Libertarian Commentary on The Day's News by Nathan A. Barton - Price of Liberty
01/08/09
Libertarian Commentary on The News
By Nathan A. Barton © 2005


Mission Statement
Revised 8.04.04
 
Editorial Policy Revised 3.19.04
 
See Reader's
Feedback
 
Reader's Forum
 
Looking for Health NEW
 
Commentary
on the News
 
Return to Home Page

September 10, 2005 --- written for September 08

What next? With things starting to calm down in the South, events are proceeding around the world - many not too good for lovers of freedom.

Business and Our Freedoms

Firms test web immigration check
Wired
"Many Americans focus on the border when they consider the fight against illegal immigration. But some experts say the real battle should be in the workplace to stop the hiring of people without work visas. Simple enough in theory, but how can you tell who's an illegal immigrant? Many companies now do little more than eyeball documents, saying they lack the expertise and resources to go any further -- and they seldom face federal sanctions. But across the country, a small group of businesses is quietly testing a Department of Homeland Security program that can check immigration status with a few clicks on the internet. The program will likely be at the heart of any federal immigration reform, even as critics say it needs improvement." (09/05/05)

Like the War on Some Drugs, the upcoming War on "Illegal Immigration" may have very far-reaching "unintended" consequences: one of which is even more government control and meddling in private business, being tested now.

Yahoo! 'gave e-mail details that helped jail Chinese writer'
Independent [UK]
"Information supplied by the internet giant Yahoo! to Chinese intelligence has resulted in the conviction of a journalist for "divulging state secrets abroad", a respected international press organisation said. Shi Tao, who worked for the daily business publication Dangdai Shang Bao (Contemporary Business News) until he was arrested in November 2004, was sentenced to 10 years in prison last April, in a case underlining the stringent censorship regime which controls the Chinese media. He was convicted of sending foreign-based websites the text of a "top secret" government message that had been sent to his newspaper. The text warned Chinese journalists of the dangers of social destabilisation and risks resulting from the return of certain dissidents on the 15th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square massacre. .... The US multinational Yahoo! allows the Chinese version of its search engine to be censored - it bars any mention of the Free Tibet campaign, for example - and critics say it is willing to stifle free speech in order to gain access to the lucrative Chinese market." (09/07/05)

Are there any large "high-technology" companies that are supporting liberty anywhere? Microsoft, Google, Yahoo, and dozens of others seem to support governments more than their other customers, as this nasty little story shows.

UK: Gov't to crack down on doctors
Guardian [UK]
"The government promised last night to crack down on GPs in England who contrive to meet targets to reduce patient waiting times by refusing to offer appointments more than a day or two in advance. The issue embarrassed Tony Blair during the general election campaign when he was confronted by a mother during a live broadcast on BBC Television's Question Time. Diana Church said her GP recommended her son should come back a week later, but the receptionist said no bookings could be made more than 48 hours ahead. The prime minister had been advised that primary care trusts claimed 99% of patients could see a GP within two working days - the government's target for speedy access. But a report today from the Healthcare Commission showed this assurance was misleading. It found 12% of patients were unable to see a GP within 48 hours and 30% said they could not book an appointment three or more days in advance." (09/06/05)

Since these doctors are, in effect, government employees, and since government regulations and controls are what have caused this mess, I fail to see how more government regulations and controls are going to solve it.

Mama's Note: What a joke! The UK killed any trace of the free market in medicine, which produced massive shortages since few have any incentive to even practice medicine this way. So, they decide to reduce the shortages, reflected in the fact that few can get an appointment, by passing a law! They might as well pass a law that requires water to run uphill.

Our Right to Defend Ourselves

Utah: Gun-toting poster misfires in Kanab
Salt Lake Tribune
"A poster featuring members of the Kanab High School football team decked out in camouflage bullet-resistant vests, military helmets, khakis and holding a variety of automatic weapons and a high-powered rifle is destined to become a collectors' item. On Friday the principal said the posters will be pulled back from the businesses where they were distributed this week and replaced with a toned-down version. "No more guns," declared Doug Jacobs of the poster featuring seven senior-class members of the football team. The photo was meant to show determination and toughness. .... The new poster, printed Friday, pictures members of the team dressed in their red-and-white uniforms. Team members try to outdo the previous year's poster in conveying a sense of toughness, said Jacobs. Last year's poster featured team members dressed like Cowboys - the team's nickname. They also wore guns, but it did not raise eyebrows." (09/03/05)

Even in supposedly conservative Utah we find this hoploclastic attitude.

North Carolina: Weapons counseling stays in bill
Charlotte Observer
"The House decided Wednesday to keep a new policy on advising domestic violence victims about carrying a gun, rejecting Gov. Mike Easley's request to nullify a law he signed a few days ago. The law requires court clerks to give victims information on applying for a concealed weapon permits. Advocates for domestic violence victims wanted something akin to a repeal because they think it's a bad idea to encourage domestic violence victims to get weapons. .... Victims advocates had hoped Easley would veto the bill. Instead, he signed it and his office worked with House leaders to change it. But a bill that would have repealed the section of the new law pertaining to notifying victims about the weapon permit was defeated, 49-57. .... Rep. Mark Hilton, the Conover Republican who sponsored the law, objected to a last-minute change after the legislature had already approved the idea overwhelmingly. "Simple educational information is all we're asking for," Hilton said. "This bill would gut what we're trying to do.' The gun-rights group Grass Roots North Carolina pushed for the law." (09/01/05)

I will be amazed if the weak-kneed governor and his flunkies don't find some other way to weasel out of this.

South Africa: Black gunowners suing for RKBA
News 24
"The South African Black Gunowners Association (Sabga) is suing the government for billions of rands because of gun-licence applications constantly being turned down. They claim 99.9% of all Sabga members' applications for gun licences have been rejected. Sabga chairperson Amos Khoele said on Friday the application had been submitted to Pretoria High Court. "More than 10 000 of the 20 000 association members have been robbed in the past year. "Many were wounded and some were even murdered. "They are not allowed to use their weapons in self-defence as applications for renewal of their licences are rejected en masse." (09/02/05)

It seems like both blacks and whites need to join in a revolt this time to get rid of this corrupt, tyrannical, and increasingly evil government.

Survey: Only 1.7 million kids in properly armed homes
USA Today
"About 1.7 million U.S. children live in homes with loaded, unlocked firearms, according to the largest survey ever done on home weapons storage, out Tuesday in the Pediatrics online journal. James Mercy, researcher with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and colleague Catherine Okoro analyzed surveys of 224,000 adults done by health departments in 50 states and the District of Columbia during 2002." (09/06/05)

Can we see a trend here? State by state, compared with "child" deaths by gunfire, the numbers don't match up, because the premise that a loaded, readily available firearm leads to increased deaths and injuries of children is bogus.

Gulf War Three

New Orleans: Mayor orders residents kidnapped
Tampa Tribune
"As flood waters receded inch by inch Tuesday, New Orleans Mayor C. Ray Nagin authorized law enforcement officers and the U.S. military to force the evacuation of all residents who refuse to heed orders to leave the dark, dangerous city. Nagin's emergency declaration released late Tuesday targets those still in the city unless they have been designated by government officials as helping with the relief effort." (09/06/05)

Although FEMA is being blamed for everything going wrong, we once more see the CIA-fearing, foul-mouthed, whining, incompetent mayor is not part of the solution: as always, he is part of the problem.

New Orleans Begins Confiscating Firearms as Water Recedes
New York Times
Waters were receding across this flood-beaten city today as police officers began confiscating weapons, including
legally registered firearms, from civilians in preparation for a mass forced evacuation of the residents still living here. No civilians in New Orleans will be allowed to carry pistols, shotguns or other firearms, said P. Edwin Compass III, the superintendent of police. "Only law enforcement are allowed to have weapons," he said.

This belongs both here and in the category above. How long will it take before they come for all of our defensive weapons? Only time will tell, but the fight to keep them better start pretty soon. MamaLiberty

Churches take charge and care for survivors
Detroit Free Press
" They came to the steps of the altar, wearing dirty T-shirts and muddy flip-flops. They cried and prayed and thanked God for being alive. On the first Sunday after Hurricane Katrina, churches in Baton Rouge were filled with relief workers, volunteer coordinators and survivors. Many churches have found a niche, becoming mini-relief agencies, filling in gaps where the government has failed." (09/05/05)

The mainstream media has a vested interest in not admitting that, far from being a "niche, . mini-relief agency" that private, voluntary efforts by churches and others are the only truly effective and efficient ways of dealing with disasters like this.

Need is vast, but so is outpouring
Christian Science Monitor
"The Chatmans popped the trunk on their aging Oldsmobile and pulled out garbage bags bursting with baby formula, clothes, shoes, sheets, and food. The Baton Rouge family didn't know anyone affected by hurricane Katrina. But when they heard a local television station was a designated donation drop-off location, they gathered up all they could and headed into town. The entire region - indeed, the nation - has responded in a huge outpouring of support for those affected by Katrina." (09/05/05)

Thousands of people doing little things like this are proving more effective than the great lumbering dinosaurs of local, state, and federal agencies.

Samaritan evacuates 82 to San Diego
Sign on San Diego
"A local businessman's concern for victims of Hurricane Katrina compelled him to charter a passenger jet and bring to San Diego 82 people who had lost everything in the disaster. David Perez, 42, said he was so disturbed by images of ineffective disaster relief that he spent about $250,000 to hire the Boeing 737 and fly the evacuees from Baton Rouge, La., to Lindbergh Field yesterday." (09/05/05)

Meanwhile it seems that government agencies weren't able to use enough common sense to keep 100 school buses from being drowned in flood waters so that thousands could have been evacuated BEFORE the water came.

Mama's Note: This was a nice gesture, but unless he proposes to support these 82 people indefinitely he didn't help them much. The cost of living is very high in San Diego and I'm sure the taxpayers there will not be thrilled to have 82 more mouths to feed. He could have supported all of them for quite a while on the money he spent for the airplane. Some people just don't have good sense.

Katrina medical help held up by red tape
CNN
"Volunteer physicians are pouring in to care for the sick, but red tape is keeping hundreds of others from caring for Hurricane Katrina survivors while health problems rise. Among the doctors stymied from helping out are 100 surgeons and paramedics in a state-of-the-art mobile hospital, developed with millions of tax dollars for just such emergencies, marooned in rural Mississippi. "The bell was rung, the e-mails were sent off. ...We all got off work and deployed," said one of the frustrated surgeons, Dr. Preston "Chip" Rich of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. "We have tried so hard to do the right thing. It took us 30 hours to get here," he said. That government officials can't straighten out the mess and get them assigned to a relief effort now that they're just a few miles away "is just mind-boggling," he said." [RRND Editor's note: Reminds me of another story that I only saw on my local news, a team of medical personnel from the Medical College of Georgia, waiting since LAST Tuesday to be 'deployed' to the disaster area.-MLS] (09/05/05)

The problem here is that too many folks, too many groups, are waiting for permission from some jumped-up government agency, when (like the folks with the trunk full of supplies) they need to just go ahead and move as close as possible and set up and spread the word by CB, internet, and if necessary, runner, that they are open for business.

Why FEMA was missing in action
Los Angeles Times
"While the federal government has spent much of the last quarter-century trimming the safety nets it provides Americans, it has dramatically expanded its promise of protection in one area -- disaster. ... But the government's stumbling response to the storm that devastated the nation's Gulf Coast reveals that the federal agency singularly most responsible for making good on Washington's expanded promise has been hobbled by cutbacks and a bureaucratic downgrading. The Federal Emergency Management Agency once speedily delivered food, water, shelter and medical care to disaster areas, and paid to quickly rebuild damaged roads and schools and get businesses and people back on their feet. ... But in the aftermath of the Sept. 11 attacks, FEMA lost its Cabinet-level status as it was folded into the giant new Department of Homeland Security. And in recent years it has suffered budget cuts, the elimination or reduction of key programs and an exodus of experienced staffers." [RRND editor's note: Excuses mostly, but also some explanation? - SAT] (09/05/05)

It has taken days for this to sink in, and still far too many people think that "first response" is the duty of a government agency and specifically of FEMA; and that only guvmint is capable of doing anything. Many people involved in emergency response and management have been beating this drum (and being ignored) for several years.

Katrina response raises questions about homeland security
WBIR-TV [Knoxville, TN]
"Hurricane Katrina has become the Homeland Security Department's first big test. Since the department was created after the 9/11 attacks to prevent and respond to catastrophes, it has spent tens of billions of dollars, studied disaster scenarios of every imaginable kind and run some of the nation's biggest emergency response drills. It should have been ready for just about anything. But it wasn't ready for the power of Katrina. Today, as workers struggle to provide better relief for survivors, Congress will begin investigating why the government's response was so slow. Sens. Susan Collins, R-Maine, and Joe Lieberman, D-Conn., leaders of the Senate Homeland Security committee, will discuss their committee's plan for an inquiry into the response by the Federal Emergency Management Agency. The agency is the disaster-response division of the Homeland Security Department. 'We intend to demand answers as to how this immense failure occurred,' the senators said in a statement." (09/06/05)

The first and foremost investigation Congress should do is of itself: IT passed the laws that created this situation. And the first question to be answered is what authority the FedGov has to do any of this.

Bush to seek $40 billion for next phase of Katrina debacle
Tampa Tribune
"President Bush intends to seek as much as $40 billion to cover the next phase of relief and recovery from Hurricane Katrina, congressional officials said Tuesday as leading lawmakers and the White House pledged to investigate an initial federal response widely condemned as woefully inadequate. One week after the hurricane inflicted devastation of biblical proportions on the Gulf Coast, Senate Democratic leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., said the total tab for the federal government may top $150 billion. At the same time, senators in both parties said they suspect price gouging by oil companies in the storm's aftermath." (09/06/05)

Another 40 billion (about 136 dollars per man, woman and child in the nation - what is YOUR family's share?) stolen and given as forced "donations" - what about at least cutting 10 or 20 percent off the gargantuan porkfest of the new transportation act and using that to pay for this?

How to tame the fury of hurricanes
Christian Science Monitor
"Down in bayou country, the Mississippi River's spreading fingers have spent the past 7,000 years building, then deserting, old riverbanks as they course through the delta toward the Gulf of Mexico. Topped with crushed clamshells, many of these old banks have become virtually the only roads through the region. When New Orleans native Donald Boesch was younger, he'd drive along some of these roads, pull over, and see marsh grass stretching to the horizon. 'There would be little lakes in there,' he recalls. 'But from that vantage point, it looked for all the world like it was a huge sea of grass.'" (09/07/05)

See - if it isn't Allah or God, then it must be because we didn't worship Mother Earth properly! (Satire,folks)

Louisiana: Some bayou veterans aren't leaving
Boston Globe
"Hurricane Katrina failed to scare them off. Neither did the flooding, nor the official calls to evacuate, nor the looting, nor the street banditry. 'We old school. From the bayou,' said Ed Butler, 62, sitting on the steps of his row house, his street submerged in several feet of water. 'This ain't nothing.' This city has emptied out in the hurricane's wake. Almost 500,000 residents are suddenly gone, a once-vibrant town is silent, with soldiers and police seemingly the only ones left. But in the nooks and crannies of New Orleans, life goes on for several hundred people who, for reasons practical and eccentric, have decided to stay home, Katrina be damned. ''We are not going anywhere. I can stay here for months," Butler said. Across Marais Street, Kenneth Kinler, 50, also sitting on his front steps, heard Butler's boast, and screamed over, 'They call us the hardheaded, isn't that right?'" (09/06/05)

These people, for whatever reason, seem to have been prepared and are prepared to live without the "benefit" of a protective, "fatherly" government. Good for them. I'll bet few of them found themselves trapped in attics with the water rising to drown them, or left the bodies of their loved ones rotting on a sidewalk.

More Stupid Government Tricks

TennCare patients skip some drugs
Tennessean
"Some TennCare enrollees and those being cut from the program are finding they have no recourse but to skip some of the drugs they need to keep them well, pharmacists say. Customers with multiple health problems requiring perhaps a dozen or more drugs often are doing without some of their medications because of the cost, pharmacists said. They predict that these patients will end up in hospitals when their medical conditions worsen as a result of going without necessary drugs. 'The state is saving money, but it's at the expense of the health of patients,' said Phil Bradley, owner of Bradley Drug Co. on Charlotte Pike." [FND editor's note: Even if you object on the grounds that this is a tax-subsidized program, the long-term expenses that will likely ensue from this "one size fits none" measure could easily derail any short-term savings! - SAT] (09/06/05)

It is truly sad to see so many people seeking to justify the continuance or reestablishment of socialist programs like this. And for people to take the word of those who have profited for decades from these programs that the "people" are suffering.

Republicans halt death-tax discussion
Washington Times
"Senate Republicans agreed yesterday to postpone consideration of the bill to fully and permanently repeal the death tax that had been scheduled for this week. Majority Leader Bill Frist promised to return to the bill as soon as possible but wanted to clear the legislative decks this week -- lawmakers' first after a month's recess -- to consider what could be done to help deal with the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. 'The Senate will move from its previously scheduled agenda for Tuesday, September 6, and instead consider a resolution expressing the sympathy of the Senate for the victims of Hurricane Katrina,' he said yesterday. The decision by Frist comes in response to requests by Minority Leader Harry Reid and other Democrats who wanted the vote on the death-tax repeal to be delayed in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. 'It doesn't look right,' Reid [D-Nevada] said yesterday." (09/06/05)

Once more, essential business is being shunted aside for things that are NOT the Fed-Gov's responsibility, and for a false sense of compassion that looks good to the voters back home; and once more the GOP wimps out in the face of even the slightest opposition by its opponents.

Roberts confirmation hearings to begin Monday
CNN
"The Senate will begin confirmation hearings next Monday for John Roberts to be Supreme Court chief justice, one week after President Bush selected him to replace the late William H. Rehnquist as the 17th leader of the nation's highest court. Senate leaders made the announcement Tuesday as Rehnquist's body lay in repose across the street at the Supreme Court. Roberts, a former Rehnquist clerk, helped carry the flag-draped casket into the building for public viewing." (09/06/05)

Clearly Bush's strategy in a quick nomination of Roberts is doing what it intended - getting this onto the Senate's plate rather more quickly than normal.

Bush: List for second court vacancy "wide open"
Las Vegas Review-Journal
"President Bush said the list of possibilities for his second Supreme Court nomination was 'wide open' Tuesday as Senate Republicans urged him to consider a woman and Democrats pressed him to consult with them before making his next pick. The president said the Senate should concentrate on confirming U.S. Appeals Judge John Roberts to replace the late Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist before worrying about any other choices." (09/06/05)

If I weren't so cynical towards the FedGov, I'd suggest that lady from California: Mrs. Davis? Who appears to be a strict constructionist who happens to be a woman and black. Again, the President seems to be approaching this logically and staying away from anything to interfere with the current process.

California legislature OKs homosexual marriage bill
MSNBC
"The California Legislature on Tuesday became the first legislative body in the country to approve same-sex marriages, as gay-rights advocates overcame two earlier defeats in the Assembly. The 41-35 vote sends the bill to Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, who had no comment on the bill when it cleared the Senate last week. His office did not immediately respond late Tuesday to a call seeking comment." (09/06/05)

I do wonder just who the California Legislature thinks it was elected to represent, given that polls show 60% or more of California voters oppose this action? Are they so afraid o the courts and of certain political pressure groups that this is possible? I am reminded of the rubber-stamp of the Reichstag to Hitler's actions in the early 1930s.

Michigan: New proposal would limit eminent domain
Detroit Free Press
"State and local government would be barred from seizing private property for anything other than clearly defined public use under legislation and a proposed constitutional amendment slated for action Tuesday afternoon, state Senate leaders announced. Calling property rights 'one of the fundamental rights of a free society,' Senate Majority Leader Ken Sikkema said the proposals were needed following a U.S. Supreme Court decision earlier this year in which the court okayed the taking of private property in Connecticut and turning it over to a developer in order to bolster the local tax base." (09/06/05)

If it is such a fundamental right, then why leave in the "except for public use" clause? Colorado and other states already have such "explicit" clauses in their constitutions, and they aren't stopping the theft. So all Michigan's legis-gators are doing are playing word games.

Mideast Tarbabies

Iraq: Talabani says Saddam confessed to crimes
Las Vegas Review-Journal
"Iraq's president said Tuesday that Saddam Hussein had confessed to killings and other 'crimes' committed during his regime, including the massacre of thousands of Kurds in the late 1980s. President Jalal Talabani told Iraqi television that he had been informed by an investigating judge that 'he was able to extract confessions from Saddam's mouth' about crimes 'such as executions' which the ousted leader had personally ordered." (09/06/05)

Assuming this is true (and certainly Saddam's always given me the impression he is PROUD of these actions and considered himself fully legally and morally in the right - sick monster that he is), this should lead to a speedy trial. I would fully expect him to repeat this "confession" (which he would probably view as "proudly stating the obvious") in public court.

Iraq oil-for-food report points fingers
Houston Chronicle
"A probe of the Iraq oil-for-food program faults U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan, the Security Council and some United Nations member states for 'egregious lapses' that allowed corruption and incompetence to cripple the operation, according to a preface of the final conclusions. The Independent Inquiry Committee's report, to be published Wednesday, criticizes Annan and the U.N. Security Council for a failure of leadership in the overall management of the program, according to the preface, released today on the committee's Web site." (09/06/05)

News flash: UN corrupt! Next: Water flows downhill.

Report: Iran 5 years from nuke
CNN
"Iran, threatened with referral to the U.N. Security Council over its atomic ambitions, is still five years away from developing a nuclear weapons capability, a London-based think tank said on Tuesday. 'We estimate, if everything goes right, if they throw all their effort into solving their problems, they might be able to produce enough weapons-grade uranium for a single nuclear weapon within five years,' Gary Samore, editor of a new report, told BBC radio." (09/06/05)

Another of the vast and growing pile of "expert" reports claiming day is night, and night is day - and whom do you believe? Remembering Clarke's law (if an eminent and respected scientist tells you something is flat impossible, you know you are on the right track), I will take this report with a very large grain of salt - it probably means that they already have at least one warhead or bomb.

Nathan Barton, now hiding again in the vastness of the Black Hills, is trying to be a christian, libertarian, engineer, rabblerouser, and family man. The comments herein and choice of news stories to cover are his own, and not necessarily those of FND, RRND, any other organization, or TPOL or anyone else associated with them. News stories are taken from the FND/RRND digest published by the International Society for Individual Liberty, from leads provided by readers and friends, and from Nathan's own search of the news feed sources available in hardcopy, by radio and on-line. Grouchiness is par for the course. Be sure to visit my blog, Liberty's Outpost.

Special Feature! Add your signature to the NEW Declaration of Independence
By Robert Greenslade

Several people have asked about buying Gadsden Flags (the rattlesnake "Don't Tread on Me flags used by the June 23d Movement and other Property Rights Organizations: you can get them for $10.00 plus shipping here.


To Read previous Commentaries, go to the archives page and click onto the link for the day. The commentaries are linked from the daily front pages.


Your feedback is always welcome! Please use the form below. If you enter your email address, the author can respond to your comment. Not all feedback can be answered personally, of course, but you will find most of it on the Mailbag page. Please allow at least 48 hours for it to be published. Thanks for reading The Price of Liberty!

Please note: Information about readers is never given or sold to anyone for any purpose. Remember, however, that many people can read and recover anything posted to web sites or email unless it is carefully encrypted. MamaLiberty)

Whose values?

Visit the Rational Review News Digest

Links to Previous
Commentaries
are on the front page for each day. Check the archives page.

[Some article sources require registration, use this link)


Submit Feedback

Name: