for stadium
Nashville City Paper
"Metro Councilman-at-Large David Briley Wednesday expressed concern about the amount of tax increment financing the city has offered to partially fund the proposed downtown Sounds stadium and accompanying mixed-use development. He believes it is disproportionately high, given the project's price tag. The project would be smaller than the roughly $230 million developer Struever Bros., Eccles & Rouse proposed this summer. Sounds General Manager Glenn Yaeger said the stadium would cost $43 million and the mixed-use buildings about $40-$60 million. Yaeger and Mayor Bill Purcell announced Tuesday that Metro would provide the Sounds an upfront $17 million payment to help fund the stadium through a tax increment financing (TIF) loan, which the Sounds would repay in the form of future property taxes. Briley said he believes this amount is roughly five to six times greater than what would be provided for a normal project." [Editor's note: They've removed everything but the city's investment in paying for it, but it still isn't a private deal. - SAT] (10/27/05)

Tax revolters are still pushing just as hard as ever in Tennessee, especially in Nashville, where thousands of signatures on a TABOR (Taxpayers Bill of Rights) initiative are already collected, and though not needed until Spring, may be sufficient by Thanksgiving to force a vote and help get rid of sweetheart deals like this.

Administration drops "bunker-buster" plan
Tampa Tribune
"The Bush administration has abandoned research into a nuclear 'bunker-buster' warhead, deciding instead to pursue a similar device using conventional weaponry, a key Republican senator said Tuesday. Sen. Pete Domenici, R-N.M., said funding for the nuclear bunker-buster as part of the Energy Department's fiscal 2006 budget has been dropped at the department's request. The nuclear bunker-buster had been the focus of intense debate in Congress, with opponents arguing that its development as a tactical nuclear weapon could add to nuclear proliferation." (10/25/05)

Or at least it has gone into the black portion of the budget, due to the fuss caused.

Brazil: Rio discourages sex tourism with postcard ban
Independent Online
"The "Girl from Ipanema" may soon have to cover up, at least if she wants to appear on a postcard in Rio de Janeiro. Postcards of bikini-clad beauties frolicking on Rio's famed beaches could be banned from sales in the city's shops and newsstands in an attempt to discourage sex tourism. The Rio state assembly approved the ban on Tuesday night, and state governor Rosinha Matheus has 30 days to ratify it. "These postcards ... attract to our city the wrong kind of tourist and promote deplorable sex tourism," said the bill's sponsor, deputy Alice Tamborindeguy." (10/26/05)

Postcards are such a recruiting tool? Really. I don't suppose the thousands of feet of video tape and hundreds of web-sites about Mardi Gras have anything to do with it.

California: Governator's initiatives lag in poll
ABC News
"Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's 'year of reform' initiatives are proving a tough sell to California voters despite a multimillion dollar advertising blitz, according to a poll released Thursday. None of his measures on the Nov. 8 ballot has majority support, and two are opposed by wide margins. The bombardment of radio and television ads from Schwarzenegger and his opponents have generated voter interest in the election, the Public Policy Institute of California poll found. So far, that interest has failed to translate into support for the governor's agenda. ... Telephone interviews were conducted with 1,079 likely voters over seven days ending Oct. 23. There was a sampling error of plus or minus 3 percentage points. Voters also remain skeptical of the former action star turned politician, with a majority disapproving how he has handled the job. Only 38 percent approve of his performance in office, while 57 percent disapprove." (10/27/05)

Schwarzeneggar may have to face the truth that California is too far gone for ANY attempts at reform to work, as the electors of the state have learned the same lesson the citizens of Rome did: buy the government they want and deserve.

Mama's Note: This should be a major wake up call for people who think all our problems would be solved if we could just elect some Libertarians to such positions. Schwarzenegger is as much a socialist as any governor in the country, and if he can't get a few very modest reforms carried out, you can just imagine what would happen to someone who tried to turn loose the real free market or make serious reductions in government size and theft. They'd be run out of town on a rail fast - or impeached. Real reform won't happen until government manages to completely destroy itself. Unfortunately, it will take our economy and most of our society down with it.

California: Tax law casts doubt on stem cell royalties
San Francisco Chronicle
"The billion dollars in royalties that voters were told could flow to the state if they passed California's $3 billion stem cell research funding initiative in 2004 may turn into an empty promise. Researchers and business groups are raising a host of reasons the state should claim no portion of the revenue from inventions produced under the stem cell program created by Proposition 71. For one thing, they say, requiring that the state get a share would hinder work toward disease cures by removing some of the incentive for private investors. But perhaps their strongest argument is that the state might actually be forbidden from sharing royalties by federal tax laws -- that is, if California chooses to finance the program by the cheapest possible route: tax-exempt bonds." (10/25/05)

Surprise, surprise: the politicians lied again to get the voters to do what they want.

China cuts income tax for low wage earners
The Raw Story
"China's legislature agreed Saturday to cut income taxes on the country's poorest workers amid official concern that the country's growing gap between rich and poor could fuel unrest. Chinese who make less than 1,600 yuan a month ($198) will no longer need to pay income tax, up from the previous cutoff point of 800 yuan ($98), the official Xinhua News Agency reported. An earlier government report said the cutoff point would be 1,500 yuan a month ($185) but it was amended upward in response to public opinion, Xinhua said. The amendment to China's tax law was submitted to the legislature for deliberation in August." (10/22/05)

The People's State is taking care of the people again, I see. By Western standards, none of these people would be expected to pay taxes, of course.

Clinton: Oil firms should pay energy fee
Binghamton Press & Sun-Bulletin
"Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton proposed on Tuesday that oil companies be required to use some of their profits over the next two years to pay for new tax incentives to spur development of cleaner, cheaper energy. Officials at the American Petroleum Institute, the trade group for the oil industry, decried Clinton's proposal, which they said appeared to be calling to reinstate the windfall profits tax imposed on the industry during the 1980s." (10/26/05)

In this, Hillary has proven both that she does not understand economics AND that she is willing to do anything she can to cater to the whims of those she wants to vote her back into the White House.

Colorado: Telluride icy to pot issue
Denver Post
"'This is a pretty antiestablishment community. You fit in here by being abnormal,' said resident John Albertson. But that doesn't mean that a ballot issue to ease marijuana enforcement in this high-altitude hamlet is a big hit with the locals. Even residents who might be expected to champion the measure, which calls for ranking possession of small amounts of marijuana by adults the lowest priority for the Telluride Marshal's Department, are refusing to back ballot Question 200. 'To me, it's a bad idea,' said San Miguel County Sheriff Bill Masters, who has made national waves as a libertarian critic of drug laws he calls ineffectual. The complaints about Question 200 center on who is backing it, whether it is necessary and what kind of outside drug-enforcement cross hairs it might place this town in if it were to pass." (10/28/05)

Sometimes you need to leave well-enough alone, and this appears to be the attitude of many people in this yuppie-hippie town high in the mountains.

More News and Commentary on Page 2

Nathan Barton is a libertarian engineer and writer, enjoying the cooling evenings in the Rockies and the Four Corners, where "monsoon" rains cause some creeks to overflow their banks, but nothing like the mess down in the South. His views are his own and do not necessarily represent the views of anyone else, including the sources of his news and other libertarians! Be sure to visit my blog, Liberty's Outpost.

Special Feature! Add your signature to the NEW Declaration of Independence
By Robert Greenslade

Several people have asked about buying Gadsden Flags (the rattlesnake "Don't Tread on Me flags used by the June 23d Movement and other Property Rights Organizations: you can get them for $10.00 plus shipping here.


To Read previous Commentaries, go to the archives page and click onto the link for the day. The commentaries are linked from the daily front pages.


Your feedback is always welcome! Please use the form below. If you enter your email address, the author can respond to your comment. Not all feedback can be answered personally, of course, but you will find most of it on the Mailbag page. Please allow at least 48 hours for it to be published. Thanks for reading The Price of Liberty!

Please note: Information about readers is never given or sold to anyone for any purpose. Remember, however, that many people can read and recover anything posted to web sites or email unless it is carefully encrypted. MamaLiberty)

Whose values?

Visit the Rational Review News Digest

Links to Previous
Commentaries
are on the front page for each day. Check the archives page.

[Some article sources require registration, use this link)


Submit Feedback

Name: