Libertarian Commentary on The Day's News by Nathan A. Barton - Price of Liberty
01/08/09
Libertarian Commentary on The News
By Nathan A. Barton © 2005


Mission Statement
Revised 8.04.04
 
Editorial Policy Revised 3.19.04
 
See Reader's
Feedback
 
Reader's Forum
 
Looking for Health NEW
 
Commentary
on the News
 
Return to Home Page

August 11, 2005

We are supposed to be in the "dog days" of August, when little happens. But the in-box seems to fill up with news, anyway, and we have to keep in mind that even small events can have a big impact. We'll see some examples, today, in this news and commentary.

World War against the Islamicists

UK Bans Hizb ut-Tahrir
BBC News/Townhall News
British Prime Minister Tony Blair announced that his government would deport foreigners found to be "fostering hatred" and ban a Muslim radical group called Hizb ut-Tahrir. The group, whose name means "Party of Liberation," was founded in the 1950s in Jerusalem. Today, wrote Ariel Cohen in a 2003 study for the Heritage Foundation, Hizb "is a clandestine, cadre-operated, radical Islamist political organization that operates in 40 countries around the world, with headquarters apparently in London. Its proclaimed goal is jihad against America and the overthrow of existing political regimes and their replacement with a caliphate (khilafah in Arabic), a theocratic dictatorship based on the Shari'a (religious Islamic law)." Hizb says on its website it hopes to bring the Islamic nation "to her rightful place as the first state in the world, as she was in the past, when she governs the world according to the laws of Islam."

Clearly, in the US, this would be a violation of constitutional rights - but since the UK has no true constitution, the Blair regime can get away with it. Should they? Some more research is indicated, and the potential impact:

UK Ban strengthens Hizb ut Tahrir
Reuters
The radical Islamist group Hizb UT Tahrir said on Tuesday a ban on its British branch would strengthen its appeal to young Muslims disenchanted by what it called Western intolerance towards their faith. Abu Mamdouh Qutaishat, a leader of the party, said the British action, part of sweeping anti-terrorism measures after deadly London bombings, would make its followers more determined to advocate reviving an Islamic caliphate by nonviolent means.

Some quick research indicates that the English language version of their website (www.hizb-ut-tahrir.org/ ) does not indeed call for violent overthrow of western or "corrupt" regimes AT THIS TIME. However, Global Security as an interesting article that goes into some length. The US has not found evidence to declare it a terrorist group, but it is suspected of participating in an extensive bombing campaign in Tashkent in recent years. Both Russia and Germany have recently outlawed them as a terrorist group. My opinion: the UK (and others) are wrong to ban them. They have a right to speak and even organize, but I wouldn't want them as neighbors unless I knew I had enough firepower to defend myself against them, when the "Time" comes.

Mama's Note: Folks like these are hypocrites, screaming for "tolerance" and having absolutely none for anyone else themselves. Let them start to condemn the violence and work toward open cooperation. Then people might begin to give them the benefit of the doubt. I don't think it's going to do any good to "ban" them, or anyone else, but in a country where honest people are forcefully disarmed it's only a matter of time before there is real trouble. You can bet your boots that these Islamists are not unarmed!

Report: 9/11 hijackers ID'd in 1999
CBS News
"Sept. 11 ringleader Mohammed Atta and three other hijackers were identified by defense intelligence officials more than a year before the attacks, but information about possible al Qaeda connections never was sent to law enforcement, Rep. Curt Weldon said Tuesday. Weldon, vice chairman of the House Armed Services and Homeland Security committees, said the hijackers were identified in 1999 by a classified military intelligence unit known as 'Able Danger,' which determined they could be members of an al Qaeda cell. Weldon said that in September 2000 the unit recommended that its information on the hijackers be given to the FBI 'so they could bring that cell in and take out the terrorists,' Weldon said in an interview. However, Weldon said Defense Department lawyers rejected the recommendation because they said Atta and the others were in the country legally." (08/09/05)

One of the risks ANY free society faces is that "preventive justice" is not possible or desirable. It leaves us subject to greater dangers if someone does wish to cause us harm. This is one of those situations where it does no good to beat a dead horse, except to try and prevent the same stupidity from happening again. And it would have been a moot point - if any of the passengers had been armed instead of being disarmed in the "cause" of safety (assuming that the aircraft really were taken over by these people and that it was not some very deep conspiracy as more and more are claiming).

Mama's Note: Rehash of news that only reminds us of government stupidity.

Stupid People

Texas: Idiot arrested in airplane bombing hoax
Houston Chronicle
"For years, signs at airports around the country have warned that making jokes about bomb threats is a federal offense. Including a phone number only makes it easier to catch you, as a 20-year-old San Antonio man learned on Tuesday. FBI agents arrested Elias Jeremiah Cervantez, accusing him of writing a hoax bomb threat discovered Friday on a Southwest Airlines flight from Dallas to Houston. The note caused authorities to close Hobby Airport for about 20 minutes and grounded the aircraft for several hours while authorities investigated. 'We were just making dumb jokes,' said Cervantez's roommate Josh Michael Gonzales. He said in a telephone interview that the two thought, 'If somebody finds that, it's going to be funny.' As it was, a passenger found two notes. One had the phony bomb threat. The second, penned by Gonzales, had no threat -- only a smiley face and a message to call what turned out to be Gonzales' wireless phone number." (08/09/05)

I suppose requiring an IQ test, or a common sense test, wouldn't be possible before people like this are allowed to fly - or breed?

President Tandja: "The people of Niger look well fed ..."
Independent [UK]
"The little boy lies on the blanket at a relief centre wrapped in his own pain, lost to the world. The doctors are uncertain whether his life can be saved. He is one of 32,000 children the United Nations says is in danger of dying in Niger -- 'the number one neglected emergency in the world.' The Médecins Sans Frontières camp in Maradi is one of the busiest trying to cope with the unfolding catastrophe. There are many other victims there. Abdu Issafou, 15 months old, is suffering from acute diarrhoea and vomiting, diseases ravaging his young body left weak by malnutrition. His mother, Hadiza, weeps knowing the life of her son may be slipping away. But for Mamadou Tandja, sitting in the presidential palace in the capital, Niamey, it is a matter of 'crisis, what crisis?' 'The people of Niger look well fed, as you can see,' President Tandja says. All the talk of mass starvation is just 'foreign propaganda,' deception by relief agencies to obtain increased funding." (08/10/05)

Just when we think we in the US have the most stupid politicians money can buy.

Florida: Harris kicks off Senate campaign
St. Petersburg Times
"Nobody is going to outdo Katherine Harris on Katherine Harris makeup jokes. She made that clear Tuesday as she kicked off her campaign for U.S. Senate. Aside from promising 'to stand up for what's right, speak up for what's needed and rise up to get the job done,' she showed a self-effacing side that hometown fans ate up. 'What I really wanted to say is I only trail (incumbent Bill Nelson) by an eyelash, but I know what you guys would do to me,' joked Florida's former secretary of state, whose makeup became fodder for late night comics suggesting she overdid it. ... Harris declared her candidacy in early June, but her higher-profile campaign kickoff Tuesday appeared likely to quell efforts by Republican leaders to recruit an alternative Republican to take on incumbent Democratic Sen. Nelson. 'My job is done,' said Gov. Jeb Bush, who had unsuccessfully encouraged Republican state House Speaker Allan Bense to run even after Harris announced her candidacy. ... The National Republican Senatorial Committee is still talking to prospective Republican candidates, spokesman Brian Nick said Tuesday, but 'the window's closing.'" (08/09/05)

Talk about a target-rich environment: Florida has much higher than its fair share of stupid people. Lots of grist for Leno and company.

Georgia: Runaway bride mows lawn of government building
Fox News
"Runaway bride Jennifer Wilbanks mowed the lawn of a government building Tuesday as part of her court-ordered community service for lying to police after she ran off days before her scheduled wedding. Wearing an orange community service vest, a ballcap that said 'Life is good' and running shoes, Wilbanks seemed upbeat as she pushed a powered mower by a swarm of reporters and photographers. She briefly spoke when the mower's engine died in some tall grass. 'I'm doing well,' said Wilbanks, who has been undergoing mental health treatment. She admitted with a laugh that it had been a long time since she had mowed a lawn." (08/09/05)

In this case, the woman is paying the price of her stupidity: fortunately, no one had the gall to put her in jail and leave it up to the taxpayers to pay twice for her silly escapade. It isn't directly restitution, but "community service" beats fines and jail time for impressing on people the folly of their actions.

Canada: Straight men to marry
Ananova [UK]
"Two heterosexual Canadian men are to tie the knot to enjoy the tax benefits of being a married couple. Bill Dalrymple, 56, and best friend Bryan Pinn, 65, are taking advantage of Canada's new same-sex marriage legislation. 'I think it's a hoot,' Mr. Pinn told the Ottawa Sun. But the two, both previously married to women, insist there is a serious issue behind the stunt. 'There are significant tax implications that we don't think the government has thought through,' Mr. Pinn said. Mr. Dalrymple has been to see a lawyer already and there are no laws in marriage that define sexual preference." (08/08/05)

Unintended consequences? As Pinn said, it's a hoot.

Our Right to Defend Ourselves

Missouri: Salvage yard owner says he shot intruder
Kansas City Channel News
"Early Monday morning, a prowler was shot at A/3 Auto Tire and Wheel at 14th Street and Jackson Avenue -- and it wasn't police doing the firing. Paul, who asked that his last name not be used, said he couldn't sleep, so he came into work before dawn. 'I couldn't sleep because they keep stealing from me down there,' Paul said. 'If you're going to catch a thief, you have to act like one.' Instead of using the front gate, Paul climbed through a hole in his chain link fence. 'I went in like an old rat, just the same way those scumbags do,' Paul said. He soon found himself face to face with a man who was stealing from Paul's truck. He told KMBC he fired two warning shots into the air. '(The man) raised his hand up like he was going to hit me with one of the wrenches he stole out of my truck,' Paul said. The owner said that's when he fired two shots at the prowler -- once in the buttocks, the other in the arm." (08/08/05)

It doesn't say whether the hole was a new one or not - but it must be a new one if this guy is this dedicated to protecting his property.

Wisconsin: Area police stand for victim disarmament
Green Bay Press Gazette
"Some local law enforcement agencies are joining the Wisconsin Anti Violence Effort against a new concealed-carry act even before it's introduced. 'We are not antigun, anti-hunter or anti-NRA,' Green Bay Police Chief Craig Van Schyndle said at a press event held by WAVE at the Brown County Courthouse in Green Bay. 'This is an officer-safety issue and a community-safety issue. Green Bay, Appleton and Brown County are very safe communities, and concealed carry is a very dangerous proposition.'" (08/09/05)

They must be "anti-common sense" since concealed carry has been shown, time after time, to make communities safer still. Of course, we are talking the German-Nordic sheep state here, AND a state where the legislature has shown, time after time, that they believe acts of the legislature trump physical laws.

Texas: Ex-husband shot breaking through door
News Journal
"A 41-year-old man was shot to death early Sunday morning when he tried to break into the house where his ex-wife was staying with another man. Chief Deputy Miguel Larsen of the Titus County Sheriff's Office said officers found William Joe Baker lying on the front porch of Marty Crocker's residence on County Road 3435. According to a news release, Baker went to Crocker's home seeking his ex-wife, Anita Baker, 41. Crocker called the police, saying that William Baker was hitting the door and threatening to kill them. ... She and William Baker had been divorced almost a year, he said. While deputies were en route to the scene, Larsen said the emergency call was disconnected. Crocker called back moments later and told the dispatcher he had fired his semiautomatic rifle multiple times through the door, hitting Baker in the head." (08/08/05)

As bad as divorce is, it was none of his business. At the same time, I don't think she's done much better: this guy fired his semi-auto RIFLE multiple times through the door? A little training would be in order, and remind me to stay away from CR 3435!

Mama's Note: Look for this kind of thing to get worse and worse. The divorce rate is climbing and the current insane state of injustice has these men desperate and very angry. They are stripped of their property, earnings, children and any incentive at all to live in many cases. Take a look at this article, and some others on Ed Ward's archives. It's a national crisis and shame. Of course the violence can't be condoned, but neither can the injustices.

Washington: Officials back shooting range
Everett Daily Herald
"The owners of the Kenmore Gun Range property shouldn't be pressured into building hundreds of homes or condos, despite occupying 80 tempting acres of mostly vacant urban land, county officials said. Instead, it should remain an oasis for shooters surrounded by hundreds of homes on culs-de-sac in the county's urban core between Bothell and Brier. 'We promised we would be an outdoor recreation area forever,' said Vic Alvarez, a board member of Wildlife Committee of Washington, which owns the gun club. 'We provide a very necessary service not only to law enforcement and the military but to the community.'" (08/09/05)

The safety zone for a firing range should NEVER be considered "vacant land." I am glad, especially in Washington State (well-known for its love of theft-by-government), that there are officials who recognize this fact.

Kansas: Man, 71, says he shot burglar
Kansas City Star [registration required, or use login "info@news-digests.com/news-digests"]
"A 71-year-old Leavenworth man told police Monday that he shot a man who had broken into his home. The homeowner, who lives in the 1100 block of Pawnee Street, told police that he heard someone breaking into his home about 8 a.m. Monday .... The homeowner told police he fired shots at the man, who fled out the door. ... Kitchens said the Leavenworth County attorney would determine whether charges would be filed against the suspect. Prosecutors could also consider charges against the homeowner, Kitchens said, although the decision to use deadly force could be justified if the suspect was committing an aggravated burglary." (08/09/05)

In this case, the "suspect" is the housebreaker, not the home-defender. Good for the authorities of Leavenworth County. Of course, with the constellation of prisons (including the infamous military Disciplinary Barracks) in the county, this kind of common sense is needed. It is a nice place to live, but does have its risks.

Mama's Note: Wait a minute! All burglary is aggravating. How's he supposed to know what an "aggravated burglary" is in the first place. I sure don't. And why should it make any difference? They don't sound so "common sense" to me if there is any chance the homeowner will be charged with anything.

Government-Ruined, Theft-Funded Schools

Arizona: Laws cut school control at local level
Arizona Republic
"There was a time when your locally elected school board members had the last word on what and how your child was taught, how the district's money was spent, who graduated from high school, how teachers were trained, and who was hired or fired. Not any more. Arizona built its education system on 'local control.' Once powerful and independent governing boards firmly directed each of the state's more than 220 districts and were answerable mainly to district voters. But new federal and state laws swept in a massive reform movement and swept away much of that power and independence." (08/09/05)

Ignoring wisdom, common sense, and constitutional issues - and stealing the future of their children as well as their school lands and buildings and money.

Imploding Demoncrats, Exploding GOP'pers

Dean: Democrats must take offensive
Raleigh News & Observer
"Howard Dean gives Republicans credit for one thing: They have put the Democrats on the defensive and forced them to fight on their turf. That, he said, is about to change. ... Dean detailed his 50-state strategy to hire and finance from national coffers organizers in every state, saying that the party is on track to have organizers in every state by the end of the year. 'Vote by vote, precinct by precinct, door by door, year by year and election by election, we will take this country back for the people who built it,' he said." (08/09/05)

Well, they are pretty offensive, right now! More seriously, I still think that the GOP, especially in Congress, is still on the defensive - mentally, at least. If the Dems are having to rebuild their political grassroots, I suspect that they will find the same problem other activists have: people are giving up on electoral politics. And they will also have their faces rubbed into the fact that as far away from the national mood that the GOP is, the liberalism of the Democrats is still farther out - and only if they change will they find it possible to win again.

New York fell for her, but will US voters?
Christian Science Monitor
"To some voters, she is a ruthless Machiavelli-in-a-pantsuit who will do anything to resume residence at 1600 Pennsylvania Ave. To others, she is the brilliant and inspiring golden girl, poised to make history as America's first female president. Nearly all Americans have an opinion about Hillary Rodham Clinton, the junior senator from New York, and if she runs for president, as expected, she will begin her quest for the Democratic nomination well ahead of her rivals. On one point, still with 2-1/2 years to go before the first caucuses or primaries, political analysts agree: The nomination is hers to lose." (08/09/05)

CSM doing its usual commentary-as-news garbage: with Dean and Clinton in charge, the future is a disaster, but whether it is for the Democratic Party or the whole nation and world is still a question to be answered.

Mama's Note: It's hard to imagine that anyone could forget that this woman trashed and robbed the White House, after all those years of dirty tricks and lies. Some people will fall for anything, won't they?

Poll: Giuliani first choice, Frist 4th for GOP nomination
Tennessean
"Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist is in the middle of the pack of prospective 2008 Republican presidential candidates, according to a USA Today-CNN-Gallup Poll released yesterday. Frist, from Tennessee, has not said whether he will seek the White House in '08, but he has visited the early primary state of New Hampshire twice this year, and he and his allies are not discouraging speculation that he will run. With the first primary and caucus still more than two years off, the new poll -- taken Friday through Sunday -- provides only a rough barometer of a race no one has officially entered. Among registered Republicans polled, Frist was fourth of nine potential candidates measured, with 9%. ... Former New York Mayor Rudolph Giuliani was first, with 27%, followed by Arizona Sen. John McCain -- who lost to President Bush in the 2000 primaries -- with 24%. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice was third with 19%." (08/09/05)

Gee, what a set of choices! No wonder so many people think Hillary has a chance!

Imperial Courts, Worldwide

Pro-choice group hits Roberts in ad
Washington Times
"NARAL Pro-Choice America [Monday] began airing nationwide a TV advertisement criticizing federal Judge John G. Roberts Jr.'s involvement in an abortion case. The spot, part of a $500,000 campaign, is the first major advertisement that is explicitly critical of President Bush's Supreme Court nominee, accusing him of aiding an abortion-clinic bomber. 'We believe in a culture of personal freedom and personal responsibility,' said NARAL President Nancy Keenan. 'As an advocacy organization, it is our job to let the American people know that John Roberts' record demonstrates hostility toward these core values.' Republican National Committee Chairman Ken Mehlman called the ad 'false and outrageous.'" (08/09/05)

Just proving that NARAL is as hypocritical as anyone in government.

Roberts deferential to other branches
Washington Times
"Supreme Court nominee John G. Roberts Jr. consistently deferred to the legislative and executive branches in his two years on the nation's second-most powerful federal court. Judge Roberts was sworn in to the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia in 2003 and has been involved in nearly 200 decisions. Almost all of those were unanimous findings by a three-judge panel. But when the judges split, Judge Roberts sided with the court's conservatives only slightly more often than with its liberals. And a review of his 48 written opinions by The Washington Times shows a judge who gives the executive branch wide latitude, as long as officials don't act capriciously, and one who takes seriously the directions given to judges by Congress." [FND editor's note: The question would seem to lie in how clearly Roberts defines "act capriciously!" - SAT] (08/09/05)

I thought that there was no "paper trail" for this guy: 200 decisions doesn't seem much like "no trail." This would seem to indicate why Bush would choose him, if this evaluation is accurate. Of course, I'd not count on that!

UK: Judges say new drink laws are lunacy
Guardian [UK]
"Town and city centres will be turned into the equivalent of violent drink-fuelled Mediterranean holiday hotspots if the government insists on liberalising Britain's licensing laws, senior judges and police officers warned yesterday. A report from senior judges in England and Wales told the Home Office to expect a big increase in rapes, domestic violence and serious assaults as a result of the new law allowing 24-hour drinking, which comes into force in November." (08/10/05)

"The sky is falling," or would it be "The dyke is leaking" or "The wolf is attacking," instead? It may well be that the opposite will happen: that people will drink themselves into a stupor, and not tank up at "Last Call" then go out and take out their frustrations on someone else because they can't get a drink.

General News

UK: License plates get chipped
Wired
"The British government is preparing to test new high-tech license plates containing microchips capable of transmitting unique vehicle identification numbers and other data to readers more than 300 feet away. Officials in the United States say they'll be closely watching the British trial as they contemplate initiating their own tests of the plates, which incorporate radio frequency identification, or RFID, tags to make vehicles electronically trackable. ... Active RFID is already enjoying limited use on U.S. roadways. Under a new program, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security is issuing RFID tags to foreign freight and passenger vehicles as they enter the country." (08/09/05)

US highways are using it for toll roads, or by private contractors to keep track of their own vehicles, NOT for police surveillance. If you thought identity theft was bad now.

Massachusetts: Bill seeks to restrict eminent domain
Boston Globe
"A bipartisan group of state lawmakers, spurred by a recent US Supreme Court ruling, is pushing a measure designed to curb the power of Massachusetts cities and towns to take private property to make way for private economic development. The move will face strong resistance from local leaders and agencies such as the Boston Redevelopment Authority, who fear that restricting the power of eminent domain will hamper their efforts to rejuvenate rundown neighborhoods. In Massachusetts, cities and towns can generally force the sale of private property to promote economic development if they can show that the development will benefit the public through job creation or expansion of the tax base." (08/09/05)

We've talked about other efforts like this - MA is one of the worst in the nation for this kind of theft by government, and it will be an uphill battle. Ending Eminent Domain is the only way to stop it: restrictions will just have too many loopholes to do any good.

New Mexico: Lab error spreads nuclear material
San Francisco Chronicle
"The apparent mishandling of a potentially hazardous radioactive substance by an employee of the University of California-run Los Alamos National Laboratory has resulted in contamination of sites in four states, according to a report released Monday. Traces of the substance have been found in homes in Colorado and Kansas that the Los Alamos employee visited, his own home in New Mexico, and also at the Pennsylvania laboratory where the employee apparently shipped a contaminated package via FedEx. Los Alamos doctors are monitoring the health of the employee and five lab colleagues who might have been contaminated by the substance, radioactive americium-241. So far, none show ill effects, lab officials said Monday." (08/09/05)

I consider this to be more of a scare than a serious problem, but it is clear that people are panicking over it. Yes, it is just what we expect from the government or the contractors of government. And yes, hazardous materials are serious business, and it is important to handle them properly. But that said, we are not going to have people dying of radiation poisoning or getting cancer faster in any degree that can be traced precisely to this failure.

Google says Cnet googled too far
San Francisco Chronicle
"Googling someone -- a prospective job candidate, a teenage crush, your son's soccer coach -- is a commonplace ritual of modern life. But the search engine company evidently doesn't appreciate a taste of its own medicine. Google has blackballed online technology news service Cnet News.com for googling Eric Schmidt, CEO of the Mountain View company, and including some personal information about him in a story last month. Google told a Cnet editor that it will not speak with Cnet reporters until August 2006, according to Jai Singh, editor in chief of Cnet News.com in San Francisco. 'We published a story that recounted how we found information on the (Google) CEO in a public forum using their service,' Singh said. 'They had issue with the fact that they felt it was private information and our point is it was public information obtained through public channels using Google search.'" (08/09/05)

It seems to me that Herr Schmidt was hoist by his own petard. And I've scant sympathy for Google, which censors such words as "freedom" for Chinese users.

US identifies remains of Vietnam MIAs
Seattle Post-Intelligencer
"The remains of 12 servicemen listed as missing in action during the Vietnam War have been identified and are returning home, 37 years after they died in a fierce battle near the Laos-Vietnam border, the Defense Department announced Tuesday. The 11 Marines and one Army soldier are the largest group of MIAs identified since the war, according to the military." (08/09/05)

Comfort, if scant comfort, to their loved ones. And still far too many MIA still left from the last three or four wars.

Nathan Barton is a libertarian engineer and family man writing from the Black Hills. The views in this commentary are his own, and not necessarily those of FND, RRND, or TPOL or anyone else associated with them. News stories are taken from the FND/RRND digest published by the International Society for Individual Liberty, from leads provided by readers and friends, and from Nathan's own search of the news feed sources available by radio and on-line. Be sure to visit my blog, Liberty's Outpost.

Special Feature! Add your signature to the NEW Declaration of Independence
By Robert Greenslade


To Read previous Commentaries, go to the archives page and click onto the link for the day. The commentaries are linked from the daily front pages.


Your feedback is always welcome! Please use the form below. If you enter your email address, the author can respond to your comment. Not all feedback can be answered personally, of course, but you will find most of it on the Mailbag page. Please allow at least 48 hours for it to be published. Thanks for reading The Price of Liberty!

Please note: Information about readers is never given or sold to anyone for any purpose. Remember, however, that many people can read and recover anything posted to web sites or email unless it is carefully encrypted. MamaLiberty)

Visit the Rational Review News Digest

Links to Previous
Commentaries
are on the front page for each day. Check the archives page.

[Some article sources require registration, or use login "info@news-digests.com/ news-digests"] (or use this link)


Submit Feedback

Name: